Familiar Scenes of Violence Arise in Mogadishu

Somalis carry their belongings on donkey carts as they leave their neighborhoods i i

hide captionSomalis carry their belongings on donkey carts as they leave their neighborhoods in an effort to flee from fighting in Mogadishu, Somalia, on Nov. 10.

Mustafa Abdi/AFP/Getty Images
Somalis carry their belongings on donkey carts as they leave their neighborhoods

Somalis carry their belongings on donkey carts as they leave their neighborhoods in an effort to flee from fighting in Mogadishu, Somalia, on Nov. 10.

Mustafa Abdi/AFP/Getty Images

The Situation in Somalia

Somalia hasn't had an internationally recognized government since 1991. Read about the country's struggles and relations with the United States during this period.

Somali women carry some of their belongings on their heads i i

hide captionSomali women carry some of their belongings on their heads as they leave the village of Wargedow, 30 kilometers west of Somalia's capital Mogadishu, on Nov. 5.

Abdurashid Abdulle Abikar/AFP/Getty Images
Somali women carry some of their belongings on their heads

Somali women carry some of their belongings on their heads as they leave the village of Wargedow, 30 kilometers west of Somalia's capital Mogadishu, on Nov. 5.

Abdurashid Abdulle Abikar/AFP/Getty Images
A wounded Somali man travels to a local hospital i i

hide captionA wounded Somali man travels to a local hospital in Mogadishu on October 17.

AFP/Getty Images
A wounded Somali man travels to a local hospital

A wounded Somali man travels to a local hospital in Mogadishu on October 17.

AFP/Getty Images

Last week, a painfully familiar scene unfolded in Mogadishu, Somalia. Somalis triumphantly dragged the body of a dead Ethiopian soldier in the street.

The scene recalled what has become known as the Blackhawk Down incident of 1993, when the bodies of dead U.S. troops met the same fate.

The circumstances of last week's scene are significantly different, but the outcome so far appears just as wretched. Somalia again has become almost too torn to save the living, or respect the dead.

Mogadishu Clears Out

Giuseppe Angelini is one of the heads of the European Commission's Humanitarian Aid arm. He and a colleague are just back to Nairobi from Mogadishu, a city so divided and violent that fewer and fewer people are willing to risk their lives to report the story.

The story that he and other humanitarian aid groups tell resists hard facts and figures — because in Somalia, the situation is as fluid as running water. But from where the crow flies, the city is emptying out.

"We saw in Mogadishu still yesterday people organized in mini buses trying to leave the city," Angelini says. "Difficult to identify them in most cases, who they are. Of the people we talked to, there was no single person we talked to who had not a personal story to tell."

International aid groups estimate that since the beginning of the year two-thirds of Mogadishu's population has cleared out of the city — including about 90,000 people a little over a week ago and an additional 45,000 last weekend.

This is because the fight for control of Somalia's capital is now fully inflamed.

The combined forces of the country's transitional government and Ethiopian troops are in a shoot out with remnants of the Islamist movement that once controlled the city. Those loyal to the Islamic Courts Union, as it was known, are believed to have killed an Ethiopian soldier last week and dragged his body in the street.

Caught in the Crossfire

The violence that has followed has left bodies strewn on lonely thoroughfares and townspeople scrambling to avoid the crossfire. But so many get caught.

The European Commission's Aadrian Sullivan brought back the pictures to prove it. But he tells the story better than the pictures do.

"Here we have a young boy. He's four years old. Just a moment. He was playing with four other friends. A landmine went off. Four of them died. He's the only survivor. All the flesh on the leg has been blown away. He's damaged his eye. But he's going to survive. Such is the situation there," Sullivan says.

All the people heading out of town are squeezing in with family or klan members in other communities, and are at the mercy of international aid groups.

Graham Davidson directs operations for Worldvision in Somalia. His organization is not represented in Mogadishu — they are in central and southern Somalia. But apparently Mogadishu is coming to them ... by the busload.

"Many of the people that have arrived from the current fighting in Mogadishu are currently staying with relatives ... relatives who already have issues with lack of food, water and sanitation — and compounds the issues we're dealing with," Davidson says. "Also, there are many people perhaps heading toward the Kenyan border."

This border has been closed for months, while the transitional government and Ethiopian forces concentrate on winning Mogadishu at any cost. Graham says the Islamic Courts Union, or ICU, may be making gains elsewhere.

"The fact is there are small pockets of the ICU that are popping up from place to place," he says.

Angelini of the European Commission calls what he saw over the weekend "The Last Episode of a Long Story." But if that is so, then Somalia may be a story without an ending. Just a long fade to black.

Unified Leadership Fails to Take Hold in Somalia

A Somali boy wheels his older brother's body i i

hide captionA Somali boy helps wheel his older brother's body in a cart in Mogadishu, Somalia.

Mustafa Abdi/AFP/Getty Images
A Somali boy wheels his older brother's body

A Somali boy helps wheel his older brother's body in a cart in Mogadishu, Somalia.

Mustafa Abdi/AFP/Getty Images

Somalis Flee Mogadishu

Thousands of Somalis are fleeing Mogadishu and surrounding areas to escape violence. Read about the country's latest struggles.

