Jobs Data Boosts Recovery Hopes The Labor Department said Friday the number of Americans who lost their jobs in November was fewer than expected. The jobless rate fell from 10.2 percent to 10 percent, raising hopes the economy is on the mend.
NPR logo

Jobs Data Boosts Recovery Hopes

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Jobs Data Boosts Recovery Hopes

Jobs Data Boosts Recovery Hopes

Jobs Data Boosts Recovery Hopes

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

The Labor Department said Friday the number of Americans who lost their jobs in November was fewer than expected. The jobless rate fell from 10.2 percent to 10 percent, raising hopes the economy is on the mend.


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Michele Norris.


And I'm Melissa Block.

Today, there was good and surprising news on the employment front. According to the government, the economy shed just 11,000 jobs in November, far fewer than expected. And the unemployment rate edged down from 10.2 percent to exactly 10 percent. But analysts say the nation's job troubles are not over.

NPR's Frank Langfitt explains.

FRANK LANGFITT: When the Bureau of Labor Statistics released its jobs numbers this morning, economists were delighted.

Dr. HEIDI SHERHOLZ (Economist, Economic Policy Institute): I was surprised and, you know, I've gradually sort of relaxed into happiness about it.

Mr. JOHN SYLVIA (Chief Economist, Well Fargo): The panic is over in terms of the job market.

Mr. DAVID WEISS (Chief Economist, Standard & Poor's): This was a much stronger employment report than we were expecting.

LANGFITT: That was Heidi Sherholz of the Economic Policy Institute, John Sylvia with Wells Fargo, and David Weiss of Standard & Poor's. In the previous three months, job losses had averaged over 130,000. So, even President Obama was surprised the November figure was so low. Christina Romer, the White House's chief economist, described their exchange.

Ms. CHRISTINA ROMER (Chief Economic Adviser, Obama Administration): When I told the president, he said, you mean a 111,000 job loss. I said, no, it's 11.

LANGFITT: Beyond the headline figure, the report contained other encouraging data. Heidi Sherholz noted that businesses gave workers more hours.

Dr. SHERHOLZ: That is a really crucial signal because what we know is that employers will restore the hours of the work force they have before they hire new workers.

LANGFITT: Temporary employment, another leading indicator of job growth, rose by more than 50,000. David Weiss says one reason job losses are ebbing is because consumers are a bit more optimistic.

Mr. WEISS: Some of this is psychological. The people panic in the beginning of a downturn. We certainly saw that six months ago. Everybody was convinced the world was coming to an end. When they realized that it wasn't, they're out there a little more confident in spending again. But there's also a natural cycle here. You can only run inventories down so far before you got to start producing again. It's the old analogy that, you know, eventually you've got to replace the light bulb and that requires going to the store and buying something.

LANGFITT: The employment numbers are a shot in the arm to the White House. Republicans have criticized President Obama over the dreadful jobs picture. And just yesterday, the White House held a summit to address the unemployment problem. At a town hall meeting in Allentown, Pennsylvania, today, the president touted the November numbers.

President BARACK OBAMA: So, overall, this is the best jobs report that we've seen since 2007.

LANGFITT: Then he tempered it with realism.

Pres. OBAMA: But I do want to keep this in perspective. We've still got a long way to go. I consider one job lost, one job to many.

LANGFITT: The job market has a very long way to go. Since the recession began two years ago, more than seven million jobs have disappeared. Sectors such as manufacturing and construction continue to shrink, and it's taking longer and longer for unemployed people to find new work. Even when jobs begin to grow again, economists expect the unemployment rate will increase. Heidi Sherholz says that's because at first monthly job gains just won't be enough to absorb new workers.

Dr. SHERHOLZ: The population is growing all the time. New babies are being born. There's new graduates being minted. So, unless we're adding roughly 127,000 jobs, the unemployment rate will rise.

LANGFITT: Sherholz says she doesn't expect the job market to really start growing until spring or summer of next year.

Frank Langfitt, NPR News, Washington.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Unemployment Rate Raises Hope, Doubt

Veterans and family members line up Nov. 23 to attend a career fair at the Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum in New York City. Mario Tama/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption
Mario Tama/Getty Images

Veterans and family members line up Nov. 23 to attend a career fair at the Intrepid Sea, Air & Space Museum in New York City.

Mario Tama/Getty Images

Friday's better-than-expected unemployment report could be positive news for holiday retail sales, but some economists say the jobless rate could still go higher.

The Labor Department reported Friday that the nation's unemployment rate fell to 10 percent in November, and employers cut just 11,000 jobs -- fewer than at any time since the start of the recession. The figure represents a decline from October's 10.2 percent, which set a 26-year high. The department also said that 159,000 fewer jobs were lost in September and October than previously reported.

Heard On All Things Considered

President Obama, speaking in Allentown, Pa., called it the "best jobs report we've seen since 2007."

