Final Call: Dems Take House, GOP Keeps Senate

Fictional Journalist Borat

Many foreign journalists are watching this election closely. hide caption

itoggle caption
Ronald Reagan Campaign Button

In 1986, a popular Republican president couldn't keep the Senate in GOP hands. hide caption

itoggle caption
A button reads "No Newts."

Eight years ago today, a rebellion in GOP ranks following disappointing election results forces House Speaker Newt Gingrich to eschew another leadership bid. hide caption

itoggle caption

With one day to Election Day, Ken Rudin offers his final call for the House: Democrats win 23 seats to capture control with a 225-seat majority. hide caption

Full House Forecast
itoggle caption

It's been said from the outset that the voters are angry about the war, the economy and the direction of the nation. And yet, there is so much uncertainty about what the electorate intends to do on Tuesday.

This election has been compared to 1994 — the last time Congress switched parties — and there are similarities. We knew '94 was going to be a Republican year, just as we suspect this to be a Democratic year. But few really saw in advance the extent of the GOP tidal wave that swept Democrats out of control in both chambers in '94, with a pickup of 52 seats in the House and eight in the Senate. The task for the Dems to return the favor this year is not as great; they need a net gain of 15 in the House and six in the Senate.

Watching President Bush campaign in the final days in the decidedly red states of Kansas and Nebraska, you would think such goals are attainable. If Jim Ryun, who was re-elected in Kansas' 2nd District by 15 points in 2004, needs a visit from the president to boost his chances, or if western Nebraska, which hasn't elected a Democrat to the House since 1958, needs a presidential visit, then perhaps a sea change is in store for us on Nov. 7.

At the same time, polls seem to indicate that the Republican Party has narrowed the gap in the past week or so, that some candidates who were badly trailing just six or seven days ago are fighting back. They point to the Montana Senate race, to name just one, where the GOP candidate — in this case, incumbent Conrad Burns — has pulled even in the polls.

So what will happen?

The House seems to be an easier call. It's hard to see a scenario where the Democrats don't win a majority. The only question is by how much. As we say before every election, watch the early states. Polls in both Kentucky and Indiana close by 7 p.m. ET. If the vulnerable GOP incumbents in those states — Chris Chocola, John Hostettler and Mike Sodrel in Indiana, and Anne Northup, Geoff Davis and perhaps Ron Lewis in Kentucky — all go down to defeat, you know it's going to be a very long night for the once Grand Old Party. Not long after come states like Ohio. Four GOP-held seats are at risk in the Buckeye State: Steve Chabot in the 1st Congressional District, Jean Schmidt in the 2nd, Deborah Pryce in the 15th, and the open 18th, where Bob Ney (R), caught in the Jack Abramoff scandal, resigned last week before the House could vote to expel him. Democrats could find themselves more than half way to their majority before the 8 p.m. hour.

There's less of a consensus as to what happens with the Senate. Democrats are all but assured of ending the careers of Sens. Rick Santorum (PA) and Mike DeWine (OH). Lincoln Chafee (RI) has been teetering on the edge and could fall in the bluest of blue states. That's three. Burns in Montana, unless he really is making a comeback, would be four. Democrats seem to have the upper hand in New Jersey, while Republicans seem to be pulling away in Tennessee. That leaves Virginia, where Jim Webb (D) and the mouth of Sen. George Allen (R) have imperiled the GOP hold; and Missouri, where the battle between Sen. Jim Talent (R) and Democratic challenger Claire McCaskill appears to be dead even. Control of the Senate will be decided here.

Picks in every Senate, House and gubernatorial race follow. But here are some other things to think about:

Will Any Democratic Seat Fall? As I outlined in the Oct. 18 column, even in big Democratic years — such as 1982, 1974, 1964 and 1958 — Democratic incumbents in the House still managed to go down to defeat. This year may be different. Right now I don't see a single Dem seat in either the House or Senate that the Republicans win. The GOP still has hope in the N.J. Senate race, and two House seats in Georgia — held by Democrats Jim Marshall (8th CD) and John Barrow (12th) — are anything but safe. So keep your eyes on them. By the way, the last time the Democrats had a big year in the House without a single Dem incumbent going down was in 1948. They had a net gain of 76 seats, and lost only two seats, but both were in districts where their incumbent was not running.

