Several States Abandon Electronic Voting for Paper

close up voting

Florida voters cast ballots with touch-screen voting machines Jan. 14, the first day of early voting in the 2008 presidential primary at the Stephen P. Clark Center in Miami. Joe Raedle/Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Joe Raedle/Getty Images

States Overhaul Voting Systems

Several key, early primary states are abandoning their electronic voting machines for paper ballots. Read about those efforts.

other voting

Florida voters cast their ballots with touch-screen voting machines for the Jan. 29 primary, but many counties are turning back to paper ballots for the November election. Joe Raedle/Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Joe Raedle/Getty Images

Only a few primaries and caucuses have been held so far this year, but questions are already being raised about the reliability of voting equipment.

In New Hampshire, two candidates have asked for a recount of optically scanned ballots. And in South Carolina last weekend, some voting machines didn't start up on time. Both these incidents have activists worried, especially with more than half the states preparing to vote in the next two weeks.

Teams of counters this past week have been sorting through ballots cast in New Hampshire's Jan. 8 primary. Then-Democratic candidate Dennis Kucinich asked for a recount because of suspicions that optically scanned ballots unfairly favored Hillary Clinton. Barack Obama did better in precincts where the ballots were counted by hand.

The partial recount, which ended Wednesday, has uncovered no major problems in the original tally. But it did illustrate one thing — there were actual ballots to count.

"The good news is that in New Hampshire, there's a verifiable voting system," says New Jersey Democratic congressman Rush Holt. Holt has been trying for years to get a bill passed that would require some form of paper ballots on all voting machines. He has just introduced "emergency" legislation to give federal funds to any jurisdiction that changes to a paper-backed system by November.

"Unless we act, you can be sure there will be some doubt in some counties or states this year about the federal election results," he says.

As if on cue, South Carolina's Republican presidential primary last weekend raised new concerns. In Horry County, which includes Myrtle Beach, election workers were unable to get about 80 percent of the touch-screen machines running on time. Many voters had to use emergency paper ballots. And some were told to come back later when the paper ballots ran out.

This set off a buzz in the blogosphere, where suspicions about electronic voting are strong. But Chris Whitmire, a spokesman for the State Election Commission, says the problems were traced to people, not the equipment.

"Any voting system is dependent on its user following the proper operating procedures and, in this case, Horry County election officials missed a step," he says. That step was closing out tests performed on the machines before the elections, which left some test votes still recorded and any affected machine locked up.

"It won't let itself be opened on Election Day. And it's really a good thing. We don't want the voting machine to allow itself to be opened with votes already on it," he adds.

Whitmire says the problem was compounded when poll workers told voters to come back later in the day, even though they were supposed to let voters use any available piece of paper once the official ballots were gone. He says the state is trying to make sure these problems aren't repeated this coming Saturday, when Democrats hold their primary.

But the incident has led to fresh calls for the state to replace its voting machines, which are the same ones used in Sarasota County, Fla., in November 2006. That's when the machines were used in a contentious congressional race. There's still a dispute over why 18,000 ballots there showed no votes for either candidate.

Warren Stewart is with Verified Voting, a group pushing for paper ballots. He notes that several states voting Feb. 5 — such as Georgia and New Jersey — will also use voting machines without a paper backup.

"If there's questions, or a razor-thin margin, and there's some issues that need to be resolved, there's really no way to resolve them," he says.

But most election officials say they do have confidence in the machines — that voters find them easy to use and there's no evidence anyone has ever manipulated one to change a vote. In fact, many officials think touch-screen voting is more reliable than paper, which can be lost or damaged. But they're resigned to the fact that many voting systems will be changing in the coming year.

"The security issues, while they're important, I think have been kind of blown out of proportion," says Ken Baird, who oversees elections in Kings County, Calif. "But at the same time, if these systems have been portrayed so negatively that voters have no confidence in the systems, then it may be time to move on to something else."

So on Feb. 5, his county, like many others in California and elsewhere, is reluctantly abandoning electronic voting machines and returning to paper.

Key States' Plans to Overhaul Voting Systems

Electronic voting machines — once seen as the trendy gadgets of the election world — are losing some of their stature.

Several states are banishing them in time for November's elections, in favor of old-fashioned paper ballots that can be electronically scanned and counted.

"2006 was the high point for electronic machines. Clearly, their numbers are starting to come down," says Kimball Brace, president of Election Data Services, Inc., a consulting firm that works with state governments on such technical matters.

Touch-screen voting machines became popular after the 2000 presidential race between then-Gov. George W. Bush and Vice President Al Gore, when confusing punch-card paper ballots led to thousands of Florida votes being cast aside.

But electronic voting machines have also proved fallible, or at the very least, raised questions about their reliability. In 2006 in Sarasota, Fla., 18,000 ballots cast on touch-screen machines did not show any votes in a close congressional election. There's an ongoing debate about why this happened.

Brace estimates that 50 percent of all registered voters in the U.S. will use paper ballots this year — but not necessarily in time for the upcoming primaries in delegate-rich states.

Here's a glance at what some states are doing to overhaul their voting systems.

Florida: Several Florida counties are dumping their touch-screen voting machines in time for the Jan. 29 primary. Instead, residents will use machines known as optical scanners that will allow voters to fill in their ballots by hand and then feed them into electronic machines to scan their choices. The counties making the switch back to paper ballots are home to roughly half of Florida's registered voters. The entire state will have to use this system for the general election.

California: After a $1 million comprehensive review of the voting system, the secretary of state decided that several of California's electronic voting machines were faulty. Now, in time for the Feb. 5 primary, the secretary of state has ruled that all electronic voting machines must leave a paper trail.

New Jersey: New Jersey residents will vote with electronic voting machines in the Feb. 5 primary, much to the disappointment of some activists. Lawmakers originally wanted the state agency that oversees elections to retrofit all electronic machines with backup paper printouts, but the agency was not able to meet the lawmakers' deadline. Now, the deadline has been pushed back until June, which means the retrofitting should be complete in time for November's general election.

Ohio: Similar to California, the Ohio secretary of state also did a huge review of the state's voting systems. The 57 counties that use touch-screens must switch to optical scanners by the November election. According to the secretary of state's office, voters who feel uncomfortable with touch-screens have the right to ask for a paper ballot on primary day. Ohio has 88 voting counties in total.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.