NPR logo

Lieberman Gets To Keep Committee Chairmanship

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Lieberman Gets To Keep Committee Chairmanship

Lieberman Gets To Keep Committee Chairmanship

Lieberman Gets To Keep Committee Chairmanship

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

Democrats in the Senate decided Tuesday that Joe Lieberman may keep his committee chairmanship — even though he campaigned for Republican John McCain. Democrats secretly voted 42-13 to let him remain chairman of the Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee. His only sanction was being removed from the Environment Committee.


On top of the Senate seat they're adding, Democrats decided to keep Joe Lieberman. They decided the independent senator could keep his committee chairmanship even though he campaigned for Republican John McCain. Here's NPR's David Welna.

DAVID WELNA: Because of Senator Lieberman's support for Republican John McCain, many Democrats felt he no longer deserved the chairmanship he'd been given on the Homeland Security Committee. That perk kept him firmly in the fold of Democrats, which in turn just barely gave them majority control of the Senate over the past two years. When it came time to decide behind closed doors whether to strip Lieberman of his prized chairmanship, Democrats secretly voted 42-13 to let him keep it. His only sanction was being removed from the Environment Committee. Majority Leader Harry Reid said he was very satisfied with this outcome.

Senator HARRY REID (Democrat, Nevada; Senate Majority Leader): I feel good about what we did today. I don't apologize to anyone, what we did today. We're moving forward, recognizing that there is a period of time that - in Joe Lieberman's political career that I will never understand or approve.

WELNA: But one thing Democrats do understand is that Lieberman can still be of great use to them. On Election Day, they picked up six more seats. With Lieberman still in their ranks, Senate Democrats could be very close to the 60-vote majority they need to stave off filibusters. Lieberman had earlier threatened to quit caucusing with the Democrats if he lost his chairmanship. He called yesterday's resolution fair and forward-leaning.

Senator JOSEPH LIEBERMAN (Independent, Connecticut; Chairman, Homeland Security Committee): It's a resolution that not only resolves the current dilemma, but it's a resolution of reconciliation and not retribution, and I appreciate it.

WELNA: The resolution strongly decries statements Lieberman made about President-elect Obama during the campaign. Lieberman said yesterday that there were some campaign statements he'd made that he wished had been more clear.

Senator LIEBERMAN: And there are some that I made that I wish I had not made at all. And obviously in the heat of the campaigns, that happens to all of us. But I regret that. And now it's time to move on.

WELNA: Democrats who voted for the resolution on Lieberman also agreed it was time to move on. Minnesota's Amy Klobuchar was one of them.

Senator AMY KLOBUCHAR (Democrat, Minnesota): This was difficult for our caucus. People talked about some of the things that bothered them that Senator Lieberman had said about Senator Obama, and he said that he regretted some of those comments. But in the end, this was about reconciliation, instead of revenge.

WELNA: Pennsylvania's Bob Casey, an early supporter of the president-elect, also voted for the resolution, even though he said he was both angry and frustrated with Lieberman.

Senator BOB CASEY (Democrat, Pennsylvania): People will judge him as he goes forward. I don't think there is any list of rules that he's got to follow. He's going to have to figure that out. But I think people will be watching.

WELNA: David Welna, NPR News, the Capitol.

Copyright © 2008 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Democrats Let Lieberman Keep Chairmanship

Independent Sen. Joe Lieberman will remain as chairman of the Homeland Security Committee, after Democrats voted overwhelmingly on Tuesday to let him to stay despite his support for Republican presidential candidate John McCain.

"This is the beginning of a new chapter, and I know that my colleagues in the Senate Democratic Caucus were moved not only by the kind words that Sen. Reid said about my longtime record, but by the appeal from President-elect Obama himself that the nation now unite to confront our very serious problems," Lieberman said after the vote.

Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada said he was very angered by Lieberman's actions during the presidential election but that "we're looking forward, we're not looking back."

"It's very clear that the vast majority of the Democratic Caucus wants to keep Sen. Lieberman as chairman of his committee, member of the Armed Services Committee, and that was done. It's all over with. Joe Lieberman is a Democrat. He's part of this caucus," Reid told reporters following the verdict.

Senate Democrats voted 42-to-13 to allow Lieberman to hang onto his chairmanship. The vote happened behind closed doors on Capitol Hill on Tuesday, after Lieberman defended himself before his colleagues. The Senate's only other independent, Vermont's Bernie Sanders, is one of those who thought Lieberman deserved a stronger rebuke.

"I voted against that Lieberman resolution. I think it will be a disappointment to millions of people who worked very hard for Barack Obama, but now is the time to move on," he said.

Lieberman, who became an independent after losing the 2006 Democratic primary in his state, has continued to sit with the Senate Democratic Caucus, despite his vocal support for McCain and criticism of then-presidential candidate Barack Obama. After Obama's decisive win, however, Lieberman's chairmanship of the prized Homeland Security Committee had been thrown into doubt.

But Lieberman's chances of keeping the post were bolstered in recent days, as President-elect Obama signaled Democratic leaders not to punish the Connecticut senator, who was Democrat Al Gore's vice presidential running mate in 2000.

Obama reportedly told Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada it would hurt the message of unity that he wants for his new administration if Lieberman leaves the Democratic caucus. Reid met with Lieberman last week and was initially inclined to strip him of the Homeland Security Committee chairmanship, according to a Senate Democratic aide.

Instead, Lieberman will have to forfeit the much less prestigious chairmanship of a subcommittee to the Environment and Public Works Committee. That move allows Lieberman to save face, as it comes amid a general reshuffling of Democratic subcommittee chairmanships designed to comply with long-standing caucus rules limiting the number of such posts.

Meanwhile, House Democrats are preparing for a bruising battle on Wednesday over who will control the Energy and Commerce Committee. Michigan Rep. John Dingell, 82, is trying to defend his leadership of the Energy and Commerce Committee against 69-year-old California Rep. Henry Waxman.

Energy and Commerce is likely to be an increasingly powerful committee in the new Congress, as it will have say over health care and energy legislation, expected to be cornerstone issues of an Obama White House.

The challenge to Dingell, the longest-serving House Democrat, has become more poignant in recent days, as he has long championed Michigan automakers that are now hat-in-hand before Congress.

The 50-odd freshmen in the House are key to the ultimate outcome. Few of them remember the heyday of Dingell's congressional career. Their vote in the caucus could go to the younger Waxman.

The incoming members are getting lobbied from both sides.

"I knew both of them and admired both of them," said Rep.-elect Dan Maffei (D-NY), who previously served in various staff positions on Capitol Hill. "It's a tough vote for all of us," he said of the expected showdown.

From NPR and wire reports