DAVID BIANCULLI, HOST:
This is FRESH AIR. I'm TV critic David Bianculli.
This Sunday, Discovery Channel presents the first two installments of "Frozen Planet," its newest nature documentary made in collaboration with England's BBC TV. It's from the same team that produced the brilliantly photographed "Planet Earth," and I love this new TV series just as much. But once again, I have the same single complaint, the one grating flaw in an otherwise exceptional television program. I don't want to complain about "Frozen Planet," however, until I dish out a little praise.
"Frozen Planet" is the kind of program that television was made for - and, even more certainly, the kind that modern TV was made for. This series not only takes us, quite literally, to the coldest, most remote places on Earth, but captures images of so much majesty, artistry, and clarity, it's almost ridiculous. On a large-screen, high-definition TV, watching "Frozen Planet" is like having your own personal IMAX theater.
The newest technology affects not only how we see these images, but how they're photographed. Even since "Planet Earth" was made a handful of years ago, advances in video technology have allowed camera crews, armed with the latest equipment, to capture action in unprecedented ways.
There's even time-lapse photography so precise, and so carefully planned out, that it pans and zooms while telescoping weeks and months into less than a minute. The result is a glacier that advances like a slow-motion bulldozer, crushing and moving everything in its path.
The images are fantastic. A mammoth elephant seal, protecting his claim to a female, engages in a furious, bloody fight with an encroaching male. And if he's successful, he has to fight again - almost once an hour for several days, each time battling a fresh, determined rival. At the end, we see a dazed, bloody, obviously exhausted elephant seal making his way back to his mate. He may not be wondering whether she was worth it all, but I sure was.
And that's the thing about any nature documentary done well. One thing it should do is make us cherish, and think about, the beauty and value and fragility of the natural world. More on that in a minute.
The other thing it should do is make us empathize with the natural drama of everyday survival. Television has been doing this quite effectively ever since "The Undersea World of Jacques Cousteau" and the nature specials presented by Walt Disney. And it's true that in many places in "Frozen Planet," the narration, the music, and the simple storytelling combine to make it all feel like a much higher-tech equivalent of one of those Disney programs.
Narrator Alec Baldwin in the episode called "Spring," describes the nest-building efforts of some Antarctic penguins. The males, he explains, build nests out of small pebbles on patches of dry land, because eggs would freeze within minutes if resting on snow or ice.
And in this scene, the camera tracks one male penguin as he makes the long trek to find, and return with, one pebble at a time. The camera also catches a neighbor penguin who waits until the other's back is turned to steal his rock. This happens again and again, and everything about the way it's presented makes it look, and sound, like a silent film comedy or a classic Disney nature moment.
(SOUNDBITE OF DOCUMENTARY, "FROZEN PLANET")
ALEC BALDWIN: (Narrating) The hapless victim seems completely unaware he's being robbed blind, but somehow, the more rocks he gathers, the smaller his nest becomes.
(Narrating) Meanwhile, the thief's nest is coming along nicely, probably because he keeps a sharp eye out for rock robbers. After all, it takes one to know.
BIANCULLI: And that leads to my problem with Discovery Channel's "Frozen Planet." As with "Planet Earth," where the American Network hired Sigourney Weaver to replace the original narration by Sir David Attenborough, this time Alec Baldwin gets the call.
Attenborough survives, however, on the most important episode of the series called "On Thin Ice," because that's the one where he speaks, from very personal experience as more than 50 years as a BBC nature documentary filmmaker about how and why the Earth is changing. And, yes, globally warming.
Replacing Attenborough, for any of these shows, is very insulting. But everything else about "Frozen Planet" is very inspiring. Even the "Making of" episode is a winner. Listen to Mark, a cameraman who's waited weeks to capture the moment when a frozen waterfall suddenly thaws. As he finally – and barely – gets the angle, and the daylight, to get the shot he needs. Baldwin sets the stage.
(SOUNDBITE OF DOCUMENTARY, "FROZEN PLANET")
BALDWIN: (Narrating) In the middle of the night, as the "Frozen Planet" team feared, the town was alerted that the frozen waterfall was about to break.
MARK: They just called a full evacuation of the island where we're staying and if we don't move now we're all going to be on the water, and possibly get trapped her from a few days.
BALDWIN: (Narrating) They had to race to the waterfall, hoping that it didn't give way before daybreak.
(Narrating) It held off and they got there just in time.
MARK: That is a serious amount of ice coming around the corner.
After weeks of waiting, sleepy giant of a river, we thought nothing was going to happen, and suddenly look at this. This is what we're here for. Unbelievable. Absolutely unbelievable.
BIANCULLI: The executive producer of "Frozen Planet," Alastair Fothergill, has worked on "Planet Earth," "Blue Planet," and Attenborough's classic "The Trials of Life." The two even teamed up for a previous visit to the Antarctic, almost 20 years ago, for a fine series called "Life in the Freezer."
But it's good to know, somehow, that with all this knowledge, all these brilliant filmmakers, and all this modern equipment, many times getting just the right shot, at just the right time, is a matter of dumb, simple luck. And that makes me feel very lucky to be able to sit back in the comfort of my own home, and watch the astonishing results.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR's programming is the audio.