'Forgetting Sarah Marshall' From the Judd Apatow laff factory: Crushed by a breakup with his famous girlfriend, Peter (Jason Segel) heads for Hawaii to mend his heart — only to find his ex in residence with her new rock-star beau.
NPR logo 'Forgetting Sarah Marshall'

Review

Arts & Life

'Forgetting Sarah Marshall'

Matthew (Jonah Hill), a songwriting resort waiter, tries to cheer up the recently dumped Peter (Jason Segel). Glen Wilson/Universal Pictures hide caption

toggle caption
Glen Wilson/Universal Pictures

Matthew (Jonah Hill), a songwriting resort waiter, tries to cheer up the recently dumped Peter (Jason Segel).

Glen Wilson/Universal Pictures
  • Director: Nicholas Stoller
  • Genre: Romantic Comedy
  • Running Time: 112 minutes

Watch a Clip

With pratfalls, yucks, a crying jag, and what is starting to seem like the requisite flash of nudity, Jason Segel becomes this year's adorably hapless movie schlub.

Segel was an early Freak (as opposed to a Geek) in Judd Apatow's unofficial rep company, and in penning a starring vehicle for himself, he's hewn closely to the formula of bawdy sweetness and cuddly raunch that worked for his Knocked Up/Superbad/Virgin antecedents.

This time, the story centers on a bad breakup made worse: Segel's TV composer, the dumpee, has fled to a Hawaiian hotel to recuperate, only to find that the dumper (Kristen Bell's TV-star title character) and her new rock-star lover (Russell Brand) have picked the same spot. Mortification ensues. Happily, there's a pretty hotel receptionist (Rachel Jansen) to take pity on Segel, and a few random Apatovians (surfing instructor Paul Rudd, songwriting waiter Jonah Hill) to help with the comic heavy lifting.

First-time director Nicholas Stoller doesn't do anything particularly creative with the formula, but he keeps Segel zipping brightly from one humiliation to the next. And the star remains engaging even during the last half-hour, when the film's bubbly premise starts to go a little flat.