A Simple Emergency Room Intervention Can Help Cut Suicide Risk
Many people who attempt suicide end up in an emergency room for immediate treatment. But few of those suicide survivors get the follow-up care they need at a time when they are especially likely to attempt suicide again.
Now, a study shows that a simple intervention conducted by staff in emergency departments can reduce the risk of future attempts. The intervention involves creating a safety plan for each patient and following up with phone calls after discharge.
"It reduced the odds of suicidal behavior by half," says Barbara Stanley, a psychologist at Columbia University and the lead author of the study. "That's a phenomenal difference."
The study, which was published Wednesday in JAMA Psychiatry, included 1,200 patients at five Veterans Affairs hospitals around the country. The findings offer a way for hospitals and clinics to help reduce the rising numbers of death by suicide across the country.
You Are Not Alone
If you or someone you know may be considering suicide, contact the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255 (en Español: 1-888-628-9454; deaf and hard of hearing: 1-800-799-4889) or the Crisis Text Line by texting 741741.
"When someone goes to the emergency room for a suicide attempt, they are at risk of another suicide attempt for the next three months," says Stanley. "It's like a ticking time bomb."
This is the first large-scale study of the Safety Planning Intervention, which Stanley and her group developed in 2008 and which has been adopted at hospitals and clinics around the country. It can be provided by a physician, a nurse or a social worker and requires very little training.
"The interesting thing about the Safety Planning Intervention is that it is a relatively brief intervention and can be used in a lot of different [health care] settings," says Brian Ahmedani, director of behavioral health research at the Henry Ford Health System in Detroit, who wasn't involved in the new study.
Many health care systems are starting to think about ways to prevent suicide, he says. That's because, as his own work has shown, almost 83 percent of people who die by suicide make a health care visit in the year before their death. Yet only 50 percent of those people have been diagnosed with a mental illness.
The intervention studied by Stanley and her group starts in the ER or a clinic, before the suicidal patient is released. First, a health care professional talks with the patient and tries to understand that person's warning signs for a suicide attempt.
"If they've grappled with being suicidal, they know what their warning signs are," says Stanley. For example, she says, someone might say, " 'I find that I'm staying in my room, not answering the phone, not answering texts, not answering emails.' That could be a warning sign." Others might have repeated thoughts that they're not worthy.
The next step is for the patient — with help from the clinician — to come up with a set of coping strategies to help get through moments of intense suicidal ideation.
For most people, this intense state only lasts from a few minutes to a couple of hours, she says.
The coping strategy could be something as simple as playing video games, watching TV or talking to a loved one.
If people contemplating suicide can distract themselves with something they enjoy doing, they can bypass that narrow window during which suicidal thoughts can overpower them, notes Stanley. "For suicidal people, the passage of time is their friend," she says.
The provider also tries to persuade patients to remove or distance themselves from their means of suicide. For example, if they own a gun, they should lock it away or give it to someone who can keep it away from them. "If you make it really hard to use whatever means you were going to use, time passes and you give a chance for suicidal thoughts to subside," she says.
Safety planning includes follow-up phone calls with the patient — the first call is made within 72 hours of being discharged from the ER. The provider asks the patient how the safety plan is being used and helps revise it if needed. The provider also makes sure the patient sees a mental health care provider for long-term care. A provider keeps calling until the patient has had a second appointment with a therapist or counselor.
That follow-up is key, says Julie Goldstein Grumet, a psychologist at the Zero Suicide Institute at the Education Development Center, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit.
"People often fall off and they don't follow up on their referrals," she says. "And the times during these transitions from acute care settings is one of the highest risk times of suicides."
To evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention, Stanley's team looked at five VA emergency departments across the country that used it and compared the outcomes with four VA emergency rooms that simply discharge patients after stabilizing them.
Among the nearly 1,200 people who received the intervention, half as many people had made suicide attempts (or had come very close) as those in the control group. In other words, the intervention had nearly halved the risk of suicide in the six months after discharge. Two-thirds of the people in the treatment group had used their safety plans, and they were also twice as likely to get follow-up mental health treatment when compared with the control group.
"The study is incredibly important ... because it shows brief interventions work," says Goldstein Grumet.
Rick, a father in Missouri, says a safety plan may have saved his 12-year-old daughter's life. (NPR is leaving off his last name to protect his daughter's privacy.)
In September 2017, she came very close to taking her own life. When he found out about this from her school principal the next day, Rick rushed her to the ER at Mercy Hospital Jefferson. "The whole process was overwhelming, because you have your 12-year-old who's wanting to end her life," Rick says. "And she'd not shared any of that with us."
The hospital wasn't part of the new study but was also using a safety planning intervention as part of its efforts to prevent suicides.
"The crisis counselor did such an amazing job of setting up a safety plan that my daughter felt comfortable with," he says.
He says his daughter didn't want to talk to him or her mother about her struggles, but she agreed to communicate with them in other ways. During times when she felt her urge to take her own life coming back, she agreed to watch TV with her mother or call or text her father.
Rick says she usually sends a specific emoji when she is having a bad day. And he responds by distracting her with something completely different.
He says she also agreed to use a crisis help line if things escalated.
"It was something that she could follow through with," he says. "It gave her some confidence and it gave me some confidence."
He says the plan has helped his daughter get through her suicidal phase and even slowly open up to her parents.
"That's what is so powerful about a safety plan," says Ahmedani. "The patient is the author of their safety plan, but it's guided by a provider."
As part of the 2012 National Strategy For Suicide Prevention, many health care providers have adopted the approaches to prevention outlined in the Zero Suicide Initiative, which includes safety planning based on previous evidence showing it works.
While safety planning has begun to be used across the country, it ought to be adopted universally, says Goldstein Grumet.
"It is a brief intervention that hospital workers, primary care staff, outpatient behavioral health, can all be trained in to utilize," she says.
Correction July 11, 2018
A previous version of this story misspelled Julie Goldstein Grumet's last name as Gromit.