Income Inequality In The San Francisco Bay Area


We're spending some time this week in the Bay Area of California. Our tech reporting team is exploring its place in American culture and the economy. This is a part of the country where rents have been skyrocketing, fueled by tight housing stock and the latest tech boom. NPR's Elise Hu found some young professionals who've turned the situation into an opportunity.


ELISE HU, BYLINE: In this crowded kitchen of a huge San Francisco house, sweet potato peanut soup is on the stove, and someone's marinating steak for later.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN: Garlic, olive oil.

HU: No fewer than nine people take part in this organized chaos of cooking, and it happens here at least twice a week.

JESSY SCHINGLER: Food is a core component of what we do, and I think it's something that is a really easy way to unite people in a really low pressure kind of environment.

HU: Jessy Schingler - a former NASA engineer - lives in this house with a dozen other professionals with different jobs. They include an architect, a tech entrepreneur and someone who works in the mayor's office. Schingler says this kind of kitchen commotion creates community, so long as everyone abides by the one sacred rule: No dishes get left in the sink. It's part of keeping order when you live with so many friends.

SCHINGLER: We live here, but we also host events. We have hackathons and we have salons and we have concerts.

HU: She estimates there are now about 50 of these big group living arrangements in and around the Bay Area, where 10 or more unrelated folks move in together in grand estates. They share groceries, some meals and cars. Just be careful about calling this a commune.

DEREK DUNFIELD: It is certainly a way to say it, but there's a whole bunch of negative things that come out of that word.

HU: That's Derek Dunfield, a behavioral economist and a housemate here.

DUNFIELD: Yes. It's absolutely a modern commune. We prefer the term co-living. I think what it really is, is an example of what the sharing economy can actually do.

HU: He's lived in this 7,500-square-foot place since the group moved in a year and a half ago.

DUNFIELD: We found this place on Craig's List. It's an old Edwardian mansion, three stories.

HU: The common areas feature large living and dining spaces...


HU: ...even a music room and...


HU: early 1900s bowling alley in the basement.


HU: In addition to fun, they get some economies of scale by sharing. Census numbers show San Franciscans pay the highest rent in the country, prices driven by the latest tech boom and a maxed-out market. Median rent for a two-bedroom apartment here is $3,200. But co-livers can pay half that.

DAVID SOBEL: San Francisco is way too hot right now.

HU: David Sobel heads the San Francisco Housing Development Corporation, a non-profit that advocates for affordable housing options in the city.

SOBEL: You need to be a millionaire, really, to buy a home at the median home price nowadays. That does not bode well for an overall diverse and healthy city, which is one of the great traditions of San Francisco.

HU: Sobel says he likes that young professionals have found ways to make city dwelling possible, because cities do need income diversity. But when mansions get scooped up quickly, it does make an impact on the market.

SOBEL: So that individuals and families that are looking to purchase or rent those same resources are going to have even more competition to do so. Ultimately, I think there needs to be a balance between those two forces.

HU: Plenty of the co-living folks feel the same way. That's why they're expanding to other parts of Bay Area, like Berkeley, just east of San Francisco.


HU: Here, two business school grads head up a smaller co-living house.


HU: They say it's more than just random roommates coming together. Instead, co-founder Jay Standish says co-living is a way that online connections are turning into offline communities.

STANDISH: In some ways, this is the millennial generation's take on how to live together. Maybe we say social networking, but that's actually just community, or a tribe or a village.

HU: Technology brought them together, but they realize this kind of lifestyle dates to the beginning of civilization.

Co-founder Ben Provan.

BEN PROVAN: It's definitely a case of going back to the future. One of the differences that I think distinguishes it is we now have tools and technologies that allow us to organize in better and different ways.

HU: Now the founders of the San Francisco house and this Berkeley home have organized themselves into a startup real estate business. They're now enticing investors to help them buy some big homes.


HU: On this morning, the guys are checking out a building for sale in Berkeley, not far from a BART public transit station. The place has a retail storefront on the first level, and residential above

PROVAN: Couple of bay windows. It says, on the top, 1904. That means it was just before the earthquake. There's potential.


HU: Back in the rented mansion in San Francisco, dinner's served.


HU: About 20 people - housemates and some guests - sit around a table, lit by an antique chandelier.



HU: They were once strangers. Online networks made them friends, and living together makes them more like family. After dinner, in keeping with the one rule of this giant house, someone will do all the dishes.

Elise Hu, NPR News.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from