America's Growing Cop Shortage A hot job market and skepticism about law enforcement are making it harder for police departments across the country to replace officers who are retiring.
NPR logo America's Growing Cop Shortage

America's Growing Cop Shortage

Officer Christian Bruckhart collects used needles from a vacant site in his patrol area in New Haven, Conn. Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

Officer Christian Bruckhart collects used needles from a vacant site in his patrol area in New Haven, Conn.

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

It's a fall Monday morning in New Haven, Conn., and Officer Christian Bruckhart has lost track of how many calls he has had. He thinks it has been six. Maybe seven.

There was the family dispute involving vandalism to a car. He needs to write reports on stolen property and a woman being harassed on Facebook. But first, he has to help search for a missing woman who may be suicidal.

"I'm backed up," he says.

There are supposed to be six officers patrolling this territory; three are on duty today, including one who's already into overtime.

On one fall morning, Bruckhart handled about a half-dozen calls ... so many he cannot keep count. Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

On one fall morning, Bruckhart handled about a half-dozen calls ... so many he cannot keep count.

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

The New Haven Police Department simply doesn't have enough cops. It's a nationwide problem, as agencies that slowed or froze hiring during the recession are now struggling to build their ranks up again in the middle of a hot job market. Officers are retiring faster than they can be replaced.

New Haven is worse off than others. At last count, the department was 100 officers short.

Part of the problem is money — evident in the department's worn-out squad cars, one of which has a rust hole in the floorboard that has been patched with an old license plate. Suburban police departments can offer better pay and are luring away New Haven's midlevel officers.

The result is a department that's both short-staffed and green.

"I think it should scare the community more than anybody," Bruckhart says. "Because you go to some of these evening shifts and, you know, we have brand-new officers out there who are asking each other what to do on some of these calls. There's no veteran leadership."

Bruckhart works in the New Haven Police Department's Fair Haven substation. Like many law enforcement agencies across the country, the department doesn't have enough officers. New Haven is 100 officers short. Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

Bruckhart works in the New Haven Police Department's Fair Haven substation. Like many law enforcement agencies across the country, the department doesn't have enough officers. New Haven is 100 officers short.

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

The severity of the officer shortage varies from department to department, but the national trend is clear: Since 2013, the total number of working sworn officers has fallen by about 23,000. The number of officers per capita is down even more sharply, from 2.42 per 1,000 residents in 1997 to 2.17 officers per 1,000 in 2016.

Recruiters blame the hot job market, as well as greater skepticism about law enforcement as a career choice. That skepticism has grown in the past few years, fed by viral videos of controversial incidents of use of force by police. Where hundreds of people used to apply for a job opening, now it's often only a handful.

Undersheriff Jeff Mori's agency in Oregon's Washington County has started allowing officers to have facial hair and tattoos. The agency is understaffed by about 55 people. Martin Kaste/NPR hide caption

toggle caption
Martin Kaste/NPR

Undersheriff Jeff Mori's agency in Oregon's Washington County has started allowing officers to have facial hair and tattoos. The agency is understaffed by about 55 people.

Martin Kaste/NPR

"It's become more like recruiting for a football team," says Undersheriff Jeff Mori, of Oregon's Washington County. His agency is short about 55 people and relies heavily on mandatory overtime to cover all the necessary shifts. He says seeking out enough new recruits is a full-time preoccupation, and it has pushed the agency to change some of its requirements.

Holes in the floorboards of a New Haven Police Department squad car have been patched with an old license plate. Christian Bruckhart/New Haven Police Department hide caption

toggle caption
Christian Bruckhart/New Haven Police Department

Holes in the floorboards of a New Haven Police Department squad car have been patched with an old license plate.

Christian Bruckhart/New Haven Police Department

"We now allow facial hair," Mori says. "We allow tattoos; we allow earrings." The sheriff's office will even hire people who admit to past use of marijuana, since the drug is now legal in Oregon; though they're not allowed to use it once they've been hired, because it's still illegal under federal law.

Mori says potential recruits today have different expectations.

"I don't know if they want to be cops as much as the previous generation," he says, adding that those who are interested are looking for a kinder, gentler version of the job.

Officer Christian Bruckhart checks in with a resident of New Haven's Fair Haven neighborhood. Community building is a priority for many younger officers. Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

Officer Christian Bruckhart checks in with a resident of New Haven's Fair Haven neighborhood. Community building is a priority for many younger officers.

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

"They want to do something that's bigger than themselves," Mori says. "They view themselves as community-builders, as opposed to the warrior or even the guardian."

Deputy Chief Valerie Cunningham, who runs training and recruiting for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police, has noticed the same trend.

"I think we have to recruit differently, and I think they're going to end up policing differently," Cunningham says. "But I don't think it's a negative, I think it's a positive."

She thinks the recruiting crunch is pushing departments to cater more to young Americans' preference for community policing, which she sees as the direction departments should be going in.

Still, that's a long-term process. Cunningham's more immediate concern is rebuilding the ranks of the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, which is also short-handed.

Competing for cops

The fact that this shortage is being felt nationwide means she has to worry about other departments hiring away her officers.

The official term for this is "lateral hiring." Unofficially, it's called "poaching."

" 'Poaching' is, yeah, the less-polite term, but it's exactly what it is," says Cunningham. Earlier this fall, the Seattle Police Department put up a billboard in Indianapolis, advertising its interest in hiring away local cops.

"I've been in this career for 27 years. I've never seen a billboard pop up from another agency in our own backyard," Cunningham says.

Seattle, which is trying to emerge from a federal consent decree to reform its use of force practices, is both short-staffed and eager to increase the racial diversity in its ranks. The department's "lateral officer" recruiting video features an African-American officer expressing satisfaction with good compensation and less rain than you would expect.

YouTube

But lateral hires do nothing to solve the national shortage of officers, and many departments are starting to find ways to live with the new reality of a smaller police force. In Washington County, Undersheriff Mori says one solution may be more technology.

"The predictive analysis software that is being rolled out right now is going to be hugely beneficial," he says. "So we don't just randomly patrol, so we'll be more strategic about where send our resources."

The Washington County Sheriff's Office has also experimented with a portable facial recognition system, to speed up identification of potential suspects in the field.

None of those technologies are enough to make up for the current shortage of available humans, though, and Mori says that until he can find more qualified applicants, his current deputies are going to be stuck working a lot of overtime; as he puts it, "being held hostage to their jobs."

Officer Christian Bruckhart says the shortage of officers and the lack of veteran leadership on some shifts "should scare the community more than anybody." Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

Officer Christian Bruckhart says the shortage of officers and the lack of veteran leadership on some shifts "should scare the community more than anybody."

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

There are supposed to be six officers patrolling Bruckhart's territory, but there are days when there are half that. Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio hide caption

toggle caption
Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

There are supposed to be six officers patrolling Bruckhart's territory, but there are days when there are half that.

Ryan Caron King/Connecticut Public Radio

Lori Mack is a reporter for Connecticut Public Radio.