Map of Somalia i i
Alice Kreit, NPR
Map of Somalia
Alice Kreit, NPR
Former Somalian Prime Minister Ali Mohamed Gedi

hide captionFormer Somalian Prime Minister Ali Mohamed Gedi.

Jose Cendon/AFP/Getty Images
Somali families lead their donkey-laden carts i i

hide captionSomali families lead their donkey-laden carts away from their homes in the lower Shabelle region of Somalia on Nov. 5.

Abdurashid Abdulle Abikar/AFP/Getty Images
Somali families lead their donkey-laden carts

Somali families lead their donkey-laden carts away from their homes in the lower Shabelle region of Somalia on Nov. 5.

Abdurashid Abdulle Abikar/AFP/Getty Images
Somali President Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed

hide captionSomali President Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed. Gedi and Yusuf come from rival clans and had feuded since the formation of the government.

Roberto Schmidt/AFP/Getty Images

The latest U.S. State Department travel warning for Somalia reads like the scenario for an improbable Hollywood action movie: those who venture to the anarchic country in the Horn of Africa run the risk of being caught up in clan warfare, kidnapping, murder, al-Qaida-linked terrorism and piracy in the Indian Ocean.

The United States has a big stake in Somalia's future. The thrust of American policy has been to try to keep the country from becoming a sanctuary for terrorists, but critics say the United States undermined this policy by supporting corrupt warlords instead of Islamic moderates.

Somalia hasn't had an internationally recognized government since 1991, when local warlords overthrew the long-time military dictator, Mohammed Siad Barre. A three-year old transitional government controls less than half the country. Several other Somali regions have declared autonomy. At least one, Somaliland, is demanding total independence.

Experts are divided as to whether a recent shift in leadership in Somalia will help.

Response to the Situation

International humanitarian groups say the misery in Somalia now rivals that of Darfur, Sudan. Despite the numbers of displaced people and the lack of food, medicine and shelter, the United Nations won't risk sending peacekeepers into the violence-torn country, let alone a team to assess the humanitarian needs there. U.S. officials say the country could become a sanctuary for terrorists.

The U.S. is widely accused of making the situation worse. Critics say that, after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, the Bush administration focused too narrowly on a secretive war against terrorist groups, violating international agreements and human rights in the process.

American involvement in Somalia goes back to the Cold War, when the United States and the former Soviet Union backed different factions in the region. But it was the U.S. military operation in the country, from 1992 to 1994, that established many current American attitudes toward Somalia. The action film "Blackhawk Down" is the sum of most American's knowledge of the conflict.

The country was in the midst of a civil war that disrupted farming and food distribution and triggered a famine. The international community responded with food and other relief supplies, but security was so poor that most of the food was stolen by clan-based militias, which often traded it for more weapons.

In 1992, President George H.W. Bush sent troops to Mogadishu to protect the shipments. The following summer, 18 American soldiers and hundreds of Somalis were killed in a battle with Somali militiamen.

The United States withdrew its troops in 1994, and paid only cursory attention to Somalia for the next several years. That was a mistake, according to Jennifer Cooke, a co-director of the Africa program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. Cooke says U.S. relations with Somalia focused too narrowly on counterterrorism, and missed opportunities to engage with moderate Islamic groups.

"At that point there was a [U.S.] tendency to paint them all with the Islamist jihadi brush," says Cooke.

Opposing the Islamic Courts Union

The U.S. opposed the Islamic Courts Union, an umbrella group that included both moderates and Muslim extremists, and instead backed an unpopular coalition of Mogadishu militia leaders.

"We ended up being associated with some pretty unsavory folks," says Ken Menkhaus, a professor of political science at Davidson College.

In June of 2006, the Islamic Courts Union defeated the warlords and brought a measure of security to the capital, Mogadishu. Menkhaus says it was then that authority for U.S. policy in the country shifted from the CIA to the State Department, which tried but failed to get the parties to negotiate a government of national unity.

Cooke says Somali perceptions of the United States were further damaged by American backing of Ethiopia, which sent sent in troops to drive out the Islamic Courts Union in December. The United States supported the invasion with airstrikes against fleeing ICU leaders and al-Qaida suspects, she says, leading both Somalis and Ethiopians to believe that the United States also approved of brutal and heavy-handed tactics by Ethiopian ground troops.

Backing the TFG

Although the Bush administration also is backing Somalia's Transitional Federal Government, or TFG, Cooke says it has thus far failed to push the government to open itself up to participation by other factions.

She says the recent resignation of Prime Minister Ali Mohamed Gedi could provide an opportunity to make the transitional government work better. Gedi and Somali President Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed, who comes from a rival clan, have feuded almost since the government was formed.

Menkhaus has little confidence that a new prime minister will help.

"The word I'm getting from some Somali opposition leaders," he says, "is that they're not going to support any candidate. They don't want to see the TFG succeed."

Menkhaus says Somalia is an example of a backward trend in U.S. foreign policy, a return to Cold War days when the United States was willing to ally with corrupt and anti-democratic groups if they professed a willingness to fight communism.

"Right now," says Menkhaus, "Ethiopia needs to hear from us. The way they're fighting is actually compromising us."

In the meantime, Somalis are fleeing their homes by the thousands. Aid groups, such as CARE, say continued fighting could lead to another catastrophic famine, like the one that killed hundreds of thousands of people in the early 1990s.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: