Pop Culture


The BBC drama series "Sherlock" returns for a second season Sunday on PBS. Our critic-at-large John Powers has been thinking about why the character of Sherlock Holmes continues to fascinate us.

JOHN POWERS, BYLINE: One of my favorite professors, the late Ian Watt, taught that there were four great myths of modern individualism: Faust, Don Juan, Don Quixote and Robinson Crusoe. This always got me wondering which, if any, pop-culture heroes might endure in the same way. James Bond? Luke Skywalker? The Avengers? Come on. In fact, there's only one who I feel sure will last: Sherlock Holmes.

In the 125 years since Arthur Conan Doyle created the world's greatest detective, 75 different actors have played him in the movies, and scads more on TV, not to mention the countless knockoffs like "The Mentalist" or Mr. Spock, who once claimed Holmes as his ancestor.

We've had him as a teen in "Young Sherlock Holmes," a wise-cracking action star played by Robert Downey, Jr., and as a retired beekeeper in Michael Chabon's terrific little novel "The Final Solution," where he encounters the crime of the century: the Holocaust. Now he's been updated as a present-day Londoner in "Sherlock," the British TV series w offers the best version of Holmes and Dr. Watson I've ever seen.

The obvious reason for Holmes' enduring appeal is that, while he possesses no superpowers - his parents weren't wizards, no radioactive spider bit him - his gifts are cool enough to be superhuman. Playing to fantasies of being smarter than everyone else, Holmes performs jaw-dropping feats of perception, like this one in the first episode of "Sherlock": Martin Freeman's Dr. Watson has known Holmes all of 90 seconds when Sherlock, played by Benedict Cumberbatch, talks about renting a flat together and gives Watson a taste of just who, or maybe what he's dealing with.


MARTIN FREEMAN: (As Watson) Is that it?

BENEDICT CUMBERBATCH: (As Holmes) Is that what?

FREEMAN: (As Watson) We've only just met, and we're going to go and look at a flat. We don't know a thing about each other. I don't know where we're meeting. I don't even know your name.

CUMBERBATCH: (As Holmes) I know you're an army doctor and you've been invalided home from Afghanistan. I know you've got a brother who's worried about you, but you won't go to him for help because you don't approve of him, possibly because he's an alcoholic, more likely because he recently walked out on his wife. And I know your therapist thinks that your limp is psychosomatic - quite correctly, I'm afraid. It's enough to be going on with, don't you think?

(As Holmes) The name's Sherlock Holmes, and the address is 221B Baker Street. Afternoon.

POWERS: As you can tell, this Holmes is a bit of a showman, one who feels sure that he ought to be mythic. He's right. Like all mythic figures, Sherlock embodies an archetypal aspect of the human psyche - in his case, the power of rational thought. I am a brain, he tells Watson in one story. The rest of me is mere appendix. And as a brain, he is the embodiment of the scientific mind.

A relentless empiricist, he not only notices details that ordinary folks don't, but he treats all of reality - from tobacco ashes to a dog that doesn't bark - as a collection of clues. He puts these clues together to solve baffling crimes, which can involve a pygmy murderer, a poisonous snake or a gigantic hound.

Now, lasting mythic heroes tend to emerge during periods of psychosocial tumult, when old values are being threatened by new ones. Holmes came to life in 1887, during the waning years of a Victorian era, in which everything from the traditional social order to the belief in God was being subverted.

It's no accident that this same period produced three other literary creations who spoke to a sense of chaotic darkness bubbling beneath the surface of things: the blood-drinking Dracula, the murderously schizoid Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and, of course, Peter Pan, who refused to grow up into the complicated world of adulthood. Their mythic power still persists, but mainly as metaphors, like the Peter Pan Complex, or in the welter of hip vampires roaming our pop culture.

Sherlock remains Sherlock. Of course, darkness bubbles in Holmes' world, too. If he lacks the tragic dimension of Faust - a fellow thinking machine, but one with ambitions so grand they damn him - he's not a cipher like 007 or Hercule Poirot. His monomaniacal genius borders on sociopathy. It cuts him off from humanity.

He has but one friend, Watson - his Sancho Panza, and our surrogate - and but one great love, Irene Adler, whose appearance opens season two of "Sherlock" with a bang.

When he's not solving crimes, boredom and melancholy lead Holmes to the violin, or cocaine. Yet if Holmes' desire for oblivion hints at the lonely man lurking beneath the brilliant superman, it remains less potent than his sheer joy in asserting rational control over purveyors of chaos, like his archenemy, Professor Moriarty. Detective stories are all about learning the truth and restoring order. That's their power. And for Holmes, that's also their fun.

Indeed, one reason why Sherlock still feels so fresh is his pleasure in the chase. Never dull or moralistic, he embodies that part of us that's turned on by a mystery, who, when he hears of a murder, feels that special tingle and cries: Come, Watson. Come. The game is afoot.

GROSS: John Powers is film and TV critic for Vogue and Vogue.com. The second season of "Sherlock" premiers Sunday on PBS' "Masterpiece Mystery." You can download podcasts of our show on our website: freshair.npr.org, and you can follow us on Twitter @nprfreshair, and on Tumblr at nprfreshair.tumblr.com.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from