NPR logo
Canceling Out The 'Background Noise' On Egypt-Israel Relations
  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Canceling Out The 'Background Noise' On Egypt-Israel Relations



So, just how precarious is the current relationship between Egypt and Israel? We've asked Rob Malley of the International Crisis Group to come in and help us explore that issue with us. He's the program director for the Middle East and North Africa. Rob, welcome back.


GREENE: Stability between Egypt and Israel - I mean, it's long been a bedrock in what's an incredibly volatile part of the world. Are we witnessing some sort of fundamental shift in that relationship?

MALLEY: Not yet. I mean, what we're seeing right now is a lot of noise but no real change, partly because, if not essentially because, both Israelis and the Egyptian security establishment believe that the relationship is critical for both of them. So, they're not about to endanger it. But - and it's a big but because of what, everything that's happening in the region is leading towards greater uncertainty, greater confusion. There are going to be changes in Egypt. There have been changes but they haven't yet been translated into a shift in foreign policy.

GREENE: Let's talk about some of that noise, the rhetoric that we've been hearing from both sides. We have Israel's foreign minister saying that Egypt is a greater threat to Israel than Iran. I mean, that is pretty incendiary. How did you interpret that?

MALLEY: If you or I had a - were given a penny for every time the foreign minister said something incendiary, neither one would have the job we currently do. But the one thing about foreign minister Lieberman is that he scratches where it itches. In other words, when he speaks about something, it resonates with the Israeli public and it is indicative of a feeling that the Israeli public has. So, when he says that he's scared about the future of Egyptian-Israeli relations, he's not really saying, or he's not really representing, a panic among Israeli officials that they think that tomorrow something's going to change and the Camp David Accord is going to be scrapped. What he's saying is we look at Egypt, we don't know where things are headed and we don't like what we see in the Sinai, where there's a security vacuum. We don't like what we hear from some Egyptian politicians, so we got to be careful.

GREENE: You mentioned, of course, the Camp David Accords, which in 1979 led to the peace treaty between these two countries. On the Egypt side, there was one member of the Muslim Brotherhood who was quoted as saying that safety along the Israel-Egypt border in Sinai cannot be maintained under the current requirements in Camp David. Is that the beginning of sort of tinkering away at that accord or is that peace treaty still safe?

MALLEY: For now, it's still safe. And I think we have to distinguish between some of the background noise and what are the real interests of the parties involved. You're going to hear a lot. You've heard foreign minister Lieberman. You're going to hear Egyptians saying things. But deep down, neither Israel nor the Egyptian military, nor even the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood has an interest in undermining relations with Israel, relations with the United States because all prefer stability. And for the Muslim Brotherhood in particular, what they want to do is have a chance at governing and they want to have a chance at succeeding at governing. And in order to do that, they need stability, they need economic assistance from the U.S. They can't afford to have a conflict at their borders. So, I think there's going to be some of these noises. But, as I said, a lot of it is relatively insignificant.

GREENE: Well, Rob, you say things are sort of holding together for now and we're waiting for changes to come. Egypt has the first presidential election since the fall of Hosni Mubarak coming this May and maybe a runoff in June. I mean, what moment, what type of event are you looking for when we might bring you into this studio and you would say now we have a real problem, now there's really a moment of concern in this relationship?

MALLEY: The most likely scenario in my view is if the Muslim Brotherhood Islamists really come to power and they face what I think inevitably they will face: great difficulties on the economic field, great difficulties in running the country in terms of security and they start facing a discontented, dissatisfied population, which is going to ask them, what have you done for us? That's when I think you might see the Muslim Brotherhood, the leadership saying we need to appeal to our constituency, either by going back with some rigorous sort of the old-fashioned social issues or by distracting the population by turning them to pay attention to foreign policy and that's when they might start escalating the rhetoric when it comes to Israel. That's one scenario that I think one would worry about. The other scenario is if something were to happen in Gaza, and whether it's initiated by Israel or by Hamas - the Islamist movement that controls Gaza - I think under the circumstances where you have public opinion in Egypt that matters today far more than it has in the recent decades, where you might have the Muslim Brotherhood controlling the government and perhaps the presidency, Egypt will not be able to sit idly by as it has on past occasions if Israel were to start attacking Gaza in response to the rocket attack or simply as a preemptive move. And that could really endanger the relationship.

GREENE: Rob Malley is the program director for the Middle East and North Africa at the International Crisis Group. Rob, thanks so much, as always, for coming in.

MALLEY: Thanks for having me.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.