What Effect Will Bush's Campaigning Have? The president certainly has the ability to fire up the GOP base, but ultimately he doesn't make much of a difference. A good yardstick is 1986, when President Reagan was quite popular and yet his campaigning didn't keep the Republicans from losing eight seats and control of the Senate. President Bush's numbers don't come near to Reagan's.

One for the Record Books? The worst showing by a New York Republican Senate candidate in a two-way race is the 31 percent garnered by Bob McMillan against Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D) in 1988. In a two-way N.Y. governor's race, it's the 32 percent Andrew O'Rourke got in his 1986 challenge to Gov. Mario Cuomo (D). Let's see if 2006 Senate nominee John Spencer or gubernatorial nominee John Faso will fall below those totals. In Connecticut, GOP nominee Alan Schlesinger may get the lowest percentage ever by a major-party Senate candidate in the state. Thomas Dodd, the Democratic incumbent running as an independent in 1970, got 24.5 percent of the vote that year in his third-place finish. Schlesinger may get half that.

Now, the calls.

SENATE PREDICTION: Democratic net gain of four, but GOP maintains control.

Thirty-three seats are up: 17 Democratic, 15 Republican, one Independent. Let's first dispense with the ones that have never been especially competitive:

Republican seats (six): Richard Lugar (IN), Olympia Snowe (ME), Trent Lott (MS), Kay Bailey Hutchison (TX), Orrin Hatch (UT), Craig Thomas (WY).

Democratic seats (10): Dianne Feinstein (CA), Tom Carper (DE), Bill Nelson (FL), Daniel Akaka (HI), Edward Kennedy (MA), Jeff Bingaman (NM), Hillary Clinton (NY), Kent Conrad (ND), Robert Byrd (WV), Herb Kohl (WI).

Here are the calls for the remaining 18 (incumbent in italics, calls in bold):

ARIZONA: Jon Kyl (R) vs. Jim Pederson (D) — KYL

CONNECTICUT: Joe Lieberman (I) vs. Ned Lamont (D) vs. Alan Schlesinger (R) — LIEBERMAN

MARYLAND (open D): Ben Cardin (D) vs. Michael Steele (R) — CARDIN

MICHIGAN: Debbie Stabenow (D) vs. Mike Bouchard (R) — STABENOW

MINNESOTA (open D): Amy Klobuchar (D) vs. Mark Kennedy (R) — KLOBUCHAR

MISSOURI: Jim Talent (R) vs. Claire McCaskill (D) — TALENT

MONTANA: Conrad Burns (R) vs. Jon Tester (D) — TESTER (Dem pickup)

NEBRASKA: Ben Nelson (D) vs. Pete Ricketts (R) — NELSON

NEVADA: John Ensign (R) vs. Jack Carter (D) — ENSIGN

NEW JERSEY: Bob Menendez (D) vs. Tom Kean Jr. (R) — MENENDEZ

OHIO: Mike DeWine (R) vs. Sherrod Brown (D) — BROWN (Dem pickup)

PENNSYLVANIA: Rick Santorum (R) vs. Bob Casey Jr. (D) — CASEY (Dem pickup)

RHODE ISLAND: Lincoln Chafee (R) vs. Sheldon Whitehouse (D) — WHITEHOUSE (Dem pickup)

TENNESSEE (open R): Bob Corker (R) vs. Harold Ford Jr. (D) — CORKER

VERMONT (open I): Bernie Sanders (I) vs. Rich Tarrant (R) — SANDERS

VIRGINIA: George Allen (R) vs. Jim Webb (D) — ALLEN

WASHINGTON: Maria Cantwell (D) vs. Mike McGavick (R) — CANTWELL

HOUSE PREDICTION: Democrats take House, with a net gain of 24 (including a pickup in Vermont).

