Congress Takes Up Complaints on Credit Cards

The credit card industry is facing a much higher level of scrutiny in the new Congress.

The credit card industry is facing a much higher level of scrutiny in the new Congress. Chip Somodevilla/AFPGetty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Chip Somodevilla/AFPGetty Images

Executives from major U.S. banks were on the hot seat in Congress Wednesday over credit-card fees and penalties. One bank executive apologized to an aggrieved customer at the hearing. He said that in his case, the bank had simply blown it.

The executives, from Chase, Citigroup and Bank of America, were called to testify before the Senate permanent subcommittee on investigations about their fee and penalty policies. In the session, they were hit by an onslaught of criticism from both Republicans and Democrats.

Also testifying at the hearing was credit-card customer Wesley Wannemacher, who said he learned the hard way how a relatively small balance on his credit card could get out of control.

In 2001, Wannemacher ran up $3,200 on his credit card to pay for his wedding, including a photographer and flowers. He says he agreed to come to Washington to testify so others wouldn't have to go through what he did.

"From September of 2001 to February of 2007," Wannemacher said, "I've paid Chase over $6,300; if they hadn't reviewed my account, I would have paid another $6,110 on a $3,200 debt."

Chase, the company that issued Wannemacher his card, recently agreed to waive the rest of his debt. And the CEO of Chase Card Services, Richard Srednicki, acknowledged things should never have gone as far as they did.

"I want to begin my remarks with a public apology to Mr. Wannemaker," Srednicki said. "We have polices and procedures in place at Chase to identify customers like him who have fallen into deep financial trouble and are having a difficult time working their way out. In this case, we simply blew it."

Despite the rare public apology, subcommittee chairman Sen. Carl Levin was clearly skeptical. He questioned Srednicki about whether credit-card customers understand the fine print.

"Do you think most customers understand that the grace period only applies to people who pay their bill in full every month?" Levin asked. "Do you think most people understand that? Mr. Wannemacher sure didn't."

"I think a large majority of our customers do understand that, sir," Srednicki answered.

What emerged from the hearing was the fact that the new Congress is focusing more intently on bank lending practices.

As a result of recent hearings, several banks, including Chase and Citigroup, are announcing changes. Chase says it will no longer charge additional over-limit fees after a customer exceeds his or her credit limit for more than 90 days.

And last week, Citigroup said it will end two controversial practices: One penalizes a card holder for being late on another credit card; the other allows the bank to raise rates at any time.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.