The Fight Over New Hampshire's Tallest Mountain We take a trip to the top of New Hampshire's Mount Washington to see how a controversial trail has reignited debate over who should get to use, own and profit from the Northeast's highest peak.

The Fight Over New Hampshire's Tallest Mountain

The Fight Over New Hampshire's Tallest Mountain

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

We take a trip to the top of New Hampshire's Mount Washington to see how a controversial trail has reignited debate over who should get to use, own and profit from the Northeast's highest peak.


New Hampshire's Mount Washington, the highest mountain in the Northeast, is attracting more visitors every year. But it's also home to delicate ecosystems that some fear could suffer from overuse. New Hampshire Public Radio's Annie Ropeik has this story from the summit on how to keep that peak welcoming but wild.

ANNIE ROPEIK, BYLINE: As you near the top of Mount Washington, the trees get shorter and shorter and finally disappear. This is the alpine zone - a bare, windswept slope of yellow-green grass, endangered flowers and fragile lichens.

DAVID GOVATSKI: I can see some deer's hair sedge, Bigelow's sedge. And there's some Lapland rosebay.

ROPEIK: Naturalist David Govatski first climbed the mountain when he was 14. Since then, he's climbed every foot of the region's 1,400 miles of trails. He leads me down one of them - an ankle-bending, rocky path that's part of the Appalachian Trail. And he points down the mountainside.

GOVATSKI: That's actually the area where the hotel would be. You can see how close it would be.

ROPEIK: The hotel is a plan from the Mount Washington Cog Railway, which runs tourist trains up the mountain and owns a narrow strip of land for its tracks. The potential hotel would straddle those tracks in the alpine zone. But not everyone's on board. Molly Carmody from Massachusetts is hiking by on her way to the summit. She thinks this place should remain an escape from society.

MOLLY CARMODY: To get to someplace where you can only get by the power of your body is pretty cool.

ROPEIK: But right above us, there are hundreds of people at the summit visitors center who did not use their bodies to get here. Hiking is not the only way to scale Mount Washington. You can pay to take the train or drive the hairpin turns of a private toll road. Both have been here since the 1800s. And they're getting more popular every year. In the gift shop, with windows looking out on panoramic views and high blue sky, Jodie Heal and her 5-year-old son Austin are buying postcards to send home to family in Maine. They drove the mountain last time they visited and took the train this year. Heal says she's not sure they'd have come if the summit had no facilities.

JODIE HEAL: Especially traveling will children, they don't always hike very well, so it's nice when we get up here that if they're hungry, we can get food. And if they want to get a souvenir, they can. So...

ROPEIK: Outside, dozens of people wait in line for a photo with a pile of rocks marking the summit. And Cog Railway trains chug out of their station, heading down the mountain. I meet Cog owner Wayne Presby at their base station. He says his hotel could boost this rural economy and ease the strain on other overcrowded mountain facilities.

WAYNE PRESBY: I think we're one of the key pieces of the economy for Mount Washington and for tourism in general in the state of New Hampshire.

ROPEIK: Presby would need a special county permit to build his hotel in the alpine zone. But he thinks it'd be worth it. He says people who don't hike up the mountain want to enjoy that environment just as much as hikers do. And he thinks they'll respect it.

PRESBY: People like to visit mountain tops, and not all of them are capable of hiking. People need refuge when the weather gets bad, so I think there's any number of reasons why there's a need for additional facilities up there.

ROPEIK: This year, New Hampshire plans to find out exactly how much need there is with a study of Mount Washington's carrying capacity. It could help settle some debate over if and how this iconic summit can be accessible to everyone and still remain wild. For NPR News, I'm Annie Ropeik.

Copyright © 2018 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.