Aid Agencies Careful Not to Push Myanmar Too Hard

After a two-hour meeting Friday with the leader of Myanmar's military junta, U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon announces that "all aid workers" are now being allowed into the country to help with the cyclone recovery effort. The development comes with quite a few questions, including where these aid workers will be allowed.


NPR reporter Michael Sullivan recently spend about 10 days inside Myanmar. He worked undercover there, because the military government does not welcome journalists. Sullivan left the country earlier this week. Today, he shares his impressions of what the people of Myanmar have been through since the cyclone struck at the beginning of May.

MICHAEL SULLIVAN: There's a small Hindu temple in the middle of Tategon(ph) village, about an hour or so, south of Yangon. And that temple, villager said, is what saved them when the cyclone hit.

Unidentified Man #1: (Speaking foreign language)

SULLIVAN: The entire village, all 250 men, women and children, this man says, crammed into the tiny stone structure and waited more than 10 hours for the storm to end. When they came out, he says, there was almost nothing left.

Unidentified Man #1: (Speaking foreign language)

SULLIVAN: Only four houses out of 48 is still standing. The villagers' food, their livestock, their seeds for the next rice crop, all gone he says. The fields flooded. And when I visited, two weeks after the cyclone struck, still not a lick of help from the military government.

Unidentified Man #1: (Speaking foreign language)

SULLIVAN: We wish the generals were gone, he says, but there's nothing we can really do about it. They are strong and we are afraid. They don't care about the people at all, all they care about, he says, is staying in power.

The military's decision to go ahead with its May 10th referendum on the new constitution in areas not affected by the storm, is perhaps the most stunning example of the general's indifference to the suffering of their people. The generals call the new constitution part of their road map to democracy, critics call it a sham, designed to cement the military's hold on power for several more decades. Either way, the vote was the lead item on the evening newscast. In fact it was about the only story on the evening news.

Unidentified Man #2: (Speaking foreign language)

SULLIVAN: On that Saturday, as aid groups begged the military for more visas, almost the entire half hour newscast was devoted to the referendum. Mostly shots of generals casting their ballots and ballot boxes stuffed with yes votes being emptied onto tables. The boxes for the no votes were oddly empty. The military had reminded voters - warned voters the week before - that it was their patriotic duty to vote yes.

(Soundbite of people talking)

SULLIVAN: What they didn't show on tape when media were start videos of survivors begging for food, captured on amateur video shot by Burmese volunteers who'd rushed to the delta after the storm, their cars packed with rice, dried fish, and bottled water to distribute to desperate survivors.

Bootleg video circulating widely around Yangon show pictures of large parts of the delta underwater; of survivors floating down rivers, clinging to bits of debris; and images of the dead, faced down the on the waters, stuck in trees or lying under broken buildings. It's not clear when the videos were taken. What is clear, according to several from people just back, is that there are many bodies still unburied three weeks in.

(Soundbite of chainsaw)

SULLIVAN: But on the streets of the former capital and in the state run media, the focus is now on the recovery effort and rebuilding - the military's position that the relief effort is now almost over. This despite UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's lament, this week, that only 25 percent of those in need have been reached - 25 percent of more than two million. And even though they've been stymied in their efforts to get enough aid and aid workers into the country, most international aid agencies have been careful not to push the military too hard.

Mr. ERIC STOVER (Director, Human Rights Center, University of California): It's a very difficult situation.

SULLIVAN: Eric Stover directs the Human Rights Center at the University of California, Berkeley, and spent the last two weeks in Myanmar.

Mr. STOVER: They're in a situation where they have to be very careful in what they say. They don't want to say things that would in any way jeopardize their capacity to eventually help the cyclone survivors.

SULLIVAN: Taking the moral high ground and refusing to accept the government's conditions, Stover argues, would only hurt those who need help most. A point not lost on the generals.

Mr. STOVER: Never underestimate the ability of this military government to calibrate and decide how it's going to manage any problem on its own terms. They're very shrewd at doing this.

SULLIVAN: Shrewd at doling out visas and making other small concessions, bending just enough to keep the threat of a more forceful international response off the table - dashing the hopes of many Burmese as they were dashed back in September during the brutal crackdown a monk-led demonstrations against the government. A crackdown that left dozens dead and many more in prison or in exile. For a few heady days back then, some on the streets of Yangon and Mandalay dared to hope out loud that the international community would intervene to stop the military. I heard the same thing for the first couple of days on this trip too, but only for a few days. After that, the people had pretty much figured out who'd won, again.

Michael Sullivan. NPR News.

Copyright © 2008 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.

U.N. Chief Urges Myanmar to Allow Cyclone Aid

U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon is in Myanmar on a mission to persuade the country's military government to allow a large-scale international aid effort for the victims of the cyclone.

Ban was first flown by helicopter to a village called Kyondah, where he spoke to a few of the 500 or so people huddled in blue tents.

"I'm very upset by what I've seen," he said afterward.

Kyondah is located in the Irrawaddy Delta region, where most of the 78,000 deaths from Cyclone Nargis occurred. An additional 56,000 are officially listed as missing.

In the country's largest city, Yangon, Ban told an audience at a pagoda that he was bringing a message of hope.

"The United Nations and all the international community stand ready to help to overcome the tragedy," the secretary-general said.

In a meeting with Myanmar's Prime Minister Thein Sein, Ban stressed the need to speed up delivery of humanitarian aid. In contrast to reports of appalling conditions in the delta, Thein Sein told Ban that the relief phase of the government's operation was ending and the focus had shifted to reconstruction, a U.N. official at the talks said, requesting anonymity for reasons of protocol.

The latest report from the International Red Cross said rivers and ponds in the delta's Bogalay area were full of corpses and that many people in remote areas had received no aid.

Ban said mutual trust was needed between Myanmar and the international community, which was prepared to send in planes and helicopters to help, the official said.

Myanmar is still reluctant to accept more than a handful of experienced foreign rescue and disaster relief workers.

From NPR reports and The Associated Press.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.