DAVE DAVIES, HOST:
This is FRESH AIR. The new feature, "Obvious Child," by writer and director Gillian Robespierre, began as a short film released in 2009. It stars comedian Jenny Slate as an up-and-coming comic faced with an unexpected pregnancy. Film critic David Edelstein has this review.
DAVID EDELSTEIN: "Obvious Child" centers on Donna Stern played by Jenny Slate, an aspiring standup comic in her late twenties who's out of her depth in the grown-up world. After getting smashed and having unprotected sex with a guy she barely knows, Donna discovers she's pregnant and decides to have an abortion. It shouldn't be a particularly earth-shaking turn, but in a world of rom-coms like "Knocked Up" and "Juno," in which the heroines make the heartwarming decision to go ahead with their pregnancies, this modest little indie movie feels momentous. Director Gillian Robespierre has a good last name for a revolutionary. But it's not a revolution with placards and manifestoes. It's a revolution of small, embarrassing truths. "Obvious Child" begins with Donna standing before a mic in a Williamsburg, Brooklyn club, making fun of her Jewish features and her farts and implying it's a miracle she even has a boyfriend. That boyfriend, Ryan, is standing in the back, scowling. He doesn't seem to like her exhibitionism. In fact, he's fixing to dump her. Of course, male comics have gotten away with self-humiliation for decades. But it's only recently that women like Sarah Silverman, Amy Schumer and, in a different context, Lena Dunham, have suggested that one mark of power is the right to parade one's weaknesses in front of the world. The fictional Donna Stern is figuring out, in front of our eyes, how much of herself she can expose on stage. I imagine some audiences won't have much patience with her. She really is a child. She lets herself be babied by her adorable, leftist, teddy bear dad, played by Richard Kind. And she's patronized and financially supported by her super-competent business professor mom, played by Polly Draper. When she gets pregnant after sleeping with an earnest, Vermont-bred business student Max, played by Jake Lacy, she spends a lot of time dodging his overtures. She doesn't seem to know her own mind. All through the film, she's propped up by her pal, played by Gaby Hoffmann, and the comedy club's MC, played by Gabe Liedman. Over dinner, she tells them Max came into the bookstore where she works. He found her sitting in a cardboard box.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "OBVIOUS CHILD")
JENNY SLATE: (As Donna Stern) I can't believe he walked into the store. That's a sign.
GABY HOFFMANN: (As Nellie) And that would be a sign saying...?
SLATE: (As Donna Stern) Like, that I'm a present in a box. And that he and I should go and start our beautiful life together.
GABE LIEDMAN: (As Joey) You know, I'm not a straight guy...
SLATE: (As Donna Stern) Oh, what?
LIEDMAN: (As Joey) But my guess is that most of them would hate that gift.
SLATE: (As Donna Stern) What? You're saying that a guy doesn't want a drunk pregnant girl in a box?
HOFFMANN: (As Nellie) If you're a serial killer.
LIEDMAN: (As Joey) Maybe you want to tell him.
HOFFMANN: (As Nellie) No. Why? Why? You don't owe him anything. You don't even know this guy.
SLATE: (As Donna Stern) Maybe he just deserves to know that, like, this happened. And that I'm not a psycho and I'm going to get an abortion.
EDELSTEIN: Donna never does figure out how to tell Max what's going on. But then, most viewers probably won't figure out Max. He's not filled in. And when he turns out to be, by sheer coincidence, a business student of Donna's mom, it seems like a setup for a joke that never comes. But if Max isn't believable, Donna feels so real she could be sitting next to you in the theater. Jenny Slate can be seen opposite Nick Kroll in drag on the "Kroll Show," in a weekly, reality TV send-up called "PubLIZity," about two jittery LA publicists named Liz. She's even more famous for blowing her "Saturday Night Live" debut several years ago by blurting the F-word on live TV. I found that rather endearing and hoped Slate would get her own show. She didn't. She barely lasted out the year. But what I love about her in "Obvious Child" is that sense of danger she brings. She's all frizzy, little coils of neurotic energy. Anything could pop out of her mouth. That fits a character who has no self-control, a big baby, someone who can't take care of herself let alone a little baby. Director Gillian Robespierre lets you take Donna as you will. Robespierre has the courage of her ambivalence. The best thing about "Obvious Child" is that there's nothing obvious about it.
DAVIES: David Edelstein is film critic for New York Magazine. For Terry Gross, I'm Dave Davies.