A Love To Die For: Massenet's 'Werther'

From Genoa's Teatro Carlo Felice

HIT SINGLE

In Act 3, when Charlotte asks Werther to read from some poetry he's been translating, he chooses a passage about the poet anticipating his own death, singing it in the aria, "Pourquoi me reveleiller?" ("Why awaken me?")

B Side

Also in Act 3, Charlotte finds herself rereading a desperate letter from Werther, in which he pours out his longing for her. The aria is called "Je vous ecris..."

Tenor Giuseppe Filianoti and conductor Alain Guingal

hide captionGiuseppe Filianoti (left) sings the title role, with conductor Alain Guingal, in the Teatro Carlo Felice's performance of Werther.

Marcello Orselli

Music, no matter how innocent and lovely it might seem, can still convey some truly dire emotions.

You may remember a romantic hit from the 60s, "The End of the World" by Skeeter Davis. It features a gentle melody and softly poetic lyrics, but depending on context, those lyrics could reflect a desperate state of mind: "Why does my heart go on beating? Why do these eyes of mine cry? Don't they know it's the end of the world? It ended when you said goodbye."

Someone thinking that way — someone who has lost their one true love — might decide that if their own romantic world has ended, living with the rest of the world just isn't worth the effort any more.

Massenet's opera Werther is another example of music that, at first, is deceptively innocent. It's opening scene features happy children practicing a joyous Christmas carol on a bright, July afternoon. But before long, we meet a young man so distressed that for him, even Christmas in July is no picnic.

Werther, and the book that inspired it, are among those tragic works of art that may feed the strange yet persistent notion that suicide, especially in the name of love, is somehow a romantic, even noble, thing to do.

It's certainly hard to believe that at the moment someone takes their own life the act could possibly seem romantic — and it's surely nothing but tragic for the people left behind.

Still, the idea of romantic suicide has been around for a long time, and Werther proves that. The opera was completed in 1887, and is based on novel by Goethe that appeared more than a century earlier. The book was inspired by an actual event: the suicide of a young man who was in love with a married woman.

Goethe's novel, The Sorrows of Young Werther, consists mainly of letters from the title character to his beloved. The opera's libretto goes well beyond that, fleshing out the rest of the pivotal characters. Still, it remains Werther's story — and somehow it's plain, right from the falsely cheerful beginning, that things are bound to end badly.

World of Opera host Lisa Simeone brings us a production from the Teatro Carlo Felice in Genoa, starring tenor Giuseppe Filianoti in the title role, and the brilliant mezzo-soprano Sonia Ganassi as Charlotte.

See the previous edition of World of Opera or the full archive

The Story of 'Werther'

Soprano Adriana Kucerova

hide captionSoprano Adriana Kucerova sings the role of Sophie in the Genoa performance of Werther.

Marcello Orselli
Jules Massenet

hide captionComposer Jules Massenet finished Werther in 1887, but it wasn't premiered until 1892, in Vienna.

Getty Images

WHO'S WHO?

  • Giuseppe Filianoti ........... Werther
  • Sonia Ganassi ............... Charlotte
  • Adriana Kucerova ........... Sophie
  • Giorgio Caoduro ............. Albert
  • Gianfranco Montresor ... The Mayor
  • Teatro Carlo Felice Orchestra and Chorus
  • Alain Guingal, conductor

Act One: The setting is a small, German town. The first act takes place in July, at the home of the town's bailiff, or mayor. He is a widower, left with two daughters — 20-year-old Charlotte and 15-year-old Sophie. There are also several younger children, whom Charlotte cares for. As the act opens, the bailiff is teaching his children a Christmas carol in the garden of their house. Two neighbors, Schmidt and Johann, watch their progress with amusement. They ask after Charlotte, who's engaged to a man named Albert. The bailiff tells them Albert is away, and Charlotte will be escorted to the local ball that night by a visitor — a young poet named Werther.

As the bailiff goes into the house, Werther arrives for his date with Charlotte, and it's apparent that he is a very romantic young man. He rhapsodizes on the beauty of the evening, and watches intently as Charlotte cuts bread for the childrens' supper. When she and Werther have left for the ball, and the bailiff has gone to join his friends at the tavern, Albert returns unexpectedly. Disappointed at not finding Charlotte, he tells Sophie that he'll call again in the morning.

As the moon rises, Werther and Charlotte return. He has fallen in love with her, but his declaration is cut short when the bailiff passes by, saying that Albert is back in town. Werther can't hide his disappointment, but he takes the high road, and urges Charlotte to keep her promise to marry Albert.

Act Two: Charlotte and Albert, now married, walk contentedly across the town square on their way to church, followed by a sullen Werther. Albert and Sophie try to cheer Werther up, but he starts talking wistfully about the first time he met Charlotte.

Hearing this, Charlotte tells him it would be best for everyone if he left town. But, to strangely ominous music, she also sings, "why forget me?" Then immediately, to rather seductive music, she suggests that even when he's gone, he should think of her fondly. And maybe, she says, he could come back for a visit at Christmas.

When she leaves, Werther thinks longingly of Christmas, but he knows deep down that it's a false hope. Then he makes his first real reference to suicide — singing about eternal peace. Sophie enters, and finds Werther alone. She asks him why he hasn't joined the others and Werther says he can't. He's leaving, and will be gone forever. When he's gone, Sophie catches up to Charlotte and tells her what Werther has just said. Albert seems to know that Werther is still in love with Charlotte, while Charlotte wonders exactly what Werther meant by "forever."

Act Three: It's Christmas Eve, and Charlotte is alone at home. She rereads the dejected letters written to her by Werther, and admits to herself that she still has feelings for him. While she prays for strength, he suddenly appears. She tries to remain calm and asks him to read to her from his translations of the legendary Scottish poet, Ossian.

Werther chooses a passage in which the poet foresees his own death. When Charlotte begs him to stop, he realizes she still loves him. They embrace, but she quickly turns away, saying she can never see him again. Charlotte runs from the room and Werther leaves the house, determined to die.

Albert comes home, and finds Charlotte distraught. Knowing that Werther is back in town, Albert asks his wife what's bothering her. Nothing, she says. Then a servant arrives with a message from Werther. He's leaving on long journey, he writes, and wants to know if he might borrow Albert's pistols.

Charlotte tries to control her reaction, but her husband realizes that she still loves Werther. Albert has her fetch the pistols, then orders her to give them to the servant herself, to be taken to Werther. Albert then leaves the room, and Charlotte hurries off, praying she can reach Werther before it's too late.

Act Four: Charlotte desperately rushes into Werther's house, calling his name. He has already shot himself, and she finds him lying in a pool of blood. Werther tells her there is no point in calling for help. She says the whole thing is her fault, that she's loved him all along, and they kiss for the first time. Outside, excited children sing Christmas songs. As Werther dies, he imagines that the children are angels, granting him forgiveness.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.