What's Behind The Alarming Rise In HIV Infections Among The Indigenous People Of Panama : Goats and Soda In many parts of the world, the rate of HIV infection is declining. But not among the indigenous peoples of this Central American country.
NPR logo What's Behind The Alarming Spike In HIV Infections In Panama?

What's Behind The Alarming Spike In HIV Infections In Panama?

Dario Garcia, who lives in Panama, volunteers to visit people who are HIV-positive to see whether they are taking their medications. Garcia himself is HIV-positive. "I feel alone," he says. "I believe the most support I have now is from others who have been diagnosed." Jacob McCleland for NPR hide caption

toggle caption
Jacob McCleland for NPR

Dario Garcia, who lives in Panama, volunteers to visit people who are HIV-positive to see whether they are taking their medications. Garcia himself is HIV-positive. "I feel alone," he says. "I believe the most support I have now is from others who have been diagnosed."

Jacob McCleland for NPR

A short man with a ponytail peeks through a crack in a sheet-metal fence, calling out to see if anybody's home. His name is Dario Garcia and he is checking on some people with HIV to make sure they're taking their meds.

Garcia walks through the muddy yard, past chickens and scrawny dogs, to the cinder block house.

Inside, he finds two men, both indigenous and HIV-positive. At first, they want to talk to Garcia. Then, they spot someone outside — a neighbor or a family member. They clam up. One man backs into the corner of the room. If he could dissolve into the ash-gray wall, he would. Nobody else in the household knows they have HIV, and the men are afraid to be overheard. Garcia quickly changes the subject. A few minutes later, he leaves.

"I still find people with this fear that others will simply hear the word 'HIV' spoken around them," Garcia says in Spanish. "They automatically shut down and don't talk."

Garcia, who holds a law degree, is a volunteer for a nongovernmental organization called Viviendo Positivamente, or Living Positively. He says the stigma surrounding HIV is strong. And he knows this firsthand — he, too, is HIV-positive.

"The greatest discrimination that exists for a person with HIV is in their own family," Garcia says.

Garcia is an ethnic Ngabe, the largest indigenous group in Panama, and he is heartsick about the crisis his people are facing. In other parts of the world, the rate of new HIV infection is on the decline. Here, it's spiking. About 150,000 people live in the Comarca Ngabe-Bugle territory, and AIDS is the now the second-leading cause of death there, accounting for more than 8 percent of deaths. Approximately 2.5 percent of people who live in the Comarca Ngabe-Bugle carry the virus.

What's behind the spike

Arlene Calvo, a research professor at the University of South Florida's Panama City campus, says HIV was unheard of in Ngabe territory until recently. The first case wasn't identified until 2001, decades after the virus first ravaged other parts of the world. And now that it's here, it's entrenched.

Arlene Calvo, a research professor at the University of South Florida, says the lack of access to health care is one of the biggest barriers to controlling the outbreak. Jacob McCleland for NPR hide caption

toggle caption
Jacob McCleland for NPR

Arlene Calvo, a research professor at the University of South Florida, says the lack of access to health care is one of the biggest barriers to controlling the outbreak.

Jacob McCleland for NPR

"It went from having just a few cases to after a few months having 100 identified cases, and probably a year after that having over 500 cases," Calvo says.

Calvo says there are likely many more Ngabes with HIV who haven't been detected, and others are so sick when they are first diagnosed that there's no way to arrest the disease.

"You have to understand that this is a very rural area, not comparable to rural U.S.," Calvo says.

The terrain is rugged and mountainous, and many communities aren't connected by roads. Some villages don't have electricity or running water. Blood tests must be administered in a hospital by a lab technician, which can mean an eight- to 10-hour trip for the patient, much of it on foot. Calvo says the lack of access to care is one of the biggest barriers to controlling the outbreak.

"Even if you're healthy, it is very difficult," Calvo says. "Imagine being sick and trying to do this."

Many Ngabes with HIV get antiretroviral treatment at a clinic in the little town of San Felix. The doctor here, Cesar Gantes, says the No. 1 reason HIV has exploded among the Ngabe people is the lack of economic opportunity in their communities. Many indigenous men lead nomadic lifestyles, traveling to work at coffee harvests on plantations in western Panama, Costa Rica and Nicaragua. They contract HIV while away, then bring it back home.

"When they migrate, they are outside the control of their communities, and their sex practices can diversify," says anthropologist Patricia Ponce. And that can include sex with other men. She says women who leave their communities can often end up in the sex trade.

Additionally, Gantes says there are no pharmacies to buy condoms in the Ngabe territory, so it can be difficult to get them. While treatment for HIV is free at the clinic, funded by the government, only about half of his patients continue it, largely because they don't have money for transportation.

"And it is not permitted to talk about sex to our students," Gantes says. "This is a big barrier that we have because teachers cannot teach freely about sex."

In 2010, Gantes had 30 people in treatment for HIV/AIDS. By the end of last year, the number had jumped to approximately 550. Other Ngabes seek treatment at clinics in the cities of Santiago, David and Changuinola.

Gantes has a solution in mind for those who can't make it to a clinic. "We are putting together a proposal to get a mobile clinic to bring medical services to the most strategic places inside the Comarca Ngabe-Bugle so that patients don't have to pay so much to get here," he says.

Indigenous communities across Latin America are seeing a similar spike. In such communities in Panama and Honduras, for instance, the prevalence of HIV is six times higher than among the overall population of those countries.

Ponce says myths about HIV's transmission persist across Latin America's indigenous communities, according to the few studies that have been conducted.

"They think that through touching, hugging, through sharing food or bathrooms, or through mosquito bites that the virus can be spread," Ponce says. "They are full of these myths."

Shunned but still hopeful

Rosmery Pascasio, from the Ngabe community of Llano Ñopo, worked as part of a project to educate young people about HIV and how to seek treatment. The project's funding has ended, but Pascasio continues to do the work as a volunteer.

"Many young people who contracted HIV don't have a future right now because they think they are going to die," Pascasio says. "We're teaching them that they can continue treatment, continue working, continue living ... and they can help other young people who don't know how to get treatment."

One of the young men she has worked with is 31-year-old Mendoza. Sitting on a bench underneath a mango tree in a park in the town of Tolé, Mendoza says he knows that people with HIV can be shunned, so he doesn't want to use his full name.

"I wouldn't want another person to live through what I have," he says.

He is studying to be a teacher so he can help younger generations of Ngabes. Mendoza is more fortunate than many HIV patients here. He still lives in his village, and his family, especially his mother, is supportive and helps him receive treatment.

"She has supported me in everything," Mendoza says. "At least I have somebody who can help me blow off steam."

Garcia is not as fortunate.

"My parents don't accept me because, apart from being HIV-positive, I am also gay," Garcia says.

In the 13 years since his diagnosis, he says, he has never had the support of his parents.

"I feel alone," he says. "I believe the most support I have now is from others who have been diagnosed."

The people he helps, those who have been diagnosed with HIV, they are his real family now.


Jacob McCleland is the news director at KGOU public radio in Norman, Okla.

Correction May 30, 2018

An earlier version of this post incorrectly said that Dario Garcia is a lawyer. He has a law degree but is not a practicing lawyer.