NPR logo

Water Landings Part Of Pilot Training

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Water Landings Part Of Pilot Training


Water Landings Part Of Pilot Training

Water Landings Part Of Pilot Training

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

A day US Airways pilot safely landed a plane on the Hudson River and saved the lives of more than 150 people. Ben Berman, an airline pilot and chief of major investigations for the National Transportation and Safety Board from 2000 to 2001, talks about how pilots are trained to handle bird strikes and water landings.


From NPR News, this is All Things Considered. I'm Melissa Block.


And I'm Michele Norris. Investigators with the National Transportation Safety Board say both engines on the US Airways jet that splashed down on the Hudson River yesterday are missing. The plane was forced to make an emergency landing after reportedly hitting a flock of birds. The NTSB says the plane will be removed from the river tomorrow, and only then can the black box recorder be retrieved. President Bush called pilot Chesley Sullenberger III, and he thanked him for saving the lives of the passengers. Today, Sullenberger's wife, Lorrie, spoke to reporters outside their California home and described her husband this way.


LORRIE SULLENBERGER: He's a pilot's pilot, and he loves the art of the airplane.

BLOCK: The remarkable performance by the flight crew prompted us to call pilot Ben Berman for his reaction. He's a 737 captain and a former NTSB chief of major investigations. And Mr. Berman, let's talk first about the apparent cause of this, the bird strikes in both engines. As a pilot, when you're sitting up there in the cockpit, how often do you see birds flying all around the plane as you're taking off?

BEN BERMAN: Birds are seen almost all the time, and many times, you'll get a warning that there are birds in the vicinity of an airport when you're coming in. I think it's, I would say, more than half of the time the airports are issuing a common warning about birds. Birds are just about everywhere. It varies with the time of year. When they're in their migratory seasons, they're much, much more common, and that's when, actually, a lot of the bird strikes occur.

BLOCK: And what are you told to do when you get those warnings?

BERMAN: Well, there isn't really all that much you can do because you come upon the birds so fast. You really can't maneuver around them, and in many cases, they will duck away or maneuver away from you. What the most useful purpose of the warnings there, if you see a lot of birds that are near the runway before takeoff, you will delay your takeoff until the birds have left or are chased away by airport personnel.

BLOCK: What kind of training do you get about bird strikes as a pilot?

BERMAN: We're trained in how to be aware of bird conditions around, heeding the warnings, trained in what to do if a compressor stall occurs with the engine. There are some things you can do to get the engine producing thrust again if it isn't too badly damaged inside. And we're trained what to do in terms of assessing conditions or in-flight damage if you have had a bird strike.

BLOCK: Yesterday, with this US Airways jet, the pilot lost power in both engines. I wonder, have you put yourself in that cockpit in your mind, thinking about flying over New York City, no power, what do you do?

BERMAN: I think every pilot has put him or herself in the position of the pilot yesterday, who did such a great job to get the airplane down onto the Hudson River. We put ourselves in the position of doing the thing that you have prepared yourself mentally for, but was considered so unlikely that it's not really one of the things that we get trained for in the high-fidelity flight simulators, where we do so much of our airline training now. I imagined the expanse of the Hudson River out to my left and seeing that that's the only flat spot ahead and deciding to put the airplane down there.

BLOCK: You think that would look like a pretty good option at that point.

BERMAN: Ditching's never a good option because it's much more problematic than landing on any flat piece of land. That's a lot better than landing on ground that isn't flat.

BLOCK: You mentioned you don't get trained on flight simulators for something like this.

BERMAN: Yes, it's true. And the main reason is, the flight simulators are programmed based on the data that the manufacturers and the operators have about how the airplane really performs and behaves. So, the simulator is made to behave and perform just like the real airplane. Well, they don't test ditching airplanes, so there's really no experience for most aircraft types on exactly what the airplane will do when it touches the water, and therefore, it's impossible to program a flight simulator for it. I think if we had data to program the simulators for, we might do well to practice ditching and practice multiple engine failures more often.

BLOCK: What are pilots taught to do if they are going to ditch, land the plane in water? What do you do?

BERMAN: Well, there's a set of procedures to follow for ditching just like for most other emergencies on aircraft, and what you would do would depend on how much time you have. You'd go anywhere from closing off all the openings in the fuselage that you can control, mainly related to the pressurization systems, slow down the flow of water into the aircraft; you would notify the cabin attendants to prepare the passengers in the cabin for a ditching, and they have a set of procedures they would then follow. And then you would bring the airplane down to the water probably with the landing gear retracted for a smooth belly with the best flap setting that will give you the best contact with the water, and then touch down just as slowly as you can. The key would be keeping the airplane under control. That's what this captain did yesterday. He brought that airplane down under great control, and it worked out wonderfully well.

BLOCK: Ben Berman, thanks so much for talking with us.

BERMAN: Oh, you're very welcome.

BLOCK: Ben Berman is a 737 captain and also former NTSB chief of major investigations.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Experience, Training Make For Smooth River Landing

Capt. Chesley Sullenberger III, the pilot of US Airways Flight 1549, guided the Airbus A320 into the Hudson River on Thursday. Safety Reliability Methods Inc. hide caption

toggle caption
Safety Reliability Methods Inc.

Capt. Chesley Sullenberger III, the pilot of US Airways Flight 1549, guided the Airbus A320 into the Hudson River on Thursday.

Safety Reliability Methods Inc.

Just 2 minutes into a routine flight from New York's LaGuardia Airport to Charlotte, N.C., Capt. Chesley B. Sullenberger III had a difficult decision to make: Could he steer his 150-seat US Airways jetliner to New Jersey's small Teterboro Airport from just 1,600 feet above the Bronx? Or would he have to find another place to bring down the plane, which had lost both of its engines?

