The economic rebound last quarter turned out to be slower than first thought, one of the reasons unemployment is likely to stay high this year.
The economy grew at a 3 percent annual rate from January to March, the Commerce Department said Thursday. That was slightly weaker than an initial estimate of 3.2 percent a month ago. The new reading, based on more complete information, also fell short of economists' forecast for stronger growth of 3.4 percent.
The reasons for the small downgrade: Consumers spent less than first estimated. Same goes for business spending on equipment and software. And, the nation's trade deficit was a bigger drag on economic activity.
Stuart Hoffman, chief economist with PNC Financial Services Group, calls it a half-speed recovery.
"We are creating jobs; jobs were up in the first quarter," he says. "But the unemployment rate was very sticky at nearly 10 percent. ... You need growth even faster than this to take a big bite out of the unemployment problem."
Economists say the GDP would have to positively sizzle at 5 percent to drive down the unemployment rate even a percentage point. But Hoffman says if economic growth chugs along at 3 percent to 3.5 percent this year, he expects as many as 1.5 million new jobs to be created.
New Weekly Jobless Claims Drop
In a separate report, the Labor Department said Thursday that the number of newly laid-off workers filing claims for unemployment benefits fell by 14,000 to 460,000 last week. The decline came after claims had risen by a revised 28,000 in the previous week, the largest gain in three months.
The latest level of claims is slightly higher than it was at the start of the year. That shows the nation's workers are still facing tough times, even though the overall economy is growing again.
The four-week average for new jobless claims edged up to 456,500 last week. The government said the number of people receiving benefits fell by 49,000 to 4.64 million for the week ending May 15. However, that figure does not include unemployed workers who have exhausted their regular 26 weeks of benefits. An additional 5.3 million workers are receiving extended benefits for the week ending May 8.
Growth Still Too Weak To Boost Jobs
During normal times, growth in the 3 percent range would be considered healthy. But the country is coming out of the longest and deepest recession since the Great Depression. So economic growth needs to be a lot stronger — two or three times the current pace — to make a big dent in the nation's 9.9 percent unemployment rate.
After the last severe recession in the early 1980s, GDP grew at rates of 7 to 9 percent for five straight quarters, and the unemployment rate dropped from 10.8 to 7.2 percent in 18 months.
Economists don't see that happening this year. In fact, growth in the first quarter was slower than at the end of last year. The economy grew at 5.6 percent in the final three months of 2009. But economists had predicted that growth spurt would fade.
GDP measures the values of all goods and services — from machines to manicures — produced within the United States. It is the best measure of the country's economic health.
The National Association for Business Economics predicts moderate economic quarterly growth in the 3 percent range through the rest of this year.
The outlook means employers won't feel comfortable about bulking up their work forces.
Consumer Spending Strongest In Three Years
Consumers increased spending at a 3.5 percent pace in the first three months of this year. Even though that was a notch less than the 3.6 percent growth rate initially estimated, it still marked the strongest spending in three years. Consumer spending was feeble in the final three months of last year, rising at only a 1.6 percent pace.
Although consumers are now helping to support the recovery, they aren't showing signs of spending lavishly as they usually do in the early stages of economic rebounds. High unemployment, stagnant wages and tight credit are just some of the forces restraining spending.
Business spending on equipment and software grew at a 12.7 percent pace in the first quarter, weaker than the 13.4 percent rate first reported. The pace of spending is still strong, but the fact that the new estimate was a bit less robust than initially thought was a factor in the quarter's downgrade.
So was the trade deficit. It shaved 0.66 percentage point off GDP, versus 0.61 percentage point in the government's first estimate. Exports actually rose even more than initially thought. But so did imports, and that widened the trade gap.
Businesses are now faced with new worries about how Europe's debt crisis will affect their sales. Exporters, for example, are expecting to see slower sales from Europe, which could constrain hiring. Wall Street turmoil in response to Europe's woes could make those who have retirement savings invested in the stock market spend less.
Housing and commercial real-estate are major weak spots for the economy. Builders cut spending in each by double digits in the first quarter.
Christina Romer, head of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, said in Paris on Thursday that it would be a mistake for the U.S. to rapidly wind down fiscal stimulus measures to bring down the deficit.
Additional measures such as fiscal relief for state and local governments and extension of emergency benefits for the long-term unemployed are still needed, she said. Those are ways to inject more oxygen into the "nascent economic recovery," she said.