Is Bush The Worst President Of The Past 50 Years?

An audience member votes on the proposition at the debate. i

An audience member votes on the proposition "Bush 43 Is the Worst President of the Past 50 Years." Kevin Wick/Longview Photography hide caption

itoggle caption Kevin Wick/Longview Photography
An audience member votes on the proposition at the debate.

An audience member votes on the proposition "Bush 43 Is the Worst President of the Past 50 Years."

Kevin Wick/Longview Photography

When a group of pundits gathered for a recent Oxford-style debate, the proposition alone was provocative: "Bush 43 Is the Worst President of the Past 50 Years." But when you consider that one of the panelists defending President Bush's legacy was his longtime adviser Karl Rove, the night became even more interesting.

For instance, Rove said that President Bush probably would not have gone to war in Iraq if he had known the truth about Saddam Hussein's military capacity. "Absent weapons of mass destruction," Rove said, "I don't think there would have been an invasion."

And when Rove was asked why Osama bin Laden remains at large, Rove replied, "Because he is hiding in a deep, dark cave in a very dark corner of, in all likelihood, Pakistan. And to suggest that not every effort has been made to get him is inaccurate. Every effort has been made to get him, to get at his communications, to get at his allies, to get at his subordinates, to get at his inner circle."

Rove added, "A lot of them are dead and we aren't hearing much from him."

The event — which was part of the ongoing Intelligence Squared U.S. series that pits experts on either side of an issue against each other in debates — was held at Symphony Space in New York City and sponsored by the Rosenkranz Foundation. The debate series is modeled after a program begun in London in 2002.

Before and after each debate, the audience is asked to vote on the motion. At the start of the evening, 65 percent of the audience was in favor of the proposition that George W. Bush is the worst American president of the past 50 years; 17 percent were against the motion; and 18 percent were undecided. By the end of the debate, 68 percent were for the motion; 27 percent were against it; and 5 percent were still undecided.

Tuesday's debate was moderated by John Donvan, a correspondent for ABC News. Here are some highlights:


Simon Jenkins
Kevin Wick/Longview Photography

British journalist Simon Jenkins, a columnist for the Guardian and the Sunday Times:

"I had great respect for Bush when he came to power. I liked his courtesy, I liked his moderation, and I liked his concept of humility in America's power projection. I think, tragically, after 9/11, he allowed the politics of fear to get the better of him; he persuaded my prime minister, Tony Blair, to let the politics of fear aid his re-election campaign as well. The politics of fear is the most corrosive of all forms of politics in a democracy."

Jacob Weisberg
Kevin Wick/Longview Photography

Jacob Weisberg, chairman and editor-in-chief of The Slate Group, an online publishing group owned by The Washington Post Co.:

"Bush was never up to the job of being president, and it's not a matter of lacking in intelligence; it's a matter of lacking character. Bush wasn't interested enough in policy; he couldn't tolerate challenge or dissent or disagreement; he couldn't open his mind long enough to consider alternatives or admit the possibility that he might sometimes be wrong. He let his righteousness and his arrogance and his anger get the better of him. And in the end, I think what's so damning about Bush and what does make him the worst president of the last 50 years is that these were things within his control."


William Kristol
Kevin Wick/Longview Photography

William Kristol, editor of The Weekly Standard, a Washington-based political magazine, and columnist for The New York Times:

"In the real world, the choices are not, you know, perfection, and ... in the real world, he's made a lot of tough decisions, most of them correct. ... There's no reason not to be critical of Bush, not to disagree with Bush, not to prefer Obama, not to have voted for Gore and Kerry — most people in New York, obviously, have all those views. But to think that he's the worst president in 50 years is just silly."

Karl Rove
Kevin Wick/Longview Photography

Karl Rove, chief architect of Bush's 2000 and 2004 presidential campaigns, and Bush's senior adviser and deputy chief of staff from 2001-07:

"I will defend the president, and I will defend the record of the last eight years. Not always successful, but enormously successful over the long term and the long sweep of history."



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.