Economy Sends Mixed Signals On Recovery The U.S. economy continued to lose jobs in May, but at a slower pace than it has been, giving credence to the idea that the recession is nearing an end. Still, the unemployment rate climbed to 9.4 percent, and wage growth has slowed to a trickle.
NPR logo

Economy Sends Mixed Signals On Recovery

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Economy Sends Mixed Signals On Recovery

Economy Sends Mixed Signals On Recovery

Economy Sends Mixed Signals On Recovery

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

The U.S. economy continued to lose jobs in May, but at a slower pace than it has been, giving credence to the idea that the recession is nearing an end. Still, the unemployment rate climbed to 9.4 percent, and wage growth has slowed to a trickle.


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Melissa Block.


And I'm Robert Siegel.

It wasn't exactly good, but it was less bad. U.S. employers shed 345,000 jobs in May. The pace of layoffs slowed significantly. And that statistic may be a sign that the worst is over for the economy.

BLOCK: That optimism is also an indication of how serious the downturn is. In normal times, these numbers would be considered terrible. And, indeed, the unemployment rate jumped to its highest point in more than 25 years: 9.4 percent.

NPR's Jim Zarroli reports on how we can read the numbers released today.

JIM ZARROLI: The report to fix an economy in which jobs keep growing scarcer. Manufacturing lost more than 150,000 jobs, construction was down sharply. These are sectors that tend to employ a lot of men, so the adult male unemployment rate hit 10.5 percent. The U.S. economy has now lost six million jobs since the recession began a year and a half ago. Vice President Joe Biden spoke about the unemployment problem this morning.

Vice President JOE BIDEN: Behind every one of these job losses is a family, a individual who - a community that's trying to make it through the deepest recession in a decade, and are hurt.

ZARROLI: And the fine print in the report was even more discouraging. People are also working less than they used to. The length of the average work week fell to a little more than 33 hours - the lowest level since 1964. And the number of part-time workers who'd really like to find full-time work is rising. All of this suggests a labor market that remains anemic. People have trouble finding jobs, and they're often overqualified for the jobs they do find.

Heidi Shierholz is an economist at the Economic Policy Institute.

Dr. HEIDI SHIERHOLZ (Economist, Economic Policy Institute): We have a quote, unquote, "underemployment rate" of 16.4 percent. That's nearly one in six workers in the U.S. is either unemployed or underemployed. The state of the labor market, it's a real crisis right now.

ZARROLI: And Shierholz says the report contains some other disturbing news. She says that during the first year of the current recession, workers' wages tended to do pretty well. Now that's changed.

Dr. SHIERHOLZ: This year, wage growth has completely collapsed. It's now growing at about a third the rate as it was last year. Even people who are keeping their jobs during this recession are really feeling the effects of the downturn.

ZARROLI: Still, Shierholz says, there was some reason for optimism in the report. Over the past half a year, the economy has shed, on average, 600,000 jobs a month. Not only were job losses smaller than that last month, but the Labor Department said March and April losses were lower than first thought. Economist Joel Naroff says the slowdown in job losses is a positive sign.

Dr. JOEL NAROFF (Economist): While this report doesn't tell us that the recession is over, it tells us we're getting to that point where the bottom is in sight.

ZARROLI: Naroff pointed out that unemployment is a lagging indicator. Employers don't start hiring until they're really sure the economy has turned a corner. So the unemployment rate isn't going to start falling anytime soon.

Dr. NAROFF: It is going to rise till the end of, more than likely, till the end of this year. But job losses will slow, and as those job losses slow, it tells us that businesses are changing their perspective and the economy is indeed stabilizing.

ZARROLI: All that suggests that for the first time in months, the freefall in U.S. payrolls is over. And the day when businesses will start hiring again, no longer seems so far away. Still, the U.S. labor market has taken a beating and it will be a long time before it can climb out of the hole it's fallen into.

Jim Zarroli, NPR News, New York.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Jobless Rate Rises To 9.4 Percent, But Layoffs Slow

May unemployment reached 9.4 percent, its highest rate in a quarter century, but the number of job cuts was far less than economists had feared and the fewest since September, the Labor Department reported Friday.

The data followed a report the previous day in which the total number of continuing claims for unemployment benefits fell for the first time since January, a month that witnessed the largest job losses since 1949.

The Labor Department said employers cut 345,000 jobs in May. Since the start of the recession in December 2007, about 7 million people have lost their jobs and the total number of unemployed people stands at 14.5 million. The number of people who have been unemployed for over two years has tripled since the beginning of the recession.

The unemployment rate, up from 8.9 percent in April, was the highest since July 1983 and higher than the 9.2 percent economists had forecast. Actual job losses were considerably fewer than the 520,000 expected, but that was offset by larger-than-expected growth in the work force.

If laid-off workers who have given up looking for new jobs or have settled for part-time work are included, the unemployment rate would have been 16.4 percent in May, the highest on records dating to 1994.

March and April's job losses also were revised to show smaller declines than first reported.

Manufacturing Sector Still Hit Hard

Although the number of job cuts eased, steep losses were nonetheless felt in the manufacturing sector, while declines in construction and the service sectors moderated, Labor said.

Manufacturing shed 156,000 jobs for the month, including in motor vehicles and parts, machinery, and fabricated metal products. Unemployment in construction increased 59,000, concentrated in specialty trade contracting and residential construction. Retail trade was also down 18,000 jobs.

Education, health care, leisure and hospitality industries all added jobs in May.

Unemployment is considered a lagging indicator of economic health, and job cuts could still increase even as the broader economy rebounds.

Shortly after the numbers were released on Friday, White House economic adviser Christina Romer emphasized that point, saying "the unemployment rate is going to be high and probably stay high for a while, precisely because that is sort of the normal pattern as we come out of recession."

The Federal Reserve forecasts that unemployment will remain high into 2011, given an expectation of tepid recovery. Economists say the job market may not return to a 5 percent unemployment rate until 2013.

Signs Of A Recovery?

The numbers join fresh signs emerging earlier this week that the economy could be recovering.

The number of people continuing to draw unemployment benefits dipped for the first time in 20 weeks, and first-time claims also fell. Manufacturing's slide is slowing. Builders are boosting spending on construction projects, and a barometer of home sales firmed.

Although shoppers remain cautious according to sales results from major retailers, Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke and other economists are hopeful that consumers won't return to the deep hibernation seen at the end of last year.

That's when the recession hit with brutal force, causing the economy to contract at a 6.3 percent pace, the most in 25 years. Consumers cut their spending at the time by the most in nearly three decades. Economic activity shrank at a 5.7 percent pace in the first three months of this year, despite a rebound by consumers.

Many analysts believe the economy is shrinking at about a 2 percent pace in the current quarter, and that the economy could return to growth as soon as the third quarter. President Obama's stimulus package should help bolster the economy.

Ripple effects from General Motors Corp.'s filing for bankruptcy protection — the fourth-largest in U.S. history — could muddy the outlook, some analysts said. GM said earlier this week it will close nine factories and idle three others indefinitely as part of its restructuring. The closings, which will take place through the end of 2010, will cost up to 20,000 workers their jobs.

From NPR staff and wire service reports