Who Will Replace Letterman? Probably Another White Guy : Code Switch As David Letterman confirms his retirement, a familiar question surfaces: Why is late-night television dominated by white hosts? NPR TV critic Eric Deggans names his dream replacements.
NPR logo Who Will Replace Letterman? Probably Another White Guy

Who Will Replace Letterman? Probably Another White Guy

We might have diversity in the White House, but our late night show hosts are still predominantly white. Brendan Smialowsky/AFP/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption
Brendan Smialowsky/AFP/Getty Images

We might have diversity in the White House, but our late night show hosts are still predominantly white.

Brendan Smialowsky/AFP/Getty Images

Now that David Letterman has finally confirmed plans to retire, it seems necessary to ask the same question which surfaces every time there's a shuffle in the late night TV lineup:

Why are there so many white guys dominating late night talk show television?

The simple answer is that TV programmers mostly cast for their target audience. So daytime TV is bursting with Ellens and Oprahs, Latifahs and Katies, Barbaras and Julies, while nighttime runneth over with Jons, Jimmys, Davids, Conans, Stephens, Craigys and even a Carson or two.

But while daytime has the occasional Steve Harvey, Dr. Phil and Dr. Oz, late night has mostly been the province of the smart-alecky white guy. I don't expect CBS to change this, given how important the Letterman succession will be for them.

There's no doubt the genre has diminished since the days when Letterman first started; the mid-'70s era of The Love Boat and disco fever, when Hollywood titans like Tonight Show host Johnny Carson could still give a young comic a multimillion-dollar career just by allowing him a two-minute set.

Still, late night hosts are more than the guys who squeeze the last ratings juice out of a broadcast day. They're the face of comedy for the networks where they serve; the Emmys, Oscars and Golden Globes hosts who teach the rest of us what's funny and what's not.

So, even if you haven't watched Letterman since Cher called him a colorful term for the business end of your colon (that would be back in 1987), you should recognize that these jobs matter. And who gets them — or gets long years to perfect their performance in them, like Jimmy Fallon and Conan O'Brien once did — says volumes about who matters in television. And who doesn't.

I have few illusions that CBS will break television's long streak of hiring youthful white guys to host these shows. They've known Letterman was likely going to retire since he signed an unprecedented one-year deal with the network in 2013. If they don't have a serious succession plan in place — one Hollywood Reporter story claims they spoke to John Oliver before he inked a deal with HBO — they're not nearly as smart as I know they are.

But Letterman has a legacy of edgy innovation. He refused to play the game of being nice to guests he didn't like or showing respect to network executives who didn't deserve it. He made co-stars out of the cue card guys and camera people, laughing at the absurdity of making millions for cranking out monologue jokes and asking starlets about their new clothing lines — even while transcending those pedestrian limitations regularly.

It would be great if CBS might consider honoring that legacy by kicking Late Late Show host Craig Ferguson into the big chair — even if he doesn't want it, because he's an amazing performer who deserves a serious challenge — so a new non-white or non-male face (or faces) could take over 12:35 a.m.

Here's my (admittedly) fantasy wishlist:

  • Chris Rock

    I remain convinced one of the best things he's ever done was the late night HBO comedy show he had back in the 1990s. For you young-uns out there, it was like Chappelle's Show, but with Louis C.K. and Wanda Sykes among the ace writers/performers cranking out material. Bringing that pain to network TV would be an amazing move, especially for the network of NCIS and Blue Bloods. (shout out here to W. Kamau Bell, who Rock championed into hosting his own unfairly-canceled talk show on FX/FXX. I love him, but couldn't see CBS handing him a show on his own, even in my wildest showbiz fantasies.)

  • Key & Peele

    How cool would it be to see these guys create an In Living Color-style comedy show with a few more talented cast members, backed by their sharp comedy eye? A nightly monologue featuring Luther, President Obama's anger translator, would be enough to make me greenlight this one, even though these guys are probably committed to Comedy Central until the turn of the next century.

  • Cedric the Entertainer

    He's another smart, funny non-white comic who has scored as host of the syndicated Who Wants to be a Millionaire and has a sitcom on TV Land. I'd love to see Cedric lead a Kings of Comedy-style show filled with talent who could pop in late night like D.L. Hughley, Alonzo Bodden, Maz Jobrani and Gabriel Iglesias. Could scoop up every viewer who wondered if there was a comedy horizon beyond the latest Jimmy or Jon.

  • Aisha Tyler

    She's held her own between Julie Chen and Sharon Osbourne on The Talk, hosted The CW's version of Whose Line Is It Anyway, rocked the house on FX's Archer and made a name as a geek-friendly standup comedienne and podcaster. If she looked like Chris Hardwick, she'd have five hosting gigs on late night TV by now. (Shout-out here to Comedy Central star Amy Schumer, who I have no doubt is smart and funny enough to also pull this off, but she's way too dirty for CBS – which makes me love her even more.)

  • Amy Poehler and Tina Fey

    This is a fantasy, now. Neither of them would agree to do it alone. But what if CBS hired both to host in a rotation, with occasional nights when they did it together? Just take all the coolest moments from their time hosting the last two Golden Globes awards, string them together, and you have the tiniest hint of the comedy gold which awaits. The only drawback: angering NBC comedy kingmaker Lorne Michaels, whom both of them owe quite a bit.