Currently, it's 229 Republicans, 201 Democrats, one Independent. Four seats are vacant (three Republican, one Democrat). For purposes of what's at stake, I'm going to add these four to the totals. Thus, I'm using these numbers: 232 Republican-held seats, 202 Democratic, one Independent. A look at the most competitive House races (incumbent in italics, call in bold):

ARIZONA

1st CD: Rick Renzi (R) vs. Ellen Simon (D) — RENZI

5th CD: J.D. Hayworth (R) vs. Harry Mitchell (D) — HAYWORTH

8th District (open R): Randy Graf (R) vs. Gabrielle Giffords (D) — GIFFORDS (Dem pickup)

CALIFORNIA

4th CD: John Doolittle (R) vs. Charlie Brown (D) — DOOLITTLE

11th CD: Richard Pombo (R) vs. Jerry McNerney (D) — POMBO

50th CD: Brian Bilbray (R) vs. Francine Busby (D) — BILBRAY

COLORADO

4th CD: Marilyn Musgrave (R) vs. Angie Paccione (D) — MUSGRAVE

7th District (open R) : Rick O'Donnell (R) vs. Ed Perlmutter (D) — PERLMUTTER (Dem pickup)

CONNECTICUT

2nd CD: Rob Simmons (R) vs. Joe Courtney (D) — SIMMONS

4th CD: Chris Shays (R) vs. Diane Farrell (D) — FARRELL (Dem pickup)

5th CD: Nancy Johnson (R) vs. Chris Murphy (D) — JOHNSON

FLORIDA

13th District (open R): Vern Buchanan (R) vs. Christine Jennings (D) — JENNINGS (Dem pickup)

16th CD (open R): Joe Negron (R) vs. Tim Mahoney (D) — NEGRON

22nd CD: Clay Shaw (R) vs. Ron Klein (D) — SHAW

GEORGIA

8th CD: Jim Marshall (D) vs. Mac Collins (R) — MARSHALL

12th CD: John Barrow (D) vs. Max Burns (R) — BARROW

IDAHO

1st District (open R) : Bill Sali (R) vs. Larry Grant (D) — SALI

ILLINOIS

6th CD (open R) : Peter Roskam (R) vs. Tammy Duckworth (D) — DUCKWORTH (Dem pickup)

8th CD: Melissa Bean (D) vs. David McSweeney (R) — BEAN

INDIANA

2nd CD: Chris Chocola (R) vs. Joe Donnelly (D) — DONNELLY (Dem pickup)

8th CD: John Hostettler (R) vs. Brad Ellsworth (D) — ELLSWORTH (Dem pickup)

9th CD: Mike Sodrel (R) vs. Baron Hill (D) — HILL (Dem pickup)

IOWA

1st CD (open R): Mike Whalen (R) vs. Bruce Braley (D) — BRALEY (Dem pickup)

3rd CD: Leonard Boswell (D) vs. Jeff Lamberti (R) — BOSWELL

KANSAS

2nd CD: Jim Ryun (R) vs. Nancy Boyda (D) — RYUN

KENTUCKY

3rd CD: Anne Northup (R) vs. John Yarmuth (D) — NORTHUP

4th CD: Geoff Davis (R) vs. Ken Lucas (D) — DAVIS

MINNESOTA

1st CD: Gil Gutknecht (R) vs. Tim Walz (D) — GUTKNECHT

2nd CD: John Kline (R) vs. Coleen Rowley (D) — KLINE

6th CD (open R): Michele Bachmann (R) vs. Patty Wetterling (D) — WETTERLING (Dem pickup)

NEBRASKA

3rd CD (open R): Adrian Smith (R) vs. Scott Kleeb (D) — SMITH

NEVADA

2nd CD (open R): Dean Heller (R) vs. Jill Derby (D) — HELLER

3rd CD: Jon Porter (R) vs. Tessa Hafen (D) — PORTER

NEW HAMPSHIRE

1st CD: Jeb Bradley (R) vs. Carol Shea-Porter (D) — BRADLEY

2nd CD: Charlie Bass (R) vs. Paul Hodes (D) — BASS

NEW JERSEY

7th CD: Mike Ferguson (R) vs. Linda Stender (D) — FERGUSON

NEW MEXICO

1st CD: Heather Wilson (R) vs. Patricia Madrid (D) — MADRID (Dem pickup)

NEW YORK

19th CD: Sue Kelly (R) vs. John Hall (D) — KELLY

20th CD: John Sweeney (R) vs. Kirsten Gillibrand (D) — GILLIBRAND (Dem pickup)

24th CD (open R): Ray Meier (R) vs. Michael Arcuri (D) — ARCURI (Dem pickup)

