Turkish Cleric Tops List Of Intellectuals When the votes came in for Prospect magazine's list of the top 100 public intellectuals, at No. 1 was Turkish Sufi cleric Fethullah Gulen. Prospect Magazine editor Tom Nuttall says Gulen's global network of supporters propelled him to the top spot.

Turkish Cleric Tops List Of Intellectuals

Turkish Cleric Tops List Of Intellectuals

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/92529367/92529348" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

When the votes came in for Prospect magazine's list of the top 100 public intellectuals, at No. 1 was Turkish Sufi cleric Fethullah Gulen. Prospect Magazine editor Tom Nuttall says Gulen's global network of supporters propelled him to the top spot.

Web Resources


What would Fethullah Gulen do? Or more important, what would Fethullah Gulen say? Those must be significant questions, given the results of a poll that was organized by the British magazine Prospect and the American magazine Foreign Policy. They asked their readers to pick the world's top public intellectuals from among a list of 100 contenders, names like Noam Chomsky; Peruvian novelist Mario Vargas Llosa; Russian chess great Garry Kasparov, who challenged Vladimir Putin for the presidency of Russia; Al Gore. Well, forget about it.

When the votes were in, it was the decline of the West. The top 10 finishers were all of Muslim background, and Tom Nuttall of Prospect Magazine joins us now to talk about public intellectual number one, Fethullah Gulen. Who is he?

Mr. TOM NUTTALL (Prospect Magazine): We at Prospect had barely heard of him at the time that we drew up this list, and in fact he was one of the last additions to the list. We drew up a long list of 100 names a couple of months ago, along with foreign policy. And Gulen, we wanted someone who represented contemporary Turkish Islamism.

He's Turkish and operated out of Turkey as a cleric for some decades in the '60s and '70s but was then forced into exile, and he wound up somewhere in - just outside Philadelphia, from where he's been operating his network.

His movement is, it's very pro-science. It's at home with globalization, with public relations. As we discovered with our poll, it's a very wired network. He was - once news of the poll reached Turkey, his network around the world was mobilized into action and was able to vote for him in absolutely vast numbers.

SIEGEL: Yes. Is what you have experienced here the digital equivalent of stuffing the ballot box?

(Soundbite of laughter)

Mr. NUTTALL: When the votes for Gulen started to pour in, the voting numbers were rising so quickly that I was absolutely convinced that we'd been hacked, that a very determined (unintelligible), that's the name for his followers, hacked his way into the system and was sort of voting in hundreds of thousands for this guy. But no, it turned out not to be true. These were all legitimate votes inasmuch as each vote came from a specific individual.

SIEGEL: Evidently the tripwire event here was a newspaper wrote about this, and evidently that's where a lot of his supporters learned that they could vote for him as public intellectual number one.

Mr. NUTTALL: That's right. When Zaman published the story - Zaman is the top-selling newspaper in Turkey. It's got a circulation of 700,000 or so - when they published the story, that was the event that triggered it. Before then, Gulen was nowhere. He was languishing in the mid-table. After Zaman published this story, he rocketed to the top of the list.

SIEGEL: Now, some people may recall that when Time magazine was polling readers worldwide about the greatest figures of the 20th century, there was a Turkish campaign to vote for Kamal Ataturk, founder of the Turkish Republic, so successful that he was coming out at the top of the list of best entertainers of the 20th century, in addition to every other category. It seems to be something that goes on in Turkey (unintelligible)...

Mr. NUTTALL: That's absolutely right. He was also leading Albert Einstein in the scientist category at one point. One of our correspondents, I was talking to him when this was going on, he's based in Istanbul, and he told me that everyone was talking about it, at least in the - among the Istanbul chattering classes, and at the same time as we published our poll, around the same time, Time magazine did another one of its lists. I think it was the 100 most influential people of the year or whatever it was, and there were two Turks on that. I'd never heard of either of them.

So there's something, I don't know what it is, a great desire to be respected by, I don't know, authoritative institutions within the West or to have the achievements of great Turks recognized outside of Turkey.

SIEGEL: Well, is Prospect magazine - do you have many subscribers in Turkey at this point, or are you pushing to increase the number soon?

Mr. NUTTALL: We're hoping to get a lot more. I mean, we quite cleverly, we made it compulsory for people who were voting to enter an e-mail address into the system, so we now, our e-mail newsletter list is now made up of about 95 percent Turks, I think.

(Soundbite of laughter)

SIEGEL: And you'll have to beef up your Sufism coverage for the magazine from here on in.

Mr. NUTTALL: Yeah, that's right.

SIEGEL: Well, Tom Nuttall of Prospect magazine in London. Thank you very much for talking with us.

Mr. NUTTALL: Thank you very much.

SIEGEL: And you can find a link to the foreign policy magazine and Prospect magazine's list of the top 100 public intellectuals at NPR.org.

Copyright © 2008 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Muslims Top New List of Public Intellectuals

Muslims Top New List of Public Intellectuals

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/91955326/91955306" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

Fethullah Gulen, a Turkish religious scholar, is known for reaching out to people of many faiths. fgulen.com hide caption

toggle caption

Time has its Person of the Year. People has its Sexiest Man Alive. Not to be outdone, Foreign Policy magazine has just completed its online survey of the world's top public intellectuals.

No. 1 on the list is Fethullah Gulen, a Muslim religious leader from Turkey. In fact, the top 10 of the leading 20 are all Muslim thinkers from countries with dominant Muslim populations.

That's not a coincidence, says Kate Palmer, a Foreign Policy editor. In addition to being highly subjective, the survey generated a competition fueled by legions of supporters and, in some cases, by the intellectuals themselves.

Gulen is closely associated with the Turkish daily newspaper, Zaman, which mentioned the poll on its front page in May. Within hours, his supporters were voting and waging a vigorous campaign online and through word of mouth. Foreign Policy notes that Gulen, who is considered by many to be a moderate Islamist, is controversial in Turkey because he's still seen as a threat to Turkish secularism.

Gulen has a global network of followers. Foreign Policy editors think that once Gulen's supporters cast their votes for him, they stuck around on the site and then voted for other Muslim thinkers. Still, says Palmer, Gulen garnered many more votes than the second intellectual on the list, Muhammad Yunus, whose efforts to promote microfinancing won him the Nobel Prize two years ago.

Palmer thinks that many upwardly mobile, educated Muslims may have seen the poll as a real opportunity for recognition. "Maybe it's an enthusiasm for being included in this list, when many of these people are ignored by so many in other parts of the world," she says.