The Stressed Years of Their Lives NPR coverage of The Stressed Years of Their Lives: Helping Your Kid Survive and Thrive During Their College Years by B. Janet, Ph.D. Hibbs and Anthony, M.D. Rostain. News, author interviews, critics' picks and more.
NPR logo The Stressed Years of Their Lives

The Stressed Years of Their Lives

Helping Your Kid Survive and Thrive During Their College Years

by B. Janet Hibbs and Anthony Rostain

Hardcover, 322 pages, St Martins Pr, List Price: $28.99 |

purchase

Buy Featured Book

Title
The Stressed Years of Their Lives
Subtitle
Helping Your Kid Survive and Thrive During Their College Years
Author
B. Janet Hibbs and Anthony Rostain

Your purchase helps support NPR programming. How?

NPR stories about The Stressed Years of Their Lives

A file photo shows the campus of Harvard University in Cambridge, Mass. Dr. Anthony Rostain, co-author of The Stressed Years of Their Lives, says today's college students are experiencing an "inordinate amount of anxiety." Lisa Poole/AP hide caption

toggle caption
Lisa Poole/AP

College Students (And Their Parents) Face A Campus Mental Health 'Epidemic'

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/727509438/727628325" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

Note: Book excerpts are provided by the publisher and may contain language some find offensive.

Excerpt: The Stressed Years Of Their Lives

The Stressed Years of Their Lives

Helping Your Kid Survive and Thrive During Their College Years


St. Martin's Press

Copyright © 2019 B. Janet Hibbs and Anthony Rostain
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-1-250-11313-9


Contents

Title Page,
Copyright Notice,
Dedication,
Acknowledgments,
PART ONE OF STRESS and RESILIENCE,
1. Fault Lines in the World of Today's Youth,
2. Before You Go: Social-Emotional PREP,
3. Welcome to Campus: Overcoming Mindset Barriers to Success,
4. What to Expect When Johnny's Got Issues,
5. How to Plan — and How to Follow Through,
PART TWO OF CRISIS and RECOVERY,
6. Risky Business: The Adolescent Brain,
7. Anxiety and Depression,
8. Crisis Care,
9. Adjusting to the Boomerang Kid,
10. From Recovery to Relaunch,
11. Recasting the Safety Net,
Appendix,
Notes,
Index,
About the Authors,
Copyright,


CHAPTER 1

Fault Lines in the World of Today's Youth

Academic intelligence offers virtually no preparation for the turmoil — or opportunity — life's vicissitudes bring.

— DANIEL GOLEMAN, EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE

Carson was the salutatorian of his large public high school, earning the school's English award and a partial merit scholarship to a top-rated college. He felt proud and enormously relieved. His hard work had paid off. Without that scholarship, the commuter branch of the state university would have been his destination. And his parents had generously offered to help repay his student loans from the prestigious institution that had accepted him.

Their hopes, his dreams, mocked him as he sat in Freshman English, staring at his paper, marked with a large red "D". The class hour passed in a blur, and Carson next found himself on the eighth floor of the University Library overlooking the Great Hall below. He observed himself, contemplating what he would hit if he jumped. The glassed-in archive displays? The long polished table profiling the many recent faculty publications? A fellow student wafted through his thoughts. A girl in his French class had committed suicide only a month into the semester. She'd had a wonderfully droll sense of humor. Carson hadn't understood why she'd killed herself. It seemed she had everything going for her. So sad, so strange. But now, panicked and believing his scholarship jeopardized, his future ruined, he grasped her desperation.

A wave of vertigo forced him back from the library's overhang. He sat down and numbly hit the speed dial for the college hotline. Another student answered and kept Carson on the phone long enough for him to calm down and agree to go to the walk-in campus counseling service. And so, Carson resisted his terrible and momentary impulse. Very fortunately for him, his crisis of confidence was not superimposed upon major depression or bipolar disease. His momentary panic eventually led to therapy, which promoted a greater resilience and better ability to tolerate setbacks and distress.

