Eating And Health


Now, if you want to be one of those healthier people, you've likely heeded advice to limit fat in your diet, especially from food like meat, eggs and cheese. We've heard that advice for decades. But the evidence suggests fat is not quite the villain we've been told.

NPR's Allison Aubrey has the first of two stories.

ALLISON AUBREY, BYLINE: If you want to trace our fear of fat, Washington, D.C., is a good place to start, right at the U.S. Capitol.

DON RITCHIE: So over here is a statue of George Shoup, who was a senator from Idaho.

AUBREY: That's Senate historian Don Ritchie, and he says Shoup was a beefy guy.

RITCHIE: Yes, he protrudes. (Laughter)His belly sticks way out, beyond his waistcoat.

AUBREY: And this was considered to be...

RITCHIE: This was the epitome of success, in the late 19th century. A large man was somebody who had accomplished something.

AUBREY: And corpulence was still a sign of power in the 1950s. As we stroll past a Senate dining room, Ritchie shows me a menu printed in May 1954.

RITCHIE: We have, for instance, deep-fried Southern chicken, you know, lots of mashed potatoes with gravy.

AUBREY: There were sweetbreads, Salisbury steak, buttered succotash and pineapple cheesecake.

RITCHIE: Yes. A lot of hearty food - and this was mid-day.

AUBREY: The economy was booming, and many Americans were living high on the hog. But soon that prosperity began to cast a dark shadow within the halls of Congress.

RITCHIE: You look at the statistics, members were dying at a rather large rate.

AUBREY: This was an era when it was not uncommon for American men to drop dead of heart attacks. In the '60s and '70s, eight senators died in office of heart disease.

RITCHIE: When you have colleagues who die prematurely, that's sort of a wake-up call.

AUBREY: The harms of smoking were already on the radar, but scientists were just beginning to make connections between diet and heart disease. Sen. George McGovern, of South Dakota, decided the government should put the issue on the front burner. So, he called a hearing and summoned the likes of Nathan Pritikin, a longevity guru who believed that diet could reverse disease, and a Harvard professor who pointed to preliminary evidence that eggs and meat raised cholesterol. The message that came out of this hearing was that America's problem was the overconsumption of fat.

GARY TAUBES: The thinking of the day was that you wanted to reduce fat consumption.

AUBREY: Gary Taubes is a science writer who's written extensively on this topic. He says the hearing led to the first set of U.S. dietary guidelines. And Taubes says once fat was fingered as the villain, the thought was that any way you could get it out of the diet had to be a good thing.

TAUBES: And if we did it by merely replacing, you know, milk and cheese and fatty meat with carbohydrates - with pasta and potatoes and rice - this would make us live longer, and it would make us thinner.

AUBREY: Now, to be fair, Taubes says the kind of carbohydrates the guideline writers had in mind were whole grains, fruits and vegetables. But this message was lost in translation. What Americans heard was fat is bad, and carbs are good. And the food industry saw the low-fat, high-carb mantra as an opportunity to create a whole new range of products. Remember fat-free frozen yogurt? Or how about Snackwells?


UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESS #1: (As character) Excuse me. Do you make these delicious, fat-free Snackwells devils food cookies?

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR: (As character) Why, yes I do.

UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESS #2: (As character) You wanna tell us why we can't find them in the stores anymore?

AUBREY: Foods with little or no fat flew off the shelves. Pretzels were good; nuts were bad. Baked potatoes were fine, but hold the sour cream.

TAUBES: By the early 1990s, the whole country had effectively gone on a low-fat diet.

AUBREY: But for many Americans, a low-fat diet meant more sugar, more refined grains and more packaged foods. And what happened?

TAUBES: Right around this time is when America starts getting fatter and more diabetic.

AUBREY: And a number of experts says that in trying to address one problem - heart disease - by removing fat, the original dietary guidelines actually made things worse.

MARY FLYNN: There were definitely unintended consequences of the original guidelines.

AUBREY: That's Mary Flynn, a professor of medicine at Brown University. And she says over the last 40 years, research has shown that the fat people have been trying so hard to avoid is not the enemy it was thought to be.

FLYNN: There's been a number of studies done, and there's been no benefit for low-fat diets to lead to better weight loss, and there's no benefit for low-fat diets to lead to less disease.

AUBREY: What's clear now, she says, is that avoiding fat is not the key to a healthy diet. Allison Aubrey, NPR News.


WERTHEIMER: Monday, Allison reports on why eating some fats can be good for you.



Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from