American Cancer Society Changes Mammogram Guidelines
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
We have major news today about how women should be screened for breast cancer. For the first time in more than a decade, the American Cancer Society is changing its recommendations. And NPR health correspondent Rob Stein is here to talk about it. Whatâs the recommendation?
ROB STEIN, BYLINE: Well, Steve, you know, for years, the Cancer Societyâs been telling women that once they hit 40, they should go in and get a mammogram and then they should get one every year after that. And today, the Cancer Societyâs saying itâs changing that. Itâs pushing it back. And theyâre saying that women can wait longer. They can wait five years longer until theyâre 45 before they start screening.
INSKEEP: Get tested less â why would that be a good idea?
STEIN: Well, theyâre basically saying that there are benefits of screening, but there are â can be significant downsides to screening. And the big downside is false alarms. If you screen millions of women every year, inevitably, some are going to get false alarms. And false alarms donât just make women anxious. It could create all sorts of problems.
It can send them back for additional mammograms, which could then result in them undergoing biopsies, which could find something that may or may not be cancer, may or may not be something that ever turns out to be life-threatening. But they end up getting lots of treatment anyway, like radiation, chemotherapy, surgeries like lymphadenectomies and even mastectomies sometimes.
INSKEEP: Well, now remembering this, Rob, isnât the American Cancer Society then weighing into a much bigger debate? Thereâs been much discussion for quite some time about this problem.
STEIN: Yeah, well, what happened is back in 2009, thereâs another group known as the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force that really opened up this can of worms. And so when it announced that it was recommending that women wait even longer until theyâre 50 before they start screening and then get a mammogram every other year, ever since then, thereâs been this really intense debate about whatâs the right thing to do when it comes to mammograms.
Now, thatâs not the only change that the Cancer Societyâs making. So the first thing theyâre saying is, OK, you can wait until you turn 45. Then theyâre saying, OK, then you get one every year until youâre 54 and then once you turn 55, you can stop and start skipping your mammogram every other year. The important key message here is that this is for women at average risk for breast cancer, not women who have a family history or something like that.
INSKEEP: Isnât there something that is counterintuitive thatâs really going to trouble a lot of people here? You would think that if you have a medical problem, you would rather have the test and know. But the advice here is that sometimes itâs better not knowing what kind of minor ailments or potential ailments or false alarms you might have.
STEIN: Right. What theyâre saying is that sometimes itâs better not to get bad information basically â basically be told that something is going to be a problem when it really is never going to be a problem. And the key here is that women in their early 40s are at such low risk for breast cancer that screening millions of them every year, inevitably youâre going to catch all sorts of false alarms and send women down this trail that was completely unnecessary. And if you just waited, youâre still going to catch the cancer later and youâre still going to save lives, and youâre going to - sort of that risk benefit analysis. It gets much better.
INSKEEP: Rob, thanks very much.
STEIN: Great to be here.
INSKEEP: That's NPR's Rob Stein.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.