NPR logo

Hearing In Megaupload Case To Determine Fate Of Users' Data

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Hearing In Megaupload Case To Determine Fate Of Users' Data

Hearing In Megaupload Case To Determine Fate Of Users' Data

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Companies like Apple, Google and Amazon are trying to get more customers to store everything from family photos to favorite films online in what's known as cloud-based storage. Today, a hearing in the criminal copyright case of the file-sharing site Megaupload could have implications for all kinds of cloud-based businesses. The hearing will focus on what happens when clearly legal files get blocked by authorities, along with allegedly illegal ones. NPR's Laura Sydell reports.

LAURA SYDELL, BYLINE: Kyle Godwin was a customer of Megaupload, and last January he was having a very bad day. He's building a new business taking videos of local sports teams in Cleveland. He sells highlights to family and friends of the players. He backed all his material up on a hard drive, but then...

KYLE GODWIN: Right in the middle of a save I knocked if off my coffee table and it hit the floor. And I can't get any of the files off of that external hard drive, and that was basically everything I've worked on for the last six months.

SYDELL: Argh. Then Godwin remembered he had a paid account with Megaupload, where he had most of his files backed up. Godwin went to the site to retrieve his videos.

GODWIN: But all I got was the opening screen. Then I couldn't get into any of the files, couldn't get into the file manager. I didn't know what was going on.

SYDELL: What was going on was that the Justice Department had shut down Megaupload and arrested several of its top executives for criminal copyright infringement. The DOJ claimed that the vast majority of traffic from the site's 66 million customers was illegal.

GODWIN: When I heard about that, I'm like, this doesn't even involve me. So how do I get my files back? I need them now.

SYDELL: Godwin may never get them back. That's what the lawyers are in court about this morning. Megaupload rented servers from a company called Carpathia Hosting. That's where Godwin's files are. Megaupload is the only one that can unlock the files of customers like Kyle Godwin, and they have been shut out by the Federal government. Carpathia is asking a Federal court to tell it what to do with the servers.

The Justice Department refused to give an interview, but in court documents, it's asking the judge not to get involved in what it calls a private contractual matter between Carpathia and Megaupload.

The online civil rights group the Electronic Frontier Foundation is filing a brief on behalf of Godwin and other innocent customers. Julie Samuels is an attorney with the EFF, and she says this online case shouldn't be any different than a real-world case, say if a bank were to be seized.

JULIE SAMUELS: There are innocent third parties who might have items at that bank in a safety deposit box, in some other kind of deposit account. And the law - and the Constitution, frankly - contemplate a way for those innocent third parties to get their grandmother's pearls back.

SYDELL: Samuels says there's no reason that the digital world should be different from the real one, except - well, it is. Jim Burger, a copyright attorney, says in this case, we are talking about a huge among of material, and the court would probably have to appoint someone to sort through it.

JIM BURGER: To say, oh, yes, this 100 megabytes is Mr. Smith's, and it's legal. It's his personal stuff. But this 50 megabytes is clear infringing. It would take forever for humans to sort through 25 petabytes of data.

SYDELL: Yet Burger and Samuels agree that the implications of what happens to the material on the servers are great. Companies like Google, Amazon and Apple are trying to entice their customers to store more stuff online, from family photos to legally purchased films. If Megaupload's legitimate customers can't retrieve their files, Burger admits many people will be afraid to use cloud storage.

BURGER: If I'm in the cloud storage business, I want this done right.

SYDELL: Ultimately, says Burger, there are no laws directly applicable. It will be up to the judge to determine what is fair.

Laura Sydell, NPR News.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.