The Sweet, Social Legacy Of Cadbury Chocolate

Cadbury Workers (1932) i i

Workers at the Cadbury chocolate factory in Bournville, England, join together chocolate Easter egg halves. Cadbury’s cream-filled eggs were first introduced in 1923. Fox Photos/Hulton Archive hide caption

itoggle caption Fox Photos/Hulton Archive
Cadbury Workers (1932)

Workers at the Cadbury chocolate factory in Bournville, England, join together chocolate Easter egg halves. Cadbury’s cream-filled eggs were first introduced in 1923.

Fox Photos/Hulton Archive

Deborah Cadbury was raised on chocolate. As a child an enormous box of Cadbury chocolate would arrive on her doorstep every year, courtesy of a favorite uncle. It was one of the perks of being related to one of the world’s most famous chocolate dynasties.

Cadbury explores the roots of her family’s business and its February 2010 purchase by American food conglomerate Kraft Foods in her new book Chocolate Wars: The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World's Greatest Chocolate Makers.

The Magic Of Cocoa

The Cadbury business began in the early 19th century, when cocoa was very different from what today's consumers are used to. No one had yet figured out how to separate the cocoa butter from the rest of the cocoa bean so cocoa often came in the form of a bitter, oily beverage that was marketed as a health drink.

Chocolate Wars Cover
Chocolate Wars: The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World's Greatest Chocolate Makers
By Deborah Cadbury
Hardcover, 384 pages
PublicAffairs
List price: $27.95

Read An Excerpt

"Early products had lentils or pearl barley mixed in — all sorts of products to mop up the fat," Cadbury tells NPR's Mary Louise Kelly. "It was a little while before we realized the magic that there was to get out of the cocoa bean."

Cadbury says cocoa's origins as a health drink contributed to the creation of her family's business.

"The original founders were Quakers, and they were trying to come up with something that they thought would be a nutritious alternative to alcohol, which was the ruin of many poor families," Cadbury says. "They were trying to come up with a business idea that was actually going to help people, and cocoa was this amazing new commodity and they thought they could make a business out of this nutritious drink."

'Quaker Capitalism'

Like many other major English chocolate firms, Cadbury was a Quaker family enterprise and one whose business aims were fused with idealism, a concept Cadbury calls "Quaker capitalism." For companies like Cadbury, the point of having a business wasn't to make a lot of money and then become a philanthropist. The goal was to benefit others right from the start.

"As soon as they were able," Cadbury says, "they were doing things like raising the wages of their workforce, introducing Saturdays off, introducing pensions, introducing unemployment benefits and sickness benefits, and even free doctors, free dentists and vitamin pills for staff."

Deborah Cadbury i i

Deborah Cadbury is a writer and award-winning documentary producer for the BBC. Jerry Bauer hide caption

itoggle caption Jerry Bauer
Deborah Cadbury

Deborah Cadbury is a writer and award-winning documentary producer for the BBC.

Jerry Bauer

Then they started to think beyond their own workforce, pursuing the idea that business should benefit the entire community. That concept led to the creation of Quaker Utopian towns like Bournville, a model village just south of Birmingham, England. There, the Cadbury family hoped to improve the lives of their workers and their families by ameliorating the living and working conditions of the working class.

It's those intentions that Cadbury hopes won't change as the company enters a new phase under Kraft ownership.

"The challenge for Kraft," she says, "is to see what aspects of Cadbury Quaker history can be incorporated into the business model to make sure that Kraft really uses the business as a force for good."

Excerpt: 'Chocolate Wars'

Chocolate Wars Cover
Chocolate Wars: The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World's Greatest Chocolate Makers
By Deborah Cadbury
Hardcover, 384 pages
PublicAffairs
List price: $27.95

As a young child, the knowledge that a branch of my family had built a chocolate factory filled me with wonder. What sort of charmed life did such a possibility offer to my relatives? Each Christmas I had an insight when the most enormous case arrived from my uncle, Michael Cadbury, containing a large supply of mouth-watering chocolates. Even more memorable was the trip I made in the early 1960s to see how the chocolate was made. Opening the door to the factory at Bournville in Birmingham, the sight that greeted me was magical.

