Mayor: Bridge Collapse Brought People Together

  • Playlist
  • Download
  • Embed
    Embed <iframe src="http://www.npr.org/player/embed/93194956/93196413" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no">
  • Transcript

Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak talks about the first anniversary of the bridge collapse in the city. The mayor says this is an anniversary that marks a tragedy in the city, but also one that shows how the city came together as a community.

MICHELE NORRIS, host:

Minneapolis went silent today at 6:05 Central Time, marking the moment one year ago when the bridge collapsed. Among the other memorials around the city today, an interfaith service and a procession to appoint overlooking the bridge for a reading of the names of the 13 people who died. Earlier, we spoke with R.T. Rybak, the mayor of Minneapolis, about the meaning of this day.

Mayor R.T. RYBAK (Minneapolis, Minnesota): This was one of the worst days in history of Minneapolis and that will obviously be one of the things that we remember. But it was also, on some levels, one of the days that really showed us what we're made out of. At a period of time where the absolute worst had happened, where there is a catastrophe where there was great danger, people ran to help as opposed to ran away. There's a bridge that will be opening in just a month, only 13 months after the bridge collapsed, which is truly remarkable. So, we obviously mark this with mixed feelings but feelings that include the fact that we're proud of what we have done.

NORRIS: And Mayor, I remember so clearly - I think it was even on that day - Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota said that this does not happen in America. With the clarity of time, you still don't know exactly what caused the bridge collapse.

Mayor RYBAK: We're still not certain why that bridge collapsed. There are obviously some very bright people involved in looking at that or some very knowledgeable people. But I'm very concerned that people who drive or cross bridges across America really don't have the answers they deserve. Even more important, in the wake of that collapse, I think many people, political levels from the - leaders from the president on down, all sorts of civic leaders, stood up and said, we're gonna do what it takes to make sure this never happens again. I do not believe we've delivered on that promise.

NORRIS: You know, I hear the disappointment that you're expressing. But as the Mayor of the largest city in Minnesota, do you bear some responsibility for not moving that all forward more?

Mayor RYBAK: As the mayor of a major city, I absolutely should be held accountable for infrastructure. I'm preparing my budget for next year, which includes additional spending on infrastructure, and it should on every level of government. We have to recognize that. When you look at what situation we're in right now, we're in a period of time in which both our infrastructure and our economy is crumbling. That's happened before in America. At the height of the Depression, Franklin Roosevelt responded to that with a WPA, which built infrastructure around this country that remains in place today, and it put people to work. I believe that's the sort of value we should bring to this. There's a lot that's been said about infrastructure and not a whole lot that really has been done.

NORRIS: Mayor, have there been other problems or reports that more than 1,000 pounds of concrete rained down from the underside of a 50-year-old bridge not too great a distance away from the bridge collapse, the span of I-35E?

Mayor RYBAK: There was an incident involving concrete falling from another bridge. There have been several other bridges in the state that have been closed due to either incidents or as precautionary measures. Mercifully, we have not had anything similar to this and we hope never to do that again. But I think while there is a significant body of information that's not answered out there, what is clear is that now, a year later, Minnesotans are, in taking the state, are really focused on the families that have been changed forever and how they had a great loss and how they became part of our community.

NORRIS: Mayor R.T. Rybak, thanks so much for speaking with us.

Mayor RYBAK: Thank you very much.

NORRIS: And at our Web site, you can learn about bridges around the country, how they're inspected and how they're rated. That's at npr.org.

Copyright © 2008 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.

States Still Struggle With Bridge Upkeep

  • Playlist
  • Download
  • Embed
    Embed <iframe src="http://www.npr.org/player/embed/93146021/93196412" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no">
  • Transcript

Bridge Stats

 

Total number of U.S. bridges (including Puerto Rico): 599,766

 

Structurally deficient bridges: 72,524 (12%)

 

Functionally obsolete bridges: 79,792 (13%)

In Depth

 

What does structurally deficient and functionally obsolete mean? Are they unsafe? Find out more.

Joel Alsum i

Wisconsin bridge inspector Joel Alsum uses an ultrasound device to check the integrity of a pin that secures steel plates under an I-43 bridge in Green Bay. He's looking at a portable screen that shows the pin's ultrasonic image. David Schaper/NPR hide caption

itoggle caption David Schaper/NPR
Joel Alsum

Wisconsin bridge inspector Joel Alsum uses an ultrasound device to check the integrity of a pin that secures steel plates under an I-43 bridge in Green Bay. He's looking at a portable screen that shows the pin's ultrasonic image.

David Schaper/NPR
Ultrasound i

This portable screen provides an ultrasound image of the steel pin. David Schaper/NPR hide caption

itoggle caption David Schaper/NPR
Ultrasound

The portable screen that shows the ultrasound image of the pin.

David Schaper/NPR

In the year since the Minneapolis I-35W bridge collapsed, states appear to be aggressively inspecting bridges to locate problems. But some experts say not enough is being done to fund the maintenance of the nation's aging and crumbling bridges.

Federal Highway Administration figures indicate there are still about 150,000 bridges across the country rated as structurally deficient or functionally obsolete, according to a new report issued by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials.

"One in four of the nation's more than 590,000 bridges is rated as either in need of repair or inadequate to handle today's traffic," says Pete Rahn, Missouri's transportation director and president of the state highway officials group.

