Browse Topics



Support from:

Now with Bill Moyers on PBS

Israelis Philosophical About Golan's Future

Morning Edition: October 4, 2006

Israelis Philosophical About Golan's Future


The conflict between Israel and Hezbollah reminded many Israelis that they live in a hostile neighborhood. Making peace with Syria, the country that sponsors Hezbollah, would be a step toward making it less hostile. Previous efforts to promote a settlement have failed, and now some Israeli politicians are wondering aloud if Israel should try again. Any agreement, though, would mean returning the Golan Heights to Syria.

NPRís Michael Sullivan reports.


Unidentified Woman: Shalom, and welcome to the Bental Lookout.

MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Nearly forty years ago, this part of the Golan was a battlefield. Today itís a tourist destination.


Unidentified Woman: In front of you is the Kinetra Valley, full of orchards and vineyards.

SULLIVAN: Come here at night and you can see the lights from the Syrian capital, Damascus, about 30 miles to the northeast. In the opposite direction, the Sea of Galilee and the Israeli town of Tiberius, and to the north, Kiryat Shemona, a frequent target of Hezbollah rockets launched from southern Lebanon during this summerís war.

Mr. KOBE MARONE(ph) (Former Israeli Army Commander): In my professional point of view, I think that the Golan Heights gives us a very important strategy depth(ph) to defend the upper Galilee Region and the central part of Israel.

SULLIVAN: Former brigade commander Kobe Marone spent 25 years in the Israeli army. As a military man, he understands the reason for keeping the Golan, and for giving it back.

Mr. MARONE: If we want to have a real quiet border in our northern part, Syria has to be part of the game. If you want to stop the support that Syria gives to the Hezbollah, the only option is to start negotiating.

SULLIVAN: Israel and Syria have come close to a deal twice before, and some Israelis find the idea of trying again, so soon after the war with Hezbollah, a little hard to swallow.


SULLIVAN: The Odem Mountain Winery is one of many that have sprouted up on the Golan in recent years. Itís just a few miles from the Bental lookout, on land that would go back to Syria under any deal.

Six huge steel tanks line one wall, some venting carbon dioxide from next yearís Chardonnay. Twenty-six year old Yishai Alfasi and his brother handle the day-to-day operations in this family-run business. The winery is just a few years old, but Alfasi says itís already produced several award-winning wines.

Mr. YISHAI ALFASI (Owner, Odem Mountain Winery): This is the second year that weíre producing Chardonnay. The first one was a very big success, very fruity, and a great Israeli summer drink.

SULLIVAN: Alfasiís parents came to the Golan about 30 years ago, answering the governmentís call to settle the land just won from Syria. The idea of giving it back, of leaving, he says, is painful but perhaps necessary in the long run.

Mr. ALFASI: Itís not okay. But if we withdraw from the Golan and it will give a very good peace, like you can see in other parts of the world, maybe it would be right for us.

SULLIVAN: His friend, Leor Schalef(ph), couldnít disagree more. The sight of the settlers in Gaza being torn from their homes last year during Israelís unilateral withdrawal from Gaza, brought tears to his eyes, Schalef says. He has also lived on the Golan since he was born, and if the government ever gave it up, Schalef says, he wouldnít leave without a fight.

Mr. LEOR SCHALEF (Golan Heights Resident): Iíve been traveling around the whole world. Thereís no such place as the Golan. Itís beautiful. Itís quiet. Everything here is perfect. Thereís nothing that can ruin it.

SULLIVAN: And if for some reason the Israeli government actually gave up the Golan, what would you do?

Mr. SCHALEF: I would find it hard to live in a country that gave back my home.

SULLIVAN: Giving up the Golan would be harder than giving up Gaza, Schalef says, especially now, after the war with Hezbollah. And the persistent, though intermittent, homemade rocket attacks from Gaza on southern Israel - attacks that proved to some that the unilateral withdrawal from Gaza has brought Israel nothing.

The former career soldier and brigade commander Kobe Marone is sympathetic to that argument. And why wouldnít he be. Just a few months ago, he opened this up market restaurant and bar on the Golan with a magnificent view over the Hula Valley below. But Marone says he would give it all up, if necessary, for peace Ė though he isnít happy about the idea.

Mr. MARONE: No, Iím not. But in our situation in the Middle East, the vision has to be a national view. So I understand the personal price that me and my family and my friends maybe one day has to pay for this.

SULLIVAN: Michael Sullivan, NPR News.


The price for peace is hard to calculate. The cost for a victory celebration for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan has already been established. The New York Times reports Congress voted to allocate 20 million dollars for a commemoration of success in the nationís capital, one item in a 2006 military spending bill. They havenít spent the money yet. Those dollars roll over to 2007.

Youíre listening to NPR News.

Copyright ©2006 National Public Radio®. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to National Public Radio. This transcript may not be reproduced in whole or in part without prior written permission. For further information, please contact NPR's Permissions Coordinator at (202) 513-2000.

This transcript was created by a contractor for NPR, and NPR has not verified its accuracy. For all NPR programs, the broadcast audio should be considered the authoritative version.