Opting instinctively for the river because he didn't think he could make the airfield, Sullenberger steered the plane over the Hudson River and set it down, wings perfectly balanced, slowly enough to not tear the aircraft apart.

While the cause of the accident is currently under investigation, some aviation experts say Sullenberger, who has been flying with the airline since 1980 and has more than 19,000 hours of flight time, executed "a textbook ditching." His extensive time as a commercial airline pilot, combined with his history as a military flier and a glider pilot, gave Sullenberger the skills he needed to bring the plane down safely.

"It appears that everybody did their job just as they're trained to do," says Frank Ayers, associate professor of aeronautical science and chairman of the Flight Training Department at Embry Riddle Aeronautical University in Daytona Beach, Fla. "The pilot did a beautiful job."

The Airbus A320 entered the water shortly after 3:30 p.m. All 155 passengers and crew on the flight survived.

Training For Emergencies

Airline pilots train for a wide range of emergencies, including engine failures, hydraulics and electrical systems failures and structural failures. In simulator practices, flight crews are presented with a problem or scenario and then asked what to do next, says Ayers, who is certified to fly the Boeing 757 and 767. "And even though there's no cabin crew in the back of the simulator, the pilots and first officers train to give commands to the crew," he says.

The range of emergencies for which pilots train is extensive, says John Ladd, a pilot who has flown with American Airlines for more than 17 years. American Airlines captains and first officers go through simulator training every nine months, practicing what Ladd calls "plain vanilla" emergencies like engine failures, wind shear, total hydraulic failure and two-engine loss at high altitude.

"They also give us emergencies that allow us to explore the flight envelope of the airplane," Ladd says, explaining that losing both engines on takeoff, airplane fires, structural problems and high-speed descents are still practiced, although not as regularly as other emergencies.

Early reports indicate that Flight 1549 lost both engines, leaving the airplane at a low altitude with little thrust.

"Typically, we don't practice double engine failure ditchings," Ladd says. "That's not a normal training thing. We talk about it, but we don't do it in a simulator. Engine failures? All the time. Double engine failures? Not so often."

Executing a water landing is especially tricky, and Richard Fanjoy, associate head of the Aviation Technology Department at Purdue University, says there's not much of a history of successful water landings for commercial airliners.

"All airplanes are made with some durability for impacts during hard landings, but the fact that this airliner was put down in such a way that it remained intact was a testament to both the airliner and the skill of the pilot," Fanjoy says.

'Landing' On The Water

So how exactly does a pilot land in the water?

"You want to land the airplane as slow as possible without stalling," says Embry Riddle's Ayers. "You also want to catch both engines in the water at the same time. Hit one wingtip first, and you'll cartwheel the plane." The A320 has one engine mounted below each wing.

Ladd says there is a checklist for "ditching" an airplane, but Sullenberger most likely didn't have time to go through it. "We have procedures for ditching, but it's the instinct that got him through it, as well as the training," he says.

The pilot most likely kept the landing gear retracted, but he also probably extended the wing slats and flaps. Slats extend the front, or leading edge of the wing, and flaps change the shape of the back, or trailing edge. Extending the slats and flaps changes the aerodynamics of the plane, generating more lift, but also more drag.

Engaging the flaps, which are used during takeoffs and landings, allowed Sullenberger to slow the plane down without letting it stall. Stalling is the point at which the wings stop generating lift, the force that keeps the plane in the air.

"The pilot had to make a trade-off between going too slow and stalling, and going too fast and crashing," Fanjoy says. "He maneuvered the airplane to maintain the best glide speed," referring to the range of speeds where the airplane is still maneuverable and hasn't stalled.

"If the whole airplane entered the water at once, it would be much harder to control," Ayers says.

Setting the tail of the plane into the water first is key, Ladd says. That lets the water slow the plane down. "The idea is to make the landing as soft as you can at as slow a speed as possible. If the nose is too low and going too fast, you risk flipping the plane tail-over-nose."

Floating Down The River

After setting down in the river, the airplane floated on the surface long enough to allow all of the passengers to safely exit. While large jets aren't specifically engineered to float, they do have features that can be employed in the case of a water landing.

Mary Anne Greczyn, communications manager at Airbus, says a "ditch switch" is standard equipment on all modern Airbus and Boeing aircraft. The switch, which is mounted on an overhead panel in the cockpit, can be pushed by the pilot to close off openings on the outside of the plane before it hits the water.

"The switch closes off the outflow valve and the avionics ventilation ports — anyplace air would go in or out," Greczyn says. Where air could go, so can water to flood the plane, so "it closes off openings below a theoretical float line."

Pilot Ladd says that while the ditch switch is useful, opening the main doors and emergency exits on the plane to let passengers out would negate any impact that closing the valves would have, once the plane is down.

Fuel and air in the wings also probably kept the plane afloat for as long as it was, Ladd says. Since fuel and air are less dense than the river water, the wings helped buoy the plane. And because the wings are located slightly forward of the center of the fuselage, the front of the plane was slightly propped up while the tail began to sink.

Military And Gliding Experience

The pilot of the US Airways flight, Sullenberger, also flew the F-4 for the Air Force from 1973 to 1980, and Ladd and Ayers, both military fliers themselves, say his military training no doubt helped him navigate Thursday's emergency.

And Sullenberger was also a glider pilot, which undoubtedly brought valuable skills to the crisis.

"Every glider landing he's ever made has been a power-off landing, and every power-off landing you make can't hurt, so that gave him a lot of training," Ayers says. "Everything he had done over his professional piloting career contributed to his success here."