'Lions for Lambs' Robert Redford, Meryl Streep and Tom Cruise in a whither-the-war-on-terrorism drama. Everyone's heart is definitely in the right place, but the film amounts to two hectoring lectures and a mountaintop standoff.

Review

Culture

'Lions for Lambs'

Right-thinking: Tom Cruise argues the conservative case in Lions for Lambs. David James/United Artists hide caption

toggle caption
David James/United Artists

Right-thinking: Tom Cruise argues the conservative case in Lions for Lambs.

David James/United Artists
  • Director: Robert Redford
  • Genre: Drama/Thriller
  • Running Time: 88 minutes

Clip: 'Engagement'

Everyone's heart is definitely in the right place, but this lifeless real-time drama amounts to two hectoring lectures and a mountaintop standoff.

Actually, "drama" overstates the case: Robert Redford directs, and also plays a liberal university professor who urges his best student (an utterly charmless Andrew Garfield) to devote himself to doing good in the world.

While he's doing that, a skeptical TV interviewer (Meryl Streep) sits in a Washington office grilling a conservative senator (Tom Cruise) about the next step in the war on terrorism — even as that next step is playing out grimly for two U.S. soliders (Derek Luke and Michael Pena) atop a mountain in Afghanistan.

Cruise, snarky and vaguely reptilian, is the only one who comes off very well, though it's hard to blame the performers: They're being ambushed by an expository, painfully implausible script every time it rounds a plot twist.