Filmmaker Jason Reitman has made his reputation with bittersweet comedies, films like "Juno" and "Up in the Air." But today, he's premiering a different kind of film. "Labor Day" is an unabashed romance starring Kate Winslet and Josh Brolin. Whether or not Reitman had trouble with the shift, our critic Bob Mondello certainly did.

BOB MONDELLO, BYLINE: Here's the setup: It's 1987 and Frank, a ruggedly handsome, convicted murderer, has escaped from prison and is holding Adele, a fragile divorcee, and her 13-year-old son, Henry, captive in their own house until they eat his chili. It's good chili - so good that it inspires Adele, who the ruggedly handsome convict has tied up, to reminisce about a conversation she had with her son about his sex education class. Seriously, the chili is that good - or maybe Frank is just that ruggedly handsome. Anyway, later, Adele frees herself.


JOSH BROLIN: (As Frank) When you have to say I tied you up, you won't be lying.

MONDELLO: And Frank, who must've been really handy to have around in the prison...


BROLIN: (As Frank) I could try to help out.

MONDELLO: ...starts angling for the title of dreamiest kidnapper ever. He changes the oil in Adele's car, replaces the filter on her furnace, washes and waxes her floors and even takes Henry, who he calls Hank - because remember, he's rugged - out into the yard and teaches him to play baseball.


BROLIN: (As Frank) Choke up on the bat, hands together.

MONDELLO: All of which is nothing next to what happens when a neighbor leaves a bushel of peaches at their door.


KATE WINSLET: (As Adele) You should throw most of them away before they rot.

BROLIN: (As Frank) I have another idea.

MONDELLO: Soon, Frank, joined by Henry and Adele, are all plunging their hands into a big bowl of cut peaches - massaging them into submission, I guess - at which point, Frank says, what I want to talk about is crust. And there's another montage of hands smooshing flour and butter; dough rolled and piled high with filling, with half the dough reserved for the moment when Frank guides Adele's hands toward the pie plate and together they, in his words, put the roof on this house.


TOBEY MAGUIRE: (As Henry) Her hands started shaking beyond her control.

MONDELLO: And who could blame them? Hilarious, right? Except the movie is entirely straight-faced. I kept thinking, the guy who made "Juno" made this? It's the sort of over-baked melodrama that used to be called a woman's picture, though no one would call it that now for fear of insulting women.


BROLIN: (As Frank) I should go.

WINSLET: (As Adele) You should stay.

MONDELLO: Kate Winslet trembles vulnerably in the presence of Josh Brolin's manly perfection, making it seem as if all any woman really needs around the house is a convicted murderer. The filming is as polished as you'd expect from Jason Reitman, and parts of the picture are decently suspenseful, mostly because the music keeps turning ominous every time Brolin comes into a room; also maybe because convict kidnapping stories rarely work out very well, even when they're filled with warmth and autumn's falling leaves.

"Labor Day" was originally scheduled to open on Christmas Day, which made no sense. Then someone thought better of that and held it until now so it could be a prelude to Valentine's Day, I suppose. Might be best to just consider it an early harbinger of spring. For sure, the sap is rising. I'm Bob Mondello.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.