Jonesing for Fries? Blame the Cave Men

French fries

Researchers believe there's an evolutionary reason why we gravitate toward unhealthy foods such as salty, fatty French fries. Edyta Pawtowska hide caption

itoggle caption Edyta Pawtowska

Why do we seem to relish salty, sweet, high-fat and fried foods? Scientists studying the biology of hunger say our cravings for the unhealthy may have a lot to do with evolution.

The Volumetrics Eating Plan

Dr. Barbara Rolls' Volumetrics concept aims to help people eat more while taking in fewer calories to control their weight. The key to this is eating foods with lower energy density.

Calculating Energy Density: To calculate the energy density of foods, divide the calories in one serving by its weight in grams. Rolls says foods with an energy density less than 1, such as fruits, vegetables and low-fat dairy products, should make up a large portion of the diet of people seeking to control their weight. Foods with an energy density of 1 to 2 — such as beans, fish, fat-free, skinless chicken and rice — are also good to eat. Foods with an energy density higher than 2 — such as ice cream and French fries — should be eaten in moderation.

Gary Beauchamp, director of Philadelphia's Monell Chemical Senses Center, which is dedicated to the study of taste, smell and chemical irritation, says our human ancestors were largely herbivores, and one of their primary concerns was consuming enough calories.

Recipes: Sample Menu

Rolls has written a book, The Volumetrics Eating Plan, with recipes that offer ample servings of a variety of foods. She shares recipes for a sample three-course meal below:

"Sweet things tend to be calorie-rich and tend to be high in vitamins in the real world," Beauchamp says. "Most or all plant-eating animals have evolved an ability to taste sweet compounds, particularly carbohydrates, and a liking for them."

Likewise, salt is a signal for nutrients such as sodium. As for fat, our cravings become less clear. Some studies suggest people like the buttery texture. Fat is also the richest source of calories. "One way to think about this is that people and animals learn to associate this feel with the feeling of calories in the gut — and that association is what makes these things so attractive," Beauchamp says. He speculates that fatty acids may also enhance the sweetness of sugar and the saltiness of salt.

Similarly, an aversion to bitter foods — including vegetables — may have evolved from the need for early humans to avoid poisonous plants, which often tasted bitter.

Controlling Weight by Eating More

Meanwhile, at the Laboratory for the Study of Human Ingestive Behavior at Pennsylvania State University, researchers led by nutritionist Barbara Rolls study environmental triggers for appetite.

Rolls' research suggests that people may overeat in part because of the desire for a variety of foods. In other words, a person who's filled up on pizza may still find room for dessert.

"In our abundant society, where we have a huge variety of very calorie-dense foods that taste really good and have a lot of textures, we can keep eating way beyond where we should stop," Rolls says.

On a day-day basis, Rolls says, people tend to eat the same volume of food — but not necessarily the same number of calories. Her lab has been studying how energy or calorie density — that is, how many calories are in a given weight of food — affect satiety and weight. She says studies have found that people don't notice when their portions are increased — but they will eat more in response.

Despite these factors, Rolls says there is hope for success. Her studies suggest the key to weight control is in choosing foods that make you feel full with fewer calories. She calls this idea Volumetrics.

Take a casserole, for example. You can lower its calorie or energy density not only by using less cheese and reduced-fat milk, but by bulking the casserole up with other foods such as vegetables, which are packed with water and fiber but not calories. Adding fruits and vegetables to most dishes will lower their overall energy density, allowing you to eat more while taking in fewer calories.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.