The report indicates the average age of the nation's bridges is 43 years; most bridges are designed to last 50 years, meaning many are nearing the age of retirement.

The cost to fix or replace all the bridges in need of attention? A whopping $140 billion — and the cost is rising every day because of skyrocketing construction costs.

"Steel, concrete, asphalt [and] earth work have increased at least 50 percent," says Rahn. "And oil has quadrupled in the last four years, forcing states to delay needed repairs."

What's more, Rahn says that every state is short on funds needed to provide the kind of systematic preventive care that can extend the lives of these aging bridges.

The group is calling for "significant and radically increased federal help."

"We need federal intervention — and federal intervention at a big level," says Gov. Ed Rendell (D-PA), the new head of the National Governors Association.

But more federal funding may be hard to come by. The federal highway trust fund is running out of money, and high gas prices are partly to blame. The 18.4 cents-a-gallon federal gas tax is what fills up the trust fund, but with Americans driving less and turning to more fuel-efficient vehicles, gas tax revenue is on the decline, meaning the trust fund could be $3 to $4 billion in the red by next spring.

Fixing Bridges

Legislation that moves $8 billion from the general fund to the highway trust fund passed the U.S. House of Representatives last week, as did a bill to create a $1 billion bridge repair fund. Both were sponsored by Rep. James Oberstar (D-MN), who heads the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

"My objective is that those lives lost in the [I-35 bridge] tragedy will not have been lost in vain — that, indeed, the Congress will act, the president will sign a bill, state departments of transportation will act," Oberstar said in an interview with NPR.

Oberstar's bill, which now moves to the Senate, also would mandate more frequent bridge inspections, higher standards for inspections, and more and better training for bridge inspectors.

"Inattention by the states to their bridge needs — and sort of an overconfidence that they've built bridges to high standards and don't need to revisit them — is the principal concern I have, and I think the underlying cause for escalating deteriorating bridges, corrosion and metal fatigue," Oberstar said.

Oberstar says in recent years, states, including his own, had shifted $5 billion of federal funding out of their bridge funds to other needs, leading to neglect of bridges. Though a National Transportation Safety Board inquiry concludes that undersized gusset plates and an outdated design seem to be the primary factors that led to the I-35 bridge collapse, Oberstar and others point out that investigators also found significant corrosion on the gusset plates and on other parts of the bridge that may have been contributing factors.

Ultrasound Tools Can Detect Flaws

Oberstar wants to make more funding available for states to use cutting-edge tools for inspecting bridges so they can better identify potential structural problems before they become serious.

To check for trouble spots in Wisconsin bridges, inspector Joel Alsum uses an ultrasound device. Wisconsin is one of a few states to use the tool to try to find cracks and corrosion before they are visible to the naked eye. Problem areas can be watched over time, or repaired or replaced, if necessary.

Underneath the deck of the I-43 bridge over Green Bay, Wis., Alsum takes a detailed look at some pins that are part of the structure holding this bridge together.

"We are going from pin to pin and doing phased-array ultrasound, which is a volumetric test ... to look for cracks or corrosion in the pins."

The steel pins are huge — five to six inches in diameter and about 10 inches long. They fasten together steel plates that hold the bridge's steel girders together at its joints. It's critical to the integrity of the bridge. The ultrasound technology is not unlike what doctors use to get an image of a fetus.

Alsum rubs a gel on the face of the pin, like a doctor would on a pregnant woman's belly. Then he moves the handheld ultrasound device over the surface as it pulsates sound waves into the pin.

It creates a color image of the inside of the solid-steel pin on a portable screen.

"What we're looking for here is something out of the ordinary...." Alsum says. "Typically, we're looking for cracks, and we're also looking for large areas of corrosion. Visual inspection would not be able to identify these areas, so we need to use this volumetric test."

This phased array ultrasound puts Wisconsin ahead of the curve in bridge inspections. Wisconsin has been using the tool for about four years, Alsum says.

More Emphasis On Maintenance

Since the Minneapolis bridge's tragic collapse, states have stepped up inspections of their bridges, especially those of similar steel deck truss design.

A handful of states, including Minnesota, have moved aggressively to close bridges they feared weren't structurally sound. Just last week, Illinois and Iowa reduced traffic by one lane on the I-80 bridge over the Mississippi as a precaution after inspectors found cracks.

"I think the bridge collapse has made bridge inspections more of a priority...." says Andrew Herrmann, a member of the American Society of Civil Engineers' board of directors. "There's been some progress, but there could be more. The other area that should get attention is maintenance."

Michael Pagano, dean of the college of urban planning at the University of Illinois, agrees states are spending too little on the maintenance of bridges and other parts of the transportation infrastructure. Pagano recently graded the states on infrastructure management for Governing magazine.

He says politicians often budget only for what a bridge like this will cost, but not what it costs to keep up.

"What we have today is crumbling and neglected infrastructure, words that seem to go together all the time," Pagano says. "And the reason is we've never planned for how we should adequately pay for the use of that facility over the design life of an asset."

Pagano says the failure of the Minneapolis bridge should have been a wake-up call but says it has yet to lead to a significant change in how the nation funds the maintenance, repairing and replacement of it's aging bridges.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.