The Shape We're In : Blog Of The Nation Why do celebrities have to have a side dish of self hatred with their diet struggles?
NPR logo The Shape We're In

The Shape We're In

Oprah Winfrey arrives at the 17th Annual Women In Entertainment Power 100 Breakfast. (Power, not, dress size, being the operative word.) Source: Katy Winn/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption
Source: Katy Winn/Getty Images

People Magazine has a "Body Watch." Among E!'s Original Countdowns are 30 Best & Worst Beach Bodies, 20 Best and Worst Celebrity Plastic Surgery Stories, and Incredible Celebrity Slimdowns. (Is "slimdown" a word?) Us has "Bump Watch." On the cover of People this week, Melissa Joan Hart is quoted calling herself "horrifying" at a post-pregnancy weight that many people would consider just fine. I won't even mention Oprah's shame-coaster. I know it's boring and annoying and shrill, but I just can't help but add my voice to the chorus of protests that accompanies the recent spate of celebrity diet-shaming. (Especially on a day when TOTN is spending some time on dieting in our first hour.) Everyone is entitled to their own feelings about their body — dysmorphic or no — but why must we self-flagellate with such vigor? Jan Hoffman, in the New York Times, writes a great analysis of the phenomenon, and explains the social capital a dieter may feel they're gaining, and why beating up on themselves is part of it.

Do you think we'll ever stop reducing ourselves to our size?