Despite Challenges In 2009, Progress On Proliferation Pessimists say the events of the past year in North Korea and Iran have seriously undermined international efforts to stem the spread of nuclear weapons. But seen through the prism of history, the state of nuclear proliferation may not be all that dire.
NPR logo

Despite Challenges In 2009, Progress On Proliferation

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Despite Challenges In 2009, Progress On Proliferation

Despite Challenges In 2009, Progress On Proliferation

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Of course, Iran is just one trouble spot for those who worry about nuclear proliferation. In fact, the cover story of the most recent issue of Foreign Affairs magazine is called, �Is The Nuclear Order about to Collapse?�

NPR's Mike Shuster reports.

MIKE SHUSTER: President Obama made it clear early in his presidency that containing the spread of nuclear weapons was one of his most important goals. In April in Prague, he outlined a vision of a world without nuclear weapons and committed his administration to pursuing that goal. But at that very moment, North Korea tested a long-range missile and was threatening another underground nuclear test, prompting the president to strike a tough tone about nations that violate the nonproliferation norm.

President BARACK OBAMA: Rules must be binding. Violations must be punished. Words must mean something.

SHUSTER: Only a few weeks later, North Korea did conduct its second underground nuclear explosion. The challenge has also come from Iran. Last fall, Mr. Obama revealed that Iran was building a secret uranium-enrichment facility, sharpening suspicions that Tehran is indeed seeking a covert nuclear weapon's capability. 2009 has been a dismal year for the international regime of nuclear arms control. Or has it, asks Joshua Pollack, who writes for the Web site

Mr. JOSHUA POLLACK (Writer, One way to look at it a little differently is not that the regime is cracking or that the regime is failing, but that the regime has succeeded in retarding the pace of proliferation and continues to do so, but isn't going to catch everything.

SHUSTER: Since the first atomic bomb was detonated in 1945, the past decade has seen the fewest nuclear tests than any comparable period, notes Michael Krepon, president emeritus of the Stimson Center in Washington.

Mr. MICHAEL KREPON (President Emeritus, Stimson Center): Never before have there been so few nuclear tests as in this past decade. This is a norm. It can still be broken. But the country that breaks the norm does not gain points. It loses standing.

SHUSTER: The concerns of the Obama administration are wider than Iran and North Korea. The president also wants to see a dramatic reduction in the number of nuclear warheads deployed by the U.S. and Russia. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton made that clear in a speech she gave in Washington a few months ago.

Secretary HILLARY CLINTON (State Department): Clinging to nuclear weapons in excess of our security needs does not make the United States safer. And the nuclear status quo is neither desirable nor sustainable. It gives other countries the motivation - or the excuse - to pursue their own nuclear options.

SHUSTER: The administration concluded the way to pursue those goals is through new arms control negotiations with Moscow, a mechanism largely ignored by the George W. Bush administration.

But there's a big problem: The START treaty expired on December 5th. The START treaty was signed in 1991 by then-Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev and the first President Bush. It was the first and most important treaty that began the process of nuclear reductions at the end of the Cold War.

Before the deadline, the U.S. and Russia tried but failed to negotiate a new treaty.

Nonetheless, there is much to be optimistic about, says Joe Cirincione, president of the Ploughshares Fund.

Mr. JOE CIRINCIONE (President, the Ploughshares Fund): The overall climate is so much improved, and the overall effort to just dramatically reduce nuclear weapons and increase the transparency gives us lots of assurances.

SHUSTER: The U.S. and Russia are still negotiating, but there are some significant problems. For the Russians, the big issue is American missile defenses. Russia's Prime Minister Vladimir Putin made it clear this week that he sees U.S. missile defenses as a threat to Russia's nuclear deterrent.

Prime Minister VLADIMIR PUTIN (Russia): (Through Translator) Our American partners are building missile defense systems, as is known, and we are not. If we do not develop ABM systems, then a threat appears, because having created such an umbrella, our partners may feel completely protected and will do what they want. Aggressiveness will surge.

SHUSTER: To preserve balance, Putin added, Russia will need to develop additional offensive weapons. That could jeopardize the efforts to reduce deployed nuclear warheads. Right now, both the U.S. and Russia have set the target of about 1,600 if there is a new treaty.

For some arms control advocates and for other nations, that number is still too high and the process far too slow. Michael Krepon says reductions in nuclear warheads must come carefully and incrementally.

Mr. KREPON: You don't get to deep cuts in nuclear forces and you don't get to zero, without having a strong, credible nuclear deterrent. If the deterrent is not safe and secure and credible along this long journey, there will be great disruption.

SHUSTER: 2010 will be a crucial year. The Obama administration plans to focus even more attention on nuclear proliferation, with a global conference on the subject scheduled for April.

Mike Shuster, NPR News.

INSKEEP: We made it through a precarious decade. We'll be watching to see what happens in the next. It's MORNING EDITION from NPR News.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.