Ex-Cop Faces Trial In Racially Charged Murder Case

  • Playlist
  • Download
  • Embed
    <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Mehserle at hearing

Former Bay Area Transit Authority officer Johannes Mehserle, shown at a court hearing in January, faces a second-degree murder charge for fatally shooting Oscar Grant on New Year's Day 2009 at a BART station in Oakland, Calif. Cathleen Allison/AP hide caption

toggle caption Cathleen Allison/AP

Opening arguments begin Thursday in the trial of a former San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit police officer who is accused of murdering an unarmed man on New Year's Day 2009.

The killing was captured on video and then widely posted on the Internet. It stirred racial tensions in Oakland, Calif. — the police officer is white and the victim was black. The trial is being held in Los Angeles after a judge ruled that publicity in the case made a fair trial in Oakland impossible.

There is no doubt that Johannes Mehserle shot and killed Oscar Grant. The trial, then, hinges on the circumstances of the shooting. The jury will see several cell phone videos shot from different angles of the night Grant was killed on a crowded train platform in Oakland.

Grant and two companions had been pulled off of a train after reports of a fight. In one video, Grant is seen sitting against a wall and appears to have his hands up. Then the police pick him up and push him face-first to the platform. One officer has his knee on Grant's back. There appears to be a momentary struggle. Then Mehserle, a two-year veteran, stands, draws his weapon and fires.

The victim, Grant, was a 22-year-old supermarket worker and father. Days after his death, protesters rioted in downtown Oakland. At a far more peaceful prayer vigil last week, Grant was hailed as a martyr.

The Victim's Record

Grant was also a parolee, who had been arrested five times in his young life and spent nearly two years in jail. Just before his death, he had been looking for help to change his life and went to talk with his uncle, Cephus Johnson.

"His conversation centered around the fact that, you know, I basically have made some bad choices. He talked about how much he loved his daughter and begin to take a look at the future and what he wanted to do for himself and his family. And I can say I believe he was more or less scared straight," Johnson says.

The judge in the trial, Robert Perry, has ruled that the jury can hear about Grant's criminal record, particularly one incident in 2006 when he resisted arrest after a traffic stop.

Darryl Stallworth, an Oakland defense attorney and former prosecutor who has been following the case, says the judge made the right call.

"And sometimes, in my experience, what the victim is doing or what the victim may have done in similar situations can help a jury sometimes understand why the defendant behaved in the way that he did," Stallworth says.

BART shooting anniversary protest. i

In January, demonstrators carried protest signs outside of the Criminal Justice Center in Los Angeles, where Mehserle was attending a hearing. The trial begins Thursday. Nick Ut/AP hide caption

toggle caption Nick Ut/AP
BART shooting anniversary protest.

In January, demonstrators carried protest signs outside of the Criminal Justice Center in Los Angeles, where Mehserle was attending a hearing. The trial begins Thursday.

Nick Ut/AP

On Defense

What the defense will try to do is make the then-27-year-old Mehserle a sympathetic figure, says Stallworth.

"We have to really understand that jurors, for the most part, if you want to be real honest, are going to consider police officers sort of heroic," he says.

Not a lot is known about Mehserle. He grew up in the Napa wine country and was reportedly an average student at three different high schools. After the Grant shooting, he refused to speak with Bay Area Rapid Transit investigators and resigned from his job.

"We also don't know what Officer Mehserle saw when Oscar Grant was on his belly on the ground, trying to get up, trying to avoid being handcuffed," says Stephen Meister, a Los Angeles defense attorney. "We don't know if Officer Mehserle perceived the presence of a weapon. Before they were able to get him cuffed and thoroughly searched, Officer Mehserle did not know whether Oscar Grant was armed or not."

According to his defense attorney, Michael Rains, Mehserle did not intend to draw his gun and shoot Grant, but rather he meant to pull out his newly issued taser.

Mehserle faces a second-degree murder charge.

It is not known whether Mehserle will ever take the stand in his own defense. The trial is expected to last at least one month.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from