Connecticut Puts The Squeeze On Olive Oil Fraud

Luciano Sclafani standing with a bottle of olive oil, in front of a painting of his father. i i

Food importer Luciano Sclafani says olive oil is "one of mankind's purest foods." When he saw a competitor's products selling for a cheap price, he became suspicious. Diane Orson/NPR hide caption

itoggle caption Diane Orson/NPR
Luciano Sclafani standing with a bottle of olive oil, in front of a painting of his father.

Food importer Luciano Sclafani stands in front of a painting of his father, who started the family business. When Sclafani saw a competitor's products selling for a cheap price, he became suspicious.

Diane Orson/NPR
Romeo Simeone in his New Haven, Conn., store with his imported olive oil. i i

Romeo Simeone, owner of Romeo and Cesare's market in New Haven, says Connecticut's new purity standards protect honest store owners. Diane Orson/NPR hide caption

itoggle caption Diane Orson/NPR
Romeo Simeone in his New Haven, Conn., store with his imported olive oil.

Romeo Simeone, owner of Romeo and Cesare's market in New Haven, says Connecticut's new purity standards protect honest store owners.

Diane Orson/NPR

Just as wine lovers expect complexity in an outstanding vintage, lovers of olive oil want purity in their favorite extra virgin. High-end olive oil is very expensive to produce — and fraud is a growing problem. When Connecticut officials discovered olive oil that was labeled extra virgin but was really a cheap knockoff, they took action.

In most New England supermarkets, you can't walk down the Italian food aisle without seeing products imported by Luciano Sclafani. His company, which bears his name, sells such foods as canned peeled tomatoes, San Marzano tomatoes, regular tomatoes and pasta products.

But Sclafani says the item that's closest to his heart is the Sclafani olive oil. Olive oil, he says, is "one of mankind's purest foods."

"In fact, we have one product called the Frantoio Unfiltered from Sicily, and this I actually take a half a shot glass every morning to ingest," Sclafani says. "It keeps my hair. Being a young man of 62, it's not white like my compatriots."

A one-liter bottle of Frantoio Extra Virgin sells for $25. So when Sclafani saw a competitor's three-liter tin selling for $9.99, he sensed trouble and went straight to the authorities.

Connecticut Department of Consumer Protection Commissioner Jerry Farrell ordered food inspectors to test the suspicious product.

"We came across cans of olive oil that were for sale in Connecticut that had, after testing, these other oils in there — peanut oil, soy oil, hazelnut oil," Farrell says.

In April 2007, FDA investigators and U.S. Marshals seized more than 10,000 cases of olive oil from storage facilities in New York and New Jersey. It turned out that tins labeled as extra virgin contained mostly soybean oil mixed with low grade olive-pomace oil. The seized products had an estimated retail value of more than $700,000. Amusing as it may sound, Farrell says there's a serious side to the story.

"We saw it as not only that the consumer was being cheated, but their health was being put at risk by these oils being in there and it not being disclosed in any way," he says.

For many people with serious food allergies, nut oils can be fatal. So Connecticut became the first state in the nation to enact standards to protect the purity of olive oil.

They mirror regulations set by the International Olive Council in Spain, and create legal definitions for "virgin," "extra virgin" and "olive-pomace" oil. And the state has the authority to fine wholesalers who sell diluted olive oil without proper labeling.

At Romeo and Cesare's market in New Haven, Conn., owner Romeo Simeone says the new standards also protect honest store owners.

"It's very good because the people, they no gotta be influenced for the price, and they no give the quality," he says.

New York, New Jersey and Rhode Island say they're interested in setting state standards, but California is next in line. It begins regulating the slippery olive oil industry in January.

Diane Orson reports for member station WNPR.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.