NPR logo

Red Cross Chief Announces Resignation

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Red Cross Chief Announces Resignation


Red Cross Chief Announces Resignation

Red Cross Chief Announces Resignation

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

American Red Cross President Marsha Evans announces she is stepping down from her post, effective at the end of December. During her tenure, the charity faced criticism over its response to Hurricane Katrina. Evans characterizes her departure as a long-planned retirement, though others at the agency cite problems with communication and coordination.


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Michele Norris.


And I'm Melissa Block.

There's been a shakeup at the American Red Cross. President and CEO Marsha Evans resigned today after facing criticism of the Red Cross response to Hurricane Katrina. Evans took over in 2002, a year after the September 11th attacks. The group was severely criticized then for how it handled money raised for 9/11 victims. The Red Cross promised more openness and accountability, but Hurricane Katrina raised new questions about the group's effectiveness. NPR's Howard Berkes reports.

HOWARD BERKES reporting:

Marsha Evans is a retired Navy rear admiral who led the Girl Scouts before taking the helm at the American Red Cross. She became president and CEO when the nation's biggest charity was reeling from its response to the September 11th attacks. The Red Cross collected more than a billion dollars for 9/11 victims, but set aside 200 million for other disasters. Under Evans, the Red Cross pledged more transparency and began to rebuild its reputation. Then came Hurricane Katrina.

Unidentified Man: How many of you have had trouble with the American Red Cross?

(Soundbite of crowd response)

BERKES: A month after Katrina, evacuees at this forum in Houma, Louisiana, had plenty of complaints. Janis Dilliad was frustrated trying to register for Red Cross help.

Ms. JANIS DILLIAD: You can't get through unless you use a cell phone. You sit there eight hours before you get through. You get through, you sit on there three to five hours on hold. Where do we turn?

BERKES: All across the Gulf Coast, from Houston to Houma to Hancock County, Mississippi, some people complained about little or no Red Cross help, especially in non-white neighborhoods and rural areas. This happened despite an exclusive congressional mandate to provide disaster relief. Dee Lumpkin is the deputy director of the emergency management agency in Hancock County, which faced Katrina's most powerful winds and deepest floodwater.

Ms. DEE LUMPKIN (Deputy Director, Emergency Management Agency, Hancock County): You know, we asked for supply kits to be sent right after the storm. We never received them. We did finally receive some supplies from them just a few weeks ago, and I mean, we're--What?--four months into the storm now?

BERKES: Hancock County officials say they also begged for food, shelters and volunteers and waited 12 days for a response. But none of this has anything to do with Marsha Evans' resignation. That's according to Jack McGuire, her interim replacement, who refers to Evans by her nickname.

Mr. JACK McGUIRE (Interim CEO, American Red Cross): The board actually was very pleased with Marty's leadership during Katrina, and we were pleased with the organization's response to Katrina.

BERKES: Pleased because the Red Cross mobilized 200,000 volunteers and $2 billion in relief efforts, helping millions of Katrina victims. The board sought Marsha Evans' resignation, McGuire says, due to internal communication and coordination problems. NPR left messages on Evans' cell phone today, but she hasn't returned them. McGuire adds that addressing the Katrina failures is his top priority as interim CEO. But he doesn't expect major changes in Red Cross operations.

Mr. McGUIRE: Now I don't anticipate any change in that core mission, nor have I been asked by the board to consider any change in that core mission.

BERKES: Congress may have something to say about that. Today a House subcommittee focused on the Red Cross hurricane response. Subcommittee Chairman Jim Ramstad of Minnesota noted the change in Red Cross leadership.

Representative JIM RAMSTAD (Republican, Minnesota): I believe the coming transition at the American Red Cross offers an opportunity for Red Cross management to respond to the concerns that have been raised and will be discussed here today.

BERKES: And Republican Jim McCrery of Louisiana wondered about a key part of the Red Cross mission.

Representative JIM McCRERY (Republican, Louisiana): After witnessing the Red Cross' struggles during Katrina and Rita, I question whether it's prudent for Congress to place such great responsibility in the hands of one organization.

BERKES: The Red Cross says it has already launched an effort to learn from its Katrina shortcomings. Howard Berkes, NPR News.

Copyright © 2005 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Wildfire Response Redemptive for Red Cross

Wildfire Response Redemptive for Red Cross

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

The American Red Cross was widely criticized for its poor response to victims of Hurricane Katrina. But it's been a different story in Southern California, where supplies and assistance arrived in abundance early on.

The Red Cross has a charter from Congress to provide relief to disaster victims. Poor communication and bureaucratic issues highlighted by its Katrina response were targeted in a major re-organization that is still under way.

Now, the wildfires are its first big test post-Katrina.

By Monday evening — the first day of the fire evacuation — the Red Cross had five shelters open in the San Diego area. Eventually, it had opened 14 shelters. But those didn't include the area's largest shelter — Qualcomm Stadium, which housed 10,000 evacuees.

That was opened by the city of Chula Vista, south of San Diego, which had to set up its own shelter.

"When the city called for assistance to other agencies that would normally be able to provide assistance, that assistance was not available," Chula Vista Mayor Cheryl Cox said.

Vincent Mudd, the chairman of the San Diego and Imperial County Red Cross, told NPR member station KPBS noted the scope of the evacuation order.

"No one anticipated that this would be something that evacuated over 650,000 Californians," Mudd said.

"In the first day and the second day, we ... were beyond the limit of what we could all do, and we still had to do more," he added.

The local chapter had just 2,000 cots on hand for people to sleep on. But that's where the post-Katrina reorganization plan kicked in.

There are now regional Red Cross supply centers instead of a central location. Within 48 hours, 10,000 additional cots were trucked from the regional warehouse in Reno.

Also, the Red Cross used to be pretty possessive of its supplies. When other agencies asked to share, they were turned down. This time, the Red Cross gave 1,000 cots and 10,000 blankets to the Qualcomm shelter.