26th CD: Tom Reynolds (R) vs. Jack Davis (D) — DAVIS (Dem pickup)

29th CD: Randy Kuhl (R) vs. Eric Massa (D) — KUHL

NORTH CAROLINA

11th CD: Charles Taylor (R) vs. Heath Shuler (D) — SHULER (Dem pickup)

OHIO

1st CD: Steve Chabot (R) vs. John Cranley (D) — CRANLEY (Dem pickup)

2nd CD: Jean Schmidt (R) vs. Victoria Wulsin (D) — SCHMIDT

6th CD (open D): Charlie Wilson (D) vs. Charles Blasdel (R) — WILSON

15th CD: Deborah Pryce (R) vs. Mary Jo Kilroy (D) — PRYCE

18th CD (open R): Joy Padgett (R) vs. Zach Space (D) — SPACE (Dem pickup)

PENNSYLVANIA

6th CD: Jim Gerlach (R) vs. Lois Murphy (D) — MURPHY (Dem pickup)

7th CD: Curt Weldon (R) vs. Joe Sestak (D) — SESTAK (Dem pickup)

8th CD: Mike Fitzpatrick (R) vs. Patrick Murphy (D) — FITZPATRICK

10th CD: Don Sherwood (R) vs. Chris Carney (D) — CARNEY (Dem pickup)

SOUTH CAROLINA

5th CD: John Spratt (D) vs. Ralph Norman (R) — SPRATT

TEXAS

17th CD: Chet Edwards (D) vs. Van Taylor (R) — EDWARDS

22nd CD (open R): Shelley Sekula-Gibbs (R write in) vs. Nick Lampson (D) — LAMPSON (Dem pickup)

23rd CD: Henry Bonilla (R) vs. Ciro Rodriguez (D), others — BONILLA

VERMONT

At Large (open I): Peter Welch (D) vs. Martha Rainville (R) — WELCH (Dem pickup from Independent)

VIRGINIA

2nd CD: Thelma Drake (R) vs. Philip Kellam (D) — DRAKE

WASHINGTON

8th CD: Dave Reichert (R) vs. Darcy Burner (D) — BURNER (Dem pickup)

WEST VIRGINIA

1st CD: Alan Mollohan (D) vs. Chris Wakim (R) — MOLLOHAN

WISCONSIN

8th CD (open R): John Gard (R) vs. Steve Kagen (D) — GARD

WYOMING

At-Large: Barbara Cubin (R) vs. Gary Trauner (D) –- CUBIN

GUBERNATORIAL PREDICTION: Dems win net gain of eight.

And finally, a look at the 36 races for governor this year. Of the 36, 22 are held by the Republicans, 14 by the Democrats. (Incumbent in italics, call in bold.)

ALABAMA: Bob Riley (R) vs. Lucy Baxley (D) — RILEY

ALASKA (open R): Sarah Palin (R) vs. Tony Knowles (D) — PALIN

ARIZONA: Janet Napolitano (D) vs. Len Munsil (R) — NAPOLITANO

ARKANSAS (open R): Asa Hutchinson (R) vs. Mike Beebe (D) — BEEBE (Dem pickup)

CALIFORNIA: Arnold Schwarzenegger (R) vs. Phil Angelides (D) — SCHWARZENEGGER

COLORADO (open R): Bob Beauprez (R) vs. Bill Ritter (D) — RITTER (Dem pickup)

CONNECTICUT: Jodi Rell (R) vs. John DeStefano (D) — RELL

FLORIDA (open R): Charlie Crist (R) vs. Jim Davis (D) — CRIST

GEORGIA: Sonny Perdue (R) vs. Mark Taylor (D) — PERDUE

HAWAII: Linda Lingle (R) vs. Randy Iwase (D) — LINGLE

IDAHO (open R): Butch Otter (R) vs. Jerry Brady (D) — OTTER

ILLINOIS: Rod Blagojevich (D) vs. Judy Baar Topinka (R) — BLAGOJEVICH

IOWA (open D): Chet Culver (D) vs. Jim Nussle (R) — CULVER

KANSAS: Kathleen Sebelius (D) vs. Jim Barnett (R) — SEBELIUS

MAINE: John Baldacci (D) vs. Chandler Woodcock (R) — BALDACCI

MARYLAND: Bob Ehlrich (R) vs. Martin O'Malley (D) — O'MALLEY (Dem pickup)