"This is good news, just in time for the season of hope," he said. "But I want to keep this in perspective. We still have a long way to go."

Christina Romer, the chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, said the report is "the most hopeful sign yet ... of improvement in the labor market."

"It is by far the closest we have been to stable employment since the recession began almost two years ago," she said.

November's unemployment decline was a surprise to most economists, who predicted it would hold steady for the month. The data were the strongest since December 2007, the official start of the recession, the last time payrolls have seen an increase.

"The decline in the unemployment rate, the loss of jobs at a much slower pace than we'd expected, were big, big surprises and should be positive news not only for the Obama administration but also the financial markets generally," Hugh Johnson, an analyst with Johnson Illington Advisors, told NPR.

Stock prices surged in early trading following the release of the jobs numbers. At midmorning, the Dow Jones industrial average was up 120 points, a little more than 1 percent, to 10,484.84, and the S&P 500 stock index was up 14 points, 1.3 percent, to 1,114.

Behind November's Numbers

A Positive Trend The loss of just 11,000 jobs in November is far below the average of 135,000 shed in each of the previous three months. It's an even more dramatic plunge from the 600,000 to 700,000 monthly losses last winter.

Still Double Digits The unemployment rate retreated to 10 percent from a 26-year high 10.2 percent in October. But that's more than double the 4.9 percent rate when the recession began.

Winners And Losers Jobs increased in these sectors: Professional and business services (up 86,000, including about 52,000 temporary jobs), education and health services (up 40,000) and government (up 7,000). But these areas fell: Manufacturing (down 41,000), construction (down 27,000), and leisure and hospitality (down 11,000).

Temps Grow Much of the November payroll increase came in the form of temporary jobs. "It's good news as a leading indicator, because the first thing that firms usually do when they need help [is] if they're not sure that they want to hire permanent staff onto their payroll, they use more temps," said Nigel Gault, an economist at IHS Global Insight.

Long-Term Unemployment But those out of work for more than six months rose by 293,000, to 5.9 million.

A Deep Hole Economists say the unemployment rate is likely to rise again as people who had given up looking start searching for work again. The job market has a lot of ground to make up. Since the recession began, payroll employment has dropped by 7.2 million.

—Avie Schneider and Tamara Keith

Manufacturing Demand Picks Up

The positive economic news did not stop with the jobs report. Orders to U.S. factories unexpectedly rose in October, the sixth gain in the past seven months, the Commerce Department said Friday.

Orders rose 0.6 percent in October, much better than the flat reading that economists had expected. A jump in demand for commercial aircraft and petroleum products led the gain.

Orders for durable goods, items expected to last three years, climbed 0.6 percent. Orders for nondurable goods rose 1.6 percent, propelled by gains in demand for petroleum, chemicals, plastics and food.

The professional and business services sectors added 86,000 jobs -- including 52,400 temporary positions, while the service sector increased payrolls by 58,000 and health services added 40,000 jobs. The construction sector, hard hit by the residential and commercial real estate slump, shed 27,000 jobs.

Will Temporary Jobs Turn Permanent?

Economists generally believe that an increase in temporary jobs is a precursor to adding more permanent slots.

"If you look at the details of the report, business is getting better. And although employers are hiring permanent workers yet, they are still trying to meet that demand by hiring temporary help," Johnson said.

"Sooner or later … those temporary jobs will become permanent jobs," he said.

Analysts also predict employers will increase hours for existing employees before hiring new ones. November saw the average workweek extended to 33.2 hours from a record low of 33 hours in October.

The positive economic news comes a day after Obama hosted a jobs summit at the White House, where he told economists, business executives and union leaders that he is "open to every demonstrably good idea" to create jobs. Obama is also scheduled to deliver a speech on the economy Tuesday morning.

Democrats in Congress are also considering a $100 billion extension to unemployment benefits for those workers who are about to see them run out.

Alan Levenson, chief economist at T. Rowe Price in Baltimore, said the unemployment rate is unlikely to firm up a downward trend until the economy is adding about 110,000 jobs a month.

"I think the unemployment rate is going to drift up again next year," he said.

Part of that is due to the fact that more people have given up looking for work. The size of the labor force, which includes the employed and those actively searching for jobs, fell by nearly 100,000, the third straight decline.

Hope For The Holidays

But the psychological value of a dip in unemployment could help bolster holiday retail sales, as Americans become a bit less concerned about losing their jobs, said Brian Wesbury, chief economist with First Trust in Chicago.

"I look for better than consensus, better-than-expected holiday shopping," he told NPR. "If you look back at this past year, it's clear that people held back and their savings went up. As a result, there's a lot of dry powder, so to speak, on the sidelines."

But tight credit remains a concern, and Obama on Friday prodded banks to increase lending, reminding them of the $700 billion government bailout of the financial industry.

"The taxpayers were there for you to clean up your mistakes," he said at his appearance in Pennsylvania. "You now have a responsibility to be there for the community."

From NPR staff and wire reports