In addition to vertigo and the absence of mental illness, the serendipity of many emotional skills came to Carson's aid that afternoon. A strong connection to his family and friends and a willingness to seek help also enabled him to step back from the balcony and make that call. His family environment had fostered the noncognitive skills that empowered him to ask for help when needed. His parents consistently praised his effort more than the outcome; they quietly noticed and supported his interests. When Carson made mistakes, they joked, "pobody's nerfect." His family talked through problems but didn't solve them for him. His emotional preparation broke through his fleeting despair. As his thinking cleared, he recalled how he had coped with another D — on a high school calculus test. At first he had freaked out — "my high school ranking will drop" — then he told his parents, who encouraged him to talk with the teacher. It was this emotional resilience and preparation for adversity that saved him when his academics failed him. Whether coming early or late to these skills, we firmly believe that all students can learn them.

Yet the sad truth is that many students are not so fortunate or so well-prepared when caught in the epidemic of college-age mental health problems. The current and incoming generations of college students need to be better equipped with the maturity boost that social-emotional intelligence provides. Being better prepared for the roller coaster of college life will reduce the chances of their coming off the rails.

And what about the parents on the other side of these frightening experiences? Instead of the nostalgic truism that college will be "the best years of your life," we hear from countless parents concerned about how their children's lives are falling apart. Despite all they've done to educate and support their talented child, they see signs of wobbling begin to appear in the form of poor coping, anxiety, depression, or emotional upheaval.

As two well-established experts on late adolescent psychiatry and family psychology, we've coached families through such times, giving parents tools to help their once-confident students preserve or regain their ability to organize time, work, and even the basics of sleeping and eating. Yet, many students are unprepared for the removal of home's invisibly embedded emotional and cognitive scaffolding.

In his role as Professor of Psychiatry and Pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine and co-chair of the President's and Provost's Task Force on Student Psychological Health and Well Being, Dr. Rostain has closely watched the dramatic rise in campus mental-illness rates with deep concern. Colleges and universities across the country are reporting an explosion of mental health problems verging on an epidemic, with a skyrocketing number of students seeking help. Rostain is very familiar with the risks, challenges, and complex systems issues facing young people, and has made it his mission to find solutions for these students and parents alike. As a family psychologist, faculty member, and clinical supervisor, Dr. Hibbs has had decades of experience helping parents and students cope in challenging and crisis-laden times.

As parents ourselves, we know all too intimately the gnawing anxiety that can be fed by pervasive media coverage of such campus hazards as hazing, binge drinking, drug use, and sexual assault, as well as the quieter desperations of "not fitting in" or feeling that you're "not making it." When these all-too-common risks give rise to emotional disorders or psychiatric illnesses, students and parents alike can be overwhelmed.

That was Dr. Hibbs's experience when her son Jensen suffered a depression that required a medical leave from college. Despite her professional expertise, Jensen's harrowing crisis left Hibbs humbled and scrambling for answers, while more deeply informing her of the preparation, knowledge, and skills that parents and students need. Following Jensen's treatment by Dr. Rostain — and his subsequent recovery — we resolved to coauthor The Stressed Years of Their Lives, a book that provides solutions, strategies, and solidarity for parents who want to help their students avoid, resolve, or recover from a mental health problem or crisis. It is also a book to give hope and support to students, through the stories of their peers. We thank Jensen, as well as the many students, parents, and educators who so generously lent their stories to this book.

However rapid the recent and ongoing shifts in our culture, we're optimistic that today's parents have better tools at their disposal than ever before to build a sturdy and enduring emotional scaffold for their children. To help you assess its stability, we'll show you how to strengthen some key skills — namely resilience, executive functioning, and healthy habits of independent living — that can reinforce a young person's ability to cope with the coming challenges. Though individual lives are complicated, we are convinced that both parents and students alike can benefit through the thoughtful discussions, skills, and lessons described in this book. We hope that our experiences and insights will help many generations to come.