MASSACHUSETTS (open R): Kerry Healey (R) vs. Deval Patrick (D) — PATRICK (Dem pickup)

MICHIGAN: Jennifer Granholm (D) vs. Dick DeVos (R) — GRANHOLM

MINNESOTA: Tim Pawlenty (R) vs. Mike Hatch (D) — HATCH (Dem pickup)

NEBRASKA: Dave Heineman (R) vs. David Hahn (D) — HEINEMAN

NEVADA (open R): Jim Gibbons (R) vs. Dina Titus (D) — TITUS (Dem pickup)

NEW HAMPSHIRE: John Lynch (D) vs. Jim Coburn (R) — LYNCH

NEW MEXICO: Bill Richardson (D) vs. John Dendahl (R) — RICHARDSON

NEW YORK (open R): John Faso (R) vs. Eliot Spitzer (D) — SPITZER (Dem pickup)

OHIO (open R): Ken Blackwell (R) vs. Ted Strickland (D) — STRICKLAND (Dem pickup)

OKLAHOMA: Brad Henry (D) vs. Ernest Istook (R) — HENRY

OREGON: Ted Kulongoski (D) vs. Ron Saxton (R) — KULONGOSKI

PENNSYLVANIA: Ed Rendell (D) vs. Lynn Swann (R) — RENDELL

RHODE ISLAND: Don Carcieri (R) vs. Charlie Fogarty (D) — CARCIERI

SOUTH CAROLINA: Mark Sanford (R) vs. Tommy Moore (D) — SANFORD

SOUTH DAKOTA: Mike Rounds (R) vs. Jack Billion (D) — ROUNDS

TENNESSEE: Phil Bredesen (D) vs. Jim Bryson (R) — BREDESEN

TEXAS: Rick Perry (R) vs. Chris Bell (D) vs. Kinky Friedman (I) vs. Carole Keeton Strayhorn (I) — PERRY

VERMONT: Jim Douglas (R) vs. Scudder Parker (D) — DOUGLAS

WISCONSIN: Jim Doyle (D) vs. Mark Green (R) — DOYLE

WYOMING: Dave Freudenthal (D) vs. Ray Hunkins (R) — FREUDENTHAL

Time for just one question:

Q: Did the Republicans lose any House or Senate incumbents during their 1994 sweep of Congress? — Peter Graham, Seattle, Wash.

A: No. But they did lose four open House seats, all by incumbents who sought higher office. Three were seats where the Republican incumbents won Senate seats: Minnesota 6th CD (Rod Grams), Pennsylvania 18th CD (Rick Santorum) and Maine 2nd CD (Olympia Snowe). The fourth district, in Rhode Island, was the 2nd CD seat vacated by gubernatorial hopeful Ron Machtley.

Want an NPR Convention Pin? If you have a 2006 Senate, House or governor campaign button that I don't have, I will gladly trade you a (gasp) rare NPR lapel pin from the 2004 national conventions! Send a photocopy of what you have to Political Junkie, 635 Massachusetts Ave., NW, Washington, DC 20001.

Election Night on NPR: Live coverage from 8 p.m. to 5 a.m. ET time on your local NPR station. Results from every Senate, gubernatorial and key House contest, on the air and on NPR.org. The special program plays straight through to Morning Edition. If you still have questions or comments after that, then join me (and a cast of gazillions) at 2 p.m. ET on Wednesday for an extended Talk of the Nation program. Check local listings to see if your NPR station carries Talk of the Nation. If not, you can always hear it on the Web at npr.org.

And don't forget ... You won't want to miss the post-election edition of It's All Politics, NPR's weekly podcast hosted by Ron Elving and me. Find out why Elving was wrong on every one of his predictions. Check out the podcast page at NPR.org for more details.

Please ... If you are sending in a question to be used in this column, don't forget to include your city and state.

This Day in Campaign History: Stunned by the historic Democratic gains in the midterm elections, and under assault from his fellow Republicans, House Speaker Newt Gingrich announces he will not be a candidate to retain his leadership post (Nov. 6, 1998).

Got a question? Ask Ken Rudin: politicaljunkie@npr.org.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.