Latest Religious Liberty Battle: Church-Affiliated Colleges And LGBT Students
DAVID GREENE, HOST:
And now to the latest battle over religious liberty. It's in California, where anti-discrimination laws cover sexual orientation. Religious colleges and universities have had an exemption from the law. A state lawmaker wants that to change to protect LGBT students at those schools. That move would open these institutions up to lawsuits. Capital Public Radio's Ben Adler has more from Sacramento.
BEN ADLER, BYLINE: As a child, Anthony Villarreal knew he was different. His elementary school friends had girlfriends. He planned weddings. He was raised Catholic in a small town east of Fresno in California's Central Valley. He accepted an athletic scholarship to William Jessup University, a private Christian college near Sacramento. He enrolled in 2010.
ANTHONY VILLARREAL: I was conflicted. I was Christian. And I had an idea that I might be gay. But I was in denial.
ADLER: Villarreal only came out to a few people during his years at William Jessup. But in his final semester, something very public happened. A loud argument with his live-in boyfriend over whether he should come out led his neighbors to call the cops, and he was arrested for domestic violence. Soon after, the university dismissed him. Villarreal is convinced he was kicked out because he's gay. The university says it was for domestic violence.
VILLARREAL: In a sense, they ruined my life. They may not know it. They may not feel it, and they may deny it. But they changed the path of my life dramatically.
ADLER: Now, this example is an imperfect one. Villarreal was never charged with domestic violence, and there's no proof the university dismissed him for being gay. In fact, the university says it never discriminates against students based on sexual orientation. But Villarreal says many LGBT students at faith-based schools feel pressured to be someone they're not.
VILLARREAL: And this bill will make sure that no one has to go through what I had to go through.
ADLER: The bill he's talking about is a measure in the California Legislature authored by Democratic Senator Ricardo Lara.
RICARDO LARA: We're saying if there is discrimination and you can prove that in a court of law, people should be able to have damages for that.
ADLER: Religious colleges and universities can claim an exemption from federal and state anti-discrimination laws. In California, those laws cover sexual orientation. Lara wants to end that exemption under state law for any institution that receives public funding, including state financial aid. William Jessup's president, Dr. John Jackson, says Lara's proposal would force his school to change its faith-based policies, stop admitting students on state aid or be sued.
JOHN JACKSON: We do think it's ultimately a religiously discriminating bill. To our knowledge, there's never been a religious test for public benefits.
ADLER: Some California lawmakers agree. Here's Republican Assemblyman James Gallagher.
JAMES GALLAGHER: When we try to parse out what is religious and what we view should be the proper view, we're kind of imposing a secular view on that religious institution.
ADLER: That opposition led the bill's author to strip the liability provision. It now requires religious colleges and universities to notify current and future students and staff of the anti-discrimination exemption.
MARCI HAMILTON: This is really about the classical balance in the United States between religious liberty and the moral imperative not to harm others.
ADLER: Marci Hamilton is an expert on law and religion at the University of Pennsylvania. She says 21 states have Religious Freedom Restoration Acts, or RFRAs, where religious groups could try to overturn this scaled-back bill.
HAMILTON: But California is the only state where the disclosure is being introduced and there's no background RFRA. And so the religious groups are basically having to explain themselves to the legislature. So it's dramatically different politically.
ADLER: And the issue isn't going away. The bill's author says he'll try again next year to make religious colleges and universities liable for discrimination. For NPR News, I'm Ben Adler in Sacramento.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.