On Lake Michigan, A Cleaner Coal-Powered Ship Ferries On The SS Badger — the largest coal-fired passenger ship operating in the U.S. — used to dump ash into the lake. After some alterations, the ship now plies its route without polluting the waters.
NPR logo

On Lake Michigan, A Cleaner Coal-Powered Ship Ferries On

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/410903693/410958579" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
On Lake Michigan, A Cleaner Coal-Powered Ship Ferries On

On Lake Michigan, A Cleaner Coal-Powered Ship Ferries On

On Lake Michigan, A Cleaner Coal-Powered Ship Ferries On

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/410903693/410958579" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

The coal-powered S.S. Badger pulls out of the Ludington, Mich., harbor in August 2011. This summer is the first season that the Badger is operating with its new ash retention system, which passes EPA standards. Denise Stocker/Chicago Tribune/MCT /Landov hide caption

toggle caption
Denise Stocker/Chicago Tribune/MCT /Landov

The coal-powered S.S. Badger pulls out of the Ludington, Mich., harbor in August 2011. This summer is the first season that the Badger is operating with its new ash retention system, which passes EPA standards.

Denise Stocker/Chicago Tribune/MCT /Landov

A slice of history sails across Lake Michigan, carrying cars between Ludington, Mich., and Manitowoc, Wis. It's the SS Badger: the largest coal-fired passenger ship still operating in the United States.

For years, the ship was the focus of environmental scrutiny because of its practice of dumping waste coal ash directly into the lake. The pollution nearly stopped the Badger from steaming again — but now, the ash-dumping has ended.

And this summer, after a half-century on the waters, the Badger is still ferrying on.

Brass And Telegraphs

With the blast of a horn, Captain Jeffery Curtis informs the city of Ludington that the Badger is leaving the port. Then he talks to the helmsman at the wheel and gives orders to the boiler room crew — with a bell.

The bell is connected to a communication device called a Chadburn. Curtis says the Badger, which has been sailing since 1953, is the only ship on the Great Lakes that still uses one.

"We are still working as if we were in mid-century here, so we have engine-order telegraphs to communicate our needs to the engineers down in the engine room," he says.

The pilothouse has a lot more brass and fewer computers than you'll see in newer ships, hearkening back to when seven ferries operated out of Ludington.

Now it's the only one.

Bryce Goddard of Cleveland, Tenn., braved a chilly but sunny morning to sit out on the deck watching Michigan fade away.

"I keep waiting for this shoreline to disappear, but it just lasts forever," she says. "Which I'm glad of. That's my last view of Michigan for a long time, probably."

Inside, passengers play bingo, watch a movie or TV, take a nap, read a book or use the Wi-Fi — because, yes, there is Wi-Fi on a coal-powered ferry.

From The Archives: 2013

The SS Badger has been making trips across the lake to Manitowoc, Wis., during the good-weather months since 1953. And as it runs, the 411-foot ferry discharges coal ash slurry directly into the lake. ...

Locals say the ship is a fundamental part of Ludington life — and brings $20 million into the local economy each year via jobs, motels, B&Bs, restaurants, gas stations, galleries and the bike shop.

Read more

A Greener Voyage

This trip almost wasn't possible.

After decades of letting the Badger pollute the lake, the Environmental Protection Agency issued an ultimatum: Stop dumping or be grounded.

Finally, this off-season, the boat's owner installed a $2 million solution: a set of blue pipes that collect ash each trip, about 500 tons per year.

Once a week, that ash gets trucked to Charlevoix, Mich., for use in making cement products.

Badger engineer Chuck Cart says it wasn't easy to install this new system.

"We don't have a lot of space here, so we needed to design a bin that would fit in the space that we weren't using to haul cars and trucks," he says.

The boat trip is only three to five hours shorter than driving around the lake, and there are certainly faster ferries at other Lake Michigan ports.

But Mary Lou Deutsch of Traverse City, Mich., says that's not the point.

"Life isn't for going fast. Life is for enjoying the ride. And this has been delightful," she says.

And now that the Badger runs a bit greener, a leisurely ride across Lake Michigan is no longer a guilty pleasure.