Copyright ©2011 NPR. For personal, noncommercial use only. See Terms of Use. For other uses, prior permission required.

MELISSA BLOCK, host: Last week, federal marshals raided the Gibson Guitar Corporation in Tennessee, and not for the first time. The government appears to be preparing to charge the famous builder of instruments with trafficking in illegally obtained wood. Craig Havighurst of the member station WPLN reports on this rare collision of music and environmental regulation.

HENRY JUSZKIEWICZ: Well, here we are in front of our main facility at Gibson.

CRAIG HAVIGHURST: It was the hottest part of an August Tennessee day, but for 30 minutes last Thursday, Gibson Guitar CEO Henry Juszkiewicz stood out in full sun and vented to the press about the events of the day before.

JUSZKIEWICZ: We had a raid with federal marshals that were armed, that came in, evacuated our factory, shut down production, sent employees home and confiscated wood.

HAVIGHURST: The raids at two Nashville facilities and one in Memphis recalled a similar raid in Nashville in November of 2009, when agents seized a shipment of ebony from Madagascar. They were enforcing the Lacey Act, a century-old endangered species law that was amended in 2008 to include plants as well as animals. But Henry Juszkiewicz says the government won't tell him exactly how, or if, his company has violated that law.

JUSZKIEWICZ: We have been implicated in wrongdoing and we haven't been charged with anything. And our business has been injured to millions of dollars. We don't even have a court we can go to and say, well, look, here's our position.

HAVIGHURST: The U.S. Justice Department won't comment about the case it's preparing, but a court motion filed in June asserts Gibson's Madagascar ebony was contraband. It quotes emails that seem to show Gibson taking steps to maintain a supply chain that's been connected to illegal timber harvests. Andrea Johnson, director of forest programs for the Environmental Investigation Agency in Washington, says the Lacey Act requires end users of endangered wood to certify the legality of their supply chain all the way to the trees.

EIA's independent investigations have concluded that Gibson knowingly imported tainted wood.

ANDREA JOHNSON: There is evidence being presented by the government that Gibson clearly understood the risks involved, was on the ground in Madagascar getting a tour to understand how and whether they could possibly source illegally from that country, and made a decision, in the end, that they were going to source despite knowing that there was a ban on exports of ebony and rosewood.

HAVIGHURST: Gibson vigorously denies these allegations, maintaining that all of its purchases from Madagascar complied with U.S. and Malagasy law. A company attorney says Gibson has presented documents to support that claim and that the recent raid seized legally obtained wood from India. He adds that the company stopped importing wood from Madagascar in 2009. Chris Martin, chairman and CEO of the C.F. Martin Guitar Co. in Nazareth, Pennsylvania, says when he first heard guitars built from Madagascar rosewood, he dreamed it might be the long-sought substitute for Brazilian rosewood, whose trade was banned in the 1990s due to over-harvest. Then the situation in Madagascar changed.

CHRIS MARTIN: There was a coup. And what we heard was the international community has come to the conclusion that the coup created an illegitimate government. That's when we said, okay, we cannot buy any more of this wood.

HAVIGHURST: And while some say the Lacey Act is burdensome, Martin supports it.

MARTIN: I think illegal logging is appalling. It should stop. And if this is what it takes, unfortunately, to stop unscrupulous operators, I'm all for it. It's tedious, but we're getting through it.

HAVIGHURST: Others in the guitar world aren't so upbeat. Attorney Ronald Bienstock says the Gibson raids have aroused the guitar builders he represents because the Lacey Act is retroactive. He says they're worried they might be forced to prove the provenance of wood that they acquired decades ago.

RONALD BIENSTOCK: There hasn't been that moment that people have, quote, "tested the case." What is compliance? What is actual compliance? How have I complied? And has there been a ruling on it? We're lacking that.

HAVIGHURST: He's even warned clients to be wary of traveling abroad with old guitars, because the law says owners can be asked to account for every wooden part of their guitars when re-entering the U.S. The law also covers the trade in vintage instruments.

GEORGE GRUHN: It is a nightmare.

HAVIGHURST: Nashville's George Gruhn is one of the world's top dealers of old guitars, banjos and other rare stringed instruments.

GRUHN: And I'm frustrated because when they regulate the content of vintage instruments, I can't help it if they used Brazilian rosewood on almost every guitar made prior to 1970. I'm not contributing to cutting down Brazilian rosewood today.

HAVIGHURST: Gruhn acknowledges that the government has tried to create exemptions to cover vintage instruments. But he says they are rife with delays and to play it safe, he's nearly eliminated the 40 percent of his business that used to deal with overseas buyers.

JOHNSON: This is a new normal and it takes getting used to.

HAVIGHURST: The Environmental Investigation Agency's Andrea Johnson defends the Lacey Act and the government's attempts to enforce it.

JOHNSON: Nobody here wants this law to founder on unintended consequences because ultimately everybody understands that the intent here is to reduce illegal logging and send a signal to the markets that you've got to be asking questions and sourcing wood in a responsible way.

HAVIGHURST: What constitutes that responsible way may only become clear when the government finally charges Gibson and the company gets the day in court it says it wants so badly. For NPR News, I'm Craig Havighurst in Nashville.

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to NPR. This transcript is provided for personal, noncommercial use only, pursuant to our Terms of Use. Any other use requires NPR's prior permission. Visit our permissions page for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR's programming is the audio.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.