When the Best Are Stressed

Beyond panic and resilience, Carson's story acquaints us with a generational truth. Like Carson, everyone will experience a crushing disappointment at some point in time, yet in the college of a generation past, a single bad grade didn't portend doom. Nor was life success so inextricably linked with a linear trajectory from high school through the perfect college and on to a high-paying career, without allowing for a single stumble.

Increasingly, however, it can often seem as if this is the case. Contemplating adulthood, today's youth confront a gloomy forecast of increased competition and narrowing possibilities. "The college degree is becoming the new high school diploma," The New York Times recently intoned, "the new minimum requirement, albeit an expensive one, for getting even the lowest-level job."

Given the pressure to succeed, it's no wonder that today's adolescents vie with adults for the dubious title of "America's Most Stressed." The younger group may even be pulling ahead: According to a recent survey by the American Psychological Association, teens experience higher stress than adults, even in summer. That pressure, the APA survey revealed, leaves a third of teens feeling overwhelmed, depressed, and fatigued. Nor does it show any sign of letting up soon: 34 percent of the teen survey respondents expected their stress levels to rise even higher in the year ahead.

And how are both groups handling the pressure? Not well: neither the teens nor the adults reported doing enough to manage their stress. Most were indulging in unhealthy behaviors: skipping meals or "stress eating" and getting nowhere near enough exercise or sleep. By college, stress combusts with mental health diagnoses and an increased risk of self-harm.

Parents sound confused and alarmed: What's the deal with kids' stress levels today? And how long does it take for a kid to grow up? We often hear parents voice variations of a standard lament: "We're at our wits' end. We've struggled to give him every chance to succeed — more than we had at his age, certainly — so what's gone wrong?"

Beginning with the Millennials and continuing in Generation Z (also known as iGen), students experience the very real burdens of constant striving on behalf of uncertain futures, amidst swiftly changing political and economic landscapes. They're also stressed by the 24/7 availability of the Internet, by social media pressures, and by the resulting metrics of constant comparisons, whether social or academic. GPAs, the dream college, scholarships, prestigious summer internships, and later, starting salaries, are all insubstantial proxies for meaning and purpose, as one MIT professor observed. Today's pressures can overwhelm brains already struggling with developmental tasks and insecurities, among them: forming an identity, developing friendships, exploring romantic relationships, and germinating the seeds of a career.

Parents are stressed too. The parental urge to protect their young can result in over-parenting, which paradoxically hinders the emotional skills needed for a successful launch. These multiple forces often come to a head in the crucible of college life and immediately thereafter, when many stress-induced emotional problems first appear. These two phenomena — college stressors and the emergence of mental health problems — feed into one another in a closed loop, increasing the pressure of both.

Let's crunch the numbers on college mental health, then take a look at the uniquely stressful climate in which young people are coming of age today. With this understanding, we'll see how parents can teach — and students can learn — what's truly necessary to thrive in college and beyond.

Crunching the Numbers

In recent years there has been no shortage of reports about students' stress responses to the academic pressure cooker of college, with antidepressant use, mental health problems, and prescription-medication misuse all on the rise. "Rates of anxiety and depression have soared in the last decade," notes The Chronicle of Higher Education. The rise in the rate of college students seeking counseling is five times higher than the average rate of enrollment growth.

According to the American College Health Association's recent annual survey, 1 in 4 college students was either diagnosed or treated for anxiety in the prior year. This is approximately the same number as those reporting that a cold or flu hurt their academics in the prior 12 months. Untold millions went undiagnosed and untreated. Another large student survey reveals a glimpse of the magnitude of the campus problem: more than half reported the experience of overwhelming anxiety during the prior school year, while about a third reported that depression had significantly affected their academic performance. The numbers only go up from there, with even more feeling "hopeless" and "overwhelmed." Yet only about one-fourth of the affected students received counseling for these conditions, and many of those in counseling often dropped out of treatment prematurely.

The following lists summarize this alarming trend:

Mental Health–Related College Problems

• Anxiety is the most common student mental health problem.

• Almost one-third of all college students report having felt so depressed that they had trouble functioning in the last twelve months.