To child’s eyes it was as though I had entered a cavernous interior that belonged to some benign, orderly and highly productive wizard who had somehow saturated the very air with a chocolate aroma. My uncle and parents raised their voices against the whirr of machinery. But I did not hear them. All I could see was chocolate. It was all around me in every stage of the process. There was melting molten chocolate bubbling in vats towering above me, vats so huge that they had ladders running up their sides. Chocolate rivers flowed on a number of swiftly moving conveyers through gaps in the wall to mysterious interiors beyond. Solid chocolate shaped in a myriad of exciting confections travelled in neat soldierly processions towards the wrapping department. Such a miracle of clockwork precision and sensual extravagance was hard to take in. Even more puzzling to my young mind: how did this chocolate feast, which brought a whole new meaning to the idea of greed, fit with religion? For even though I did not yet understand the connection, I did know that the chocolate works were in some inexplicable way, intimately connected with a little known religious movement known as the Quakers. Was all this the hand of God?

My own father had left the Quaker movement just before the Second World War. He wanted, as he put it, to ‘join the fight against Hitler’ and this was not compatible with Quaker pacifism. I was brought up in the Church of England and as a child, when joining cousins for Quaker meetings, I felt on the outside looking in on a strange, even mystical tradition. Long silences endured in bare rooms, stripped of any sign that might excite the senses, where grownups contemplated the surrounding void, was incomprehensible to young eyes. Equally incomprehensible: how did my rich, chocolate relatives acquire that admirable restraint, that air of wholesome frugality. Even family picnics had a way of turning into long and chilly route marches, raindrops trickling down your back. The wealth and austerity seemed oddly incongruous. Did the one make the other? Cheerful homilies from my father along the lines of ‘every mickle makes a muckle’ and ‘look after the pennies and the pounds will look after themselves’ did not appear to supply the answer. Even a five year old knew this was not the key to creating a chocolate factory.

A generation elapsed before I decided to retrace my steps up Bournville Lane. This time it was personal. I wanted to delve into the Bournville and family archives to uncover the whole story. Turning the corner in the lane in the autumn of 2007, my heart skipped a beat as I was taken back to that day when my father and uncle, both now much missed, had taken me round the factory. To my surprise, the chocolate works seemed even larger than I remembered. Imposing red brick blocks stood beside the neatly mowed lawn of the cricket pitch with Bournville village and green nestled behind. At this time, Cadburys was the largest confectioner in the world and the only independent British chocolate enterprise to survive from the 19th century. I wanted to understand the journey that took my deeply religious Quaker forebears from peddling their tins of cocoa from a pony and trap around Birmingham to this Titan like company that reached across the globe.

The story began five generations ago, when a farsighted forbear, Richard Tapper Cadbury, a draper in Birmingham early in the 19th century, sent his youngest son, John, to London to study a new tropical commodity that was attracting interest among the colonial brokers of Mincing Lane: cocoa. Was it something to eat or drink? Richard Tapper saw it pre-eminently as a nutritious non-alcoholic drink in a world that relied on gin to wash away its troubles. Never could my abstemiously inclined forebear have guessed what fortunes were entwined with the humble cocoa bean, although it seemed full of promise: a touch of the exotic.

His grandsons, George and Richard Cadbury, turned a struggling business into a chocolate empire in one generation. In the process, they took on their Quaker friends and rivals, Joseph Rowntree in York, and Francis Fry and his nephew Joseph in Bristol. The Cadbury, Fry and Rowntree dynasties were built on values that form a striking contrast with business ethics today. Their approach to the creation of wealth was governed by an entire code of practice developed over generations since the Civil War by their Quaker elders and set out at yearly meetings and in Quaker books of discipline. This 19th-century ‘Quaker capitalism’ was far removed from the excesses of the world’s recent financial crisis, in which business leaders have seen no harm in  pocketing huge personal profits while their companies collapse.

