NPR logo Excerpt: 'Becoming Justice Blackmun'

Summer Reading: Nonfiction

Excerpt: 'Becoming Justice Blackmun'

Cover image from Becoming Justice Blackmun hide caption

toggle caption

Political writer Alan Greenblatt says Linda Greenhouse, the celebrated court reporter for The New York Times, has written an account rooted in the human tale of the friendship and estrangement of Justice Harry Blackmun and Chief Justice Warren Burger.

More Recommendations

Get more nonfiction suggestions from writer Alan Greenblatt.

Excerpt from Becoming Justice Blackmun

Planned Parenthood v. Casey was argued on April 22, 1992. As in the Webster case three years earlier, it was not clear from the discussion at the conference whether Roe v. Wade itself was really on the table. But while there was uncertainty as to the details, Blackmun knew he would be writing a dissent.

Rehnquist circulated a twenty-seven-page draft majority opinion on May 27. "Wow! Pretty extreme!" Blackmun wrote in the margin of the first page. All the Pennsylvania law's provisions were upheld. Further, Rehnquist said the Court had been "mistaken in Roe when it classified a woman's decision to terminate her pregnancy as a 'fundamental right.' "

Then, suddenly, everything changed. Two days later, a handwritten note arrived from Anthony Kennedy. "Dear Harry, I need to see you as soon as you have a few free moments. I want to tell you about some developments in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, and at least part of what I say should come as welcome news."

When the two met the following day, Kennedy revealed that he, O'Connor, and Souter had been meeting privately and were jointly drafting an opinion that, far from overruling Roe, would save it-not in its details, but in its essence. The constitutional right to abortion would be preserved.

From the book Becoming Justice Blackmun by Linda Greenhouse. All rights reserved. Excerpted with permission from the publisher.

Books Featured In This Story

Becoming Justice Blackmun

Harry Blackmun's Supreme Court Journey

by Linda Greenhouse

Hardcover, 268 pages |


Buy Featured Book

Becoming Justice Blackmun
Harry Blackmun's Supreme Court Journey
Linda Greenhouse

Your purchase helps support NPR programming. How?