• Mental health issues in the college student population, such as depression, anxiety, and eating disorders, are associated with lower GPA and higher probability of dropping out of college.

• More than 80 percent of college students felt overwhelmed by all they had to do in the past year, and 45 percent have felt things were hopeless.

• Minority students are less likely to seek treatment.

Mental Health Issues Can Be Deadly

• Suicide is the second leading cause of death among college students, claiming the lives of 1,100 students each year.

• 67 percent of college students tell a friend they are feeling suicidal before telling anyone else.

• More than half of college students have had suicidal thoughts and 1 in 10 students seriously consider attempting suicide. Half of the students who have suicidal thoughts never seek counseling or treatment.

• 80 to 90 percent of college students who die by suicide were not receiving help from their college counseling centers.

Why are these numbers so high? A key contributor is the fact that most psychiatric disorders show up from ages 14 to 26 — possibly the most tumultuous decade in a person's life. The academic and social demands of college can readily magnify emotional and learning problems that were mild enough to be overlooked or successfully handled in childhood or later dismissed as just a "passing teenage phase."

Certain disorders typically emerge right before and during the college years. Eating disorders reach their peak among young women, while binge drinking and substance abuse hit their crest among young men. Also common to many are anxiety, depression, and what psychologists call "problems of executive functioning" — that is, the capacity for unsupervised self-management that underlies good judgment, organization, and self-control. Combine the psychological and social vulnerabilities of college-age kids with the heightened stress of leaving home and learning to swim in an academic shark tank, and it's easy to see why the core symptoms of so many mental health disorders appear at this vulnerable time in their lives.

Emelia's story puts a face on these statistics. The distress call came from Mrs. Carr, who left an urgent message on Dr. Rostain's voicemail. Uncharacteristically, Emelia hadn't answered her mother's phone calls or texts for almost twenty-four hours.

When Dr. Rostain reached Mrs. Carr, she was less panicked but still very concerned. She had just spoken to Emelia and learned that her roommate had moved out of their dorm room. Emelia sounded annoyed with her mother for "checking up" on her, but insisted that she was "basically fine."

Two weeks later, the college called Mrs. Carr and told her to pick up Emelia and bring her home. She was failing every class and wouldn't be able to salvage the semester.

Emelia's college experience is common to many unsuccessful launches: she lacked the necessary executive functioning skills to independently organize the many academic, social, and emotional demands of being away from home. Until college, Emelia had never done a trial run of managing independently, even if that meant missing assignments or failing a subject. Mrs. Carr had helped her daughter to succeed at all costs; the stakes seemed too high to let her flounder. Once at college, Emelia was too embarrassed, ashamed, anxious, and overwhelmed to ask for help. We'll return to the dilemma many parents share: When is help unhelpful? Where is the fine line between parenting and over-parenting? But what Mrs. Carr first wanted to know was: What were colleges doing to help? She was furious with Emelia's school for not alerting her "until it was too late to do anything about it."

The Stressed Years: What Are Colleges Doing?

Beginning in the late 1990s, colleges observed a sudden rise in student mental health problems. By the early 2000s, mental health task forces were springing up on campuses across the country. Colleges were pressed to furnish additional services — including academic support and psychological counseling — that many of them were not prepared to provide. Over the past six years, there has been a 30 percent national increase in the number of students seeking counseling on campus. By some estimates, approximately one-half of current college students will seek mental health services at least once during their college career. "I don't know if [this trend is] related to the way we parent," says Marvin Krislov, formerly president of Oberlin college, now president of Pace University. "I don't know if it's related to the media or the pervasive role of technology. What I can tell you is that every campus I know is investing more resources in mental health." In response to the startling rise in students seeking help, colleges have beefed up their support. The good news: the rise reflects a few positive trends:

1. Admissions policies have widened to include talented young people who might have been denied a college education in an earlier era. Among them, students of lower income, first-generation students, and youth with preexisting psychiatric conditions, as well as those needing accommodations for social, emotional, and learning challenges.

2. Awareness of campus mental health needs and services is rising.

3. The stigma of mental illness is receding.


(Continues...)