NPR logo

Is The Future Of Nuclear Power In Minireactors?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Is The Future Of Nuclear Power In Minireactors?


Is The Future Of Nuclear Power In Minireactors?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Melissa Block.


And I'm Michele Norris.

Almost 60 years ago, engineers in Idaho switched on the world's first nuclear power plant. The reactor vessel stood about eight feet high, and at first was only able to illuminate four light bulbs. Eventually, it made enough electricity to power a building.

Today, a nuclear power plant today can produce 10,000 times as much electricity. But for the last 20 years, new plants have been too expensive to build. As NPR's Christopher Joyce reports, engineers are now trying to revive the industry by thinking small again.

CHRISTOPHER JOYCE: They're calling them modular or mini reactors. Instead of occupying a city block of buildings, the smallest could fit in a two-car garage. And it won't break the bank.

Mr. JOSE REYES (NuScale Power): We've been calling it the economy of small.

JOYCE: Jose Reyes runs NuScale Power. He's designed a reactor about one-tenth the size of current reactors. It looks very different, kind of like a 50-foot thermos.

Mr. REYES: The concept is that you can't take a large reactor with all of its pumps and valves and piping and just shrink it down and expect to see an economic advantage there.

JOYCE: In a standard reactor, there are pipes running everywhere and pumps and valves to circulate water to the reactor core. The hot fuel creates steam that is piped out of the reactor core to run a turbine. If pumps or valves fail to keep the water moving, you can get a Fukushima-style meltdown.

In the NuScale reactor, there are no pumps. Water circulates naturally as it gets heated and then cools off. The whole reactor sits underground in a tank of water that will flood everything in case of an accident.

Nuclear engineers say this so-called passive cooling design is safer than existing plants. And Reyes says it's cheaper, too. Because his reactors are small, a utility company can order, say, half a dozen, and then add more as needed.

Mr. REYES: If you built a six-pack plant, you are looking at a cost of around $1.2 billion. And then if you are looking at filling it out with the remainder, it's about a $2 billion plant. So we're not having to require the utilities to put out $5, $6, $7 billion up front to build a large facility.

JOYCE: A large traditional plant also takes a decade to build. During that time, a builder pays interest on borrowed money and jumps through numerous regulatory hoops. But the mini-reactor, people say: Just tell us how many you want, and we'll ship them from the factory along with the ignition key.

There are doubters, of course, like Ernest Moniz, energy expert at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Mr. ERNEST MONIZ (Massachusetts Institute of Technology): To really test that proposition, you've got to produce a whole bunch of the same modular reactor on a cookie-cutter line because that's where the cost reduction is supposed to come from.

JOYCE: And that requires a lot of start-up money and lots of orders for an unproven technology.

Another problem: If a mini-reactor puts out, say, one-tenth the electricity of one of its giant brethren, it will have to cost about one-tenth as much to build and operate to be competitive.

Energy consultant Kevin Book, with ClearView Energy Partners, says that's not likely. Some costs are pretty well fixed, no matter how small you are: getting permits, for example, or paying interest on loans.

Mr. KEVIN BOOK (ClearView Energy Partners): If you only have a very small plant bearing a very large regulatory or capital cost from delay, you don't have an economic resource at all.

JOYCE: Nonetheless, mini-nukes are growing popular. Enthusiasts include Microsoft's Bill Gates, who's backing a company called TerraPower.

At the industry's Nuclear Energy Institute, policy head Paul Genoa says mini-reactors might appeal to smaller utilities or foreign buyers who can't afford $5 billion for a big power plant. And cheaper kinds of power now - coal and natural gas, for example - may not look so good as more governments tax or limit climate-warming carbon from power plants. Nuclear reactors don't emit carbon.

Mr. PAUL GENOA (Nuclear Energy Institute): The price that we're trying to compete with is not the price of a big nuclear plant today or natural gas today, but it's what it will be in 2020, and it's what it will be in different parts of the world.

JOYCE: Reyes's company, NuScale, and reactor builder Babcock & Wilcox have asked the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to approve their mini-nuke designs. Babcock & Wilcox is already making small reactors, in fact, but they don't make commercial electricity, they power Navy submarines.

Christopher Joyce, NPR News.

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.