Detective's Misconduct Calls Hundreds of Cases into Question : Embedded Fellow officers long suspected a veteran detective in Antioch, Calif., was leaking operational police secrets to a drug dealer. For years, the department didn't act on their concerns. Even after the detective was finally fired in 2017, his record remained secret. In episode six of On Our Watch we look at the incentives departments have to investigate dishonest cops and what the secrecy around police misconduct means for criminal defendants who are prosecuted on their testimony.

On Our Watch: The Brady Rule

On Our Watch: The Brady Rule

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
Nicole Xu for NPR
A man is seen through a surveillance camera, moving a toolkit containing a drill.
Nicole Xu for NPR

Antioch police officials suspected one of their veteran detectives of leaking operational details as far back as 2010. But they didn't fire Santiago Castillo for another seven years. During that time, he investigated hundreds of cases including several homicides, and his testimony helped put dozens of people behind bars.

The detective had a "significant measure of influence over this organization," but "that trust has been waning in recent years," according to the internal investigation.

The local prosecutor's office knew about Castillo's 2017 firing, but it wasn't until his case became public under SB1421 that the District Attorney took a second look at those convictions.

District Attorneys have a direct legal obligation to know and to share that information about officer misconduct with defendants under a landmark 1963 Supreme Court decision: Brady v. Maryland.

In the sixth episode of On Our Watch we ask: in a secret system, what are the incentives for departments to investigate officers suspected of dishonesty or for District Attorneys to undermine their witnesses?

Learn more about On Our Watch at This podcast is produced as part of the California Reporting Project, a coalition of news organizations in California.