For the Quaker capitalists of the 19th century, the idea that wealth creation was for personal gain only would have been offensive. Wealth creation was for the benefit of the workers, the local community, and society at large, as well as the entrepreneurs themselves. Reckless or irresponsible debt was also seen as shameful. Quaker directives ensured that no man should ‘launch into trading and worldly business beyond what they can manage honourably… so that they can keep their words with all men.’ Even advertising was dismissed as dishonest, mere ‘puffery’: the quality of the product mattered far more than the message. Men like Joseph Rowntree and George Cadbury built chocolate empires at the same time as writing groundbreaking papers on poverty, publishing authoritative studies of the Bible or campaigning for a multitude of heart-rending human rights in a world that seems straight out of Dickens. Puritanical hard work and sober austerity, with the senses in watchful restraint, were the guiding principles. Even art, literature and theatre were dismissed as too great an indulgence.

Whilst it is easy to dismiss such values as antiquated notions that governed business life at a time before Darwin’s ideas had taken root, Quaker capitalism proved extraordinary successful and its puritanical work ethic unleashed a staggering worldly wealth. In the early 19th century, around 4,000 Quaker families ran 74 Quaker British banks and over 200 Quaker companies. As they came to grips with making money, these austere men of God helped to shape the course of the industrial revolution and the commercial world today.

The chocolate factories of George and Richard Cadbury and Joseph Rowntree inspired men in America such as the ‘King of Caramel,’ Milton Hershey, who took philanthropy to a new all-American scale with the creation of the utopian town of Hershey in the cornfields of Pennsylvania. But with the growth of global trade, the rise of international rivals and the emergence of a new tough breed of entrepreneurs in the 20th century unshackled by religious conviction - men such as Frank and Forrest Mars - the chocolate wars that followed gradually eroded the values that shaped Quaker capitalism. Some Quaker firms did not survive the struggle and those that did had to lose their puritan roots. In the process, ownership of the businesses passed from private Quaker dynasties to public shareholders. Little by little the implications of the transition from Quaker capitalism to shareholder capitalism began to take shape in the form of huge confectionery conglomerates that straddle the corporate world today. The story of four generations of Cadbury brothers and their rivals highlights different phases of this process. The Cadbury chocolate business came of age during the expansion of the British Empire in the Victorian era. It peaked a century later during the post Cold War era as the world’s largest confectionery company – only to be consumed in turn by global forces in the new millennium.

The end for an independent Cadbury began with an innocuous voice mail message. In late August 2009 Irene Rosenfeld, chairman of America’s largest food company, Kraft Foods, requested a meeting with the Cadbury chairman, Roger Carr. Kraft Foods made a £10.2 billion bid for the British chocolate company. The bid turned hostile. Five months later, after a long and bitter siege played out in the glare of the media, Kraft won over Cadbury’s shareholders. Britain’s last big chocolate enterprise fell to the American giant after 186 years of independence in one of the largest acquisitions in British corporate history.

Today the world’s two largest giant food companies – the Swiss firm, Nestle and America’s Kraft – circle the globe, feeding humanity’s sweet tooth. The Americans spend £8 billion on chocolate; the British £3.5 billion and more than one in four in America and Britain are obese. Yet these two behemoths are locked in a race to maintain market share in the developed world, while also selling their western confections and other processed foods to emerging markets in the developing world. Somewhere along the way the 400-year-old English Puritanical ideal of self-denial and the Quaker vision of creating wholesome nourishment for a hungry and impoverished workforce have disappeared. Also vanished are a myriad of independent chocolate confectionery firms. In Britain alone: Mackintosh of Halifax and Rowntree of York are now owned by Nestlé, while Terry of York, Fry of Bristol and Cadbury have become a division of Kraft.

My search was to explore how this happened. I wanted to unearth the true story of the original Quaker chocolate pioneers and the religious values that shaped their business decisions, and see how these values differed from today.

Excerpted from Chocolate Wars: The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World’s Greatest Chocolate Makers by Deborah Cadbury. Excerpted by arrangement with PublicAffairs, a member of The Perseus Books Group. Copyright 2010.

Books Featured In This Story

Chocolate Wars

The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World's Greatest Chocolate Makers

by Deborah Cadbury

Hardcover, 348 pages | purchase

Purchase Featured Book

Title
Chocolate Wars
Subtitle
The 150-Year Rivalry Between the World's Greatest Chocolate Makers
Author
Deborah Cadbury

Your purchase helps support NPR Programming. How?

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.