Enlisted Man Gets Burial Once Reserved For Officers

At Arlington National Cemetery, the sound of an Army band could be heard Friday as a young soldier was laid to rest. Spc. Joseph Hernandez, 24, died two weeks ago, when a roadside bomb hit his vehicle in Afghanistan.

Arlington handles burials for soldiers like Hernandez every day — about 7,000 ceremonies every year. But his was different.

The band — along with a colors team, an escort platoon and a horse-drawn caisson — are reserved for full-honors military funerals. And before now, Hernandez wouldn't have qualified for one.

That's because Army specialist is a junior enlisted rank, not an officer. But late last year, the Army changed the rules to allow all soldiers killed in action to receive full military funeral honors, regardless of their rank.

On Friday, Hernandez, of Hammond, Ind., became the first to be buried under the new rules.

"This is the right thing to do," says Joe Davis, from the group Veterans of Foreign Wars. He supports the new policy, saying it makes sense that any soldier killed by hostile fire in a war zone get full honors.

When asked why the policy wasn't changed sooner, he says, "We don't think anybody ever asked the question! And that's the big thing. Sometimes it takes one person to get noticed on the right issue."

On this issue, the right person turned out to be Sgt. 1st Class Robert Durbin.

Passing 'The Common Sense Test'

Durbin is currently deployed in Iraq. But he used to serve as a casket squad leader at Arlington. He carried President Reagan's casket. And Durbin says he just got to wondering why only officers received full honors.

"Rank has nothing to do with honor," he says. "And my hypothetical example is that a second lieutenant can graduate officer candidate school. He could hypothetically die in a car accident and receive full honors at Arlington. Whereas an enlisted service member with 20 years in the Army could be killed in action over here or Afghanistan and receive a standard honors funeral. To me, that just doesn't pass the common sense test."

Durbin caused a stir last spring, when he convinced The Military Times to publish a letter about the disparity in honors. Then he kept pushing, writing to the Army secretary and to congressmen and senators.

Finally, last month, the Army announced it was changing the policy — to create a "common standard" for all soldiers killed in action and buried at Arlington.

A Family's View

For Hernandez's widow, Alison Hernandez, the Army policy is personal. She's proud of her husband and argues that any soldier — whether specialist or sergeant or general — should be eligible for full honors.

"What is the difference? Just because the rank is smaller — they were still doing the same job," she says. "They were killed for freedom, for our country, and for us. Everyone should be allowed to be given that same service. That just seems right to me."

Alison and Joseph Hernandez met when she was 15. They were married four years and had two boys, Jacob, 2, and Noah, 9 months. While he was away in Afghanistan, Joseph called home every other day — right up until two days before he died.

"And he just started talking about all these things he wanted to do," she says. "He said, 'I want to take Jacob bowling. And I want to take you to a Cubs game. And we'll go out to Chicago, and we'll do this and that.' And it was like, he's making all these plans. And I was just waiting for him to come home so we could do those things. And now it's like, OK, those are things that I won't get to do with him. It's so hard."

At the ceremony, Hernandez's two sons took turns on their mother's lap — and were each presented with a carefully folded American flag.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.