Rep. Reyes: CIA 'Deliberately Lied' To Intel Panel The CIA last week launched a review of how it briefs key members of Congress after House Democrats complained that the CIA has been misleading lawmakers for the past eight years. Silvestre Reyes, chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, says his committee was "deliberately lied to."
NPR logo

Rep. Reyes: CIA 'Deliberately Lied' To Intel Panel

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Rep. Reyes: CIA 'Deliberately Lied' To Intel Panel

Rep. Reyes: CIA 'Deliberately Lied' To Intel Panel

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

GUY RAZ, host:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Guy Raz.

We start today with a delicate dance between Congress and the CIA about secrecy. This week the CIA launched a review of how it briefs key members of Congress. That came after House Democrats complained the CIA has been misleading Congress for the past eight years.

Late last month, CIA Director Leon Panetta held a closed-door session with members of the House Intelligence Committee. In that meeting, he revealed details of a secret program that had been, up to that point, concealed from Congress, a potential violation of the National Security Act. Panetta immediately ended that program.

Now, details of that program have not been released. Some Republicans say the revelation is no big deal; that Democrats are playing politics.

Well, on the line is a man who might be able to clear the air: Democrat Silvestre Reyes. He chairs the House Intelligence Committee.

Congressman, welcome to the show.

Representative SILVESTRE REYES (Democrat, Texas; Chairman, House Intelligence Committee): Thanks, Guy. It's good to be with you today.

RAZ: Let's start with exactly what was concealed from you and others on the committee. What can you tell us about the program?

Rep. REYES: Well, unfortunately the work that we do precludes me from going into any kind of detail. What I can tell you is that this was a very highly classified program that had been in place since right after the attacks of 9/11 and involved a worldwide effort. It's a very serious program. I know my Republican colleagues have tried to minimize it but it is a highly classified program that has very serious international implications. For those that are wondering whether or not it would be, all you got to consider is the fact that as soon as Director Panetta found out about this program, he cancelled it and then I think within less than 24 hours he was in front of our committee giving us the full scale of information.

RAZ: Well, Congressman, Speaker Pelosi issued a lot of heat for comments back in May that she was misled by the CIA on waterboarding back in 2002. In some ways, do the allegations you're now making support her claim?

Rep. REYES: There's no way that I or anybody else have any way to know what the issues were when she was briefed. She has given her side. Director Panetta put out a press statement saying that it is not the policy of the CIA to mislead Congress.

RAZ: Mm-hmm.

Rep. REYES: But that doesn't mean that that hasn't occurred. And since those attacks on the speaker were made in early May, we have, in our committee, come up with a number of instances where we were not given the full and complete information. In some cases information was kept from the committee, and in at least one instance we were deliberately lied to.

RAZ: Deliberately lied to. That's a very serious charge.

Rep. REYES: It is.

RAZ: Do you believe that in this case the CIA violated the National Security Act, the law that requires them to brief certain members of Congress on significant intelligence activities?

Rep. REYES: Well, I've been on this committee, this is my ninth year. We have been very vocal in complaining about information that has not been provided to the committee. This latest one is certainly not the only one that we were not told about.

RAZ: So I mean, so in a sense they did violate the National Security Act?

Rep. REYES: In my opinion, numerous times.

RAZ: So, are you saying - I mean, are you essentially saying that there has been a pattern of the CIA misleading your committee for several years; this is just the latest example, and it certainly gives credence to Speaker Pelosi's argument?

Rep. REYES: Obviously, I'm going to let people make up their own mind. But I will tell you this: certainly an argument can be made that this has been a pattern under the previous administration. We want to fix that. And then secondly, I think when the facts come out, people will be able to make up their own minds. Whatever viewpoint you have politically, you'll be able to say: yes, the committees of jurisdiction have a right to be concerned about not getting the information.

RAZ: There are some in CIA who argue that this is just another example of why they shouldn't have to brief Congress on every single program that they implement because essentially, Congress leaks information.

Rep. REYES: You know what? That is such a bogus argument. Let me give you a real example of something that occurred since I've been chairman of the committee. And that was we were given information by the previous administration that restricted it to the gang of eight, the two chairs, the two ranking members, and the two leaders on each side of the Capitol. And then subsequent to that, we found out that on the administration side, well over a thousand people had the same information.

So, people can make up their own mind. Where is it likely to leak? That is a bogus argument. Again, it's about getting the information that's essential, so that we can do the job of oversight, and that's really the bottom line.

RAZ: Congressman Silvestre Reyes is chairman of the House Intelligence Committee. He joined us from his home in El Paso, Texas.

Mr. Reyes, that's so much.

Rep. REYES: Thank you, Guy. And I appreciate the opportunity to comment on that.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.