Cash For Seniors Proposal Touches Off Dispute A White House proposal to give every Social Security recipient a check for $250 next year has provoked a debate over whether seniors really should be given the extra help. Critics say the proposal will just run up the deficit, while others say seniors need help to counter things like rising health care costs.
NPR logo

Cash For Seniors Proposal Touches Off Dispute

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Cash For Seniors Proposal Touches Off Dispute

Cash For Seniors Proposal Touches Off Dispute

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Last week, we told you about the White House proposal to give every Social Security recipient a check next year for $250. The idea is to make up for the fact that seniors will not get a cost-of-living adjustment. So what do seniors think? NPR's Larry Abramson has that story.

LARRY ABRAMSON: A drop in energy prices has helped drive inflation backwards. Prices are getting cheaper. That's good, right? No, that's bad because Social Security increases are tied to inflation. Lower prices means payouts will remain flat for the first time in decades, that's despite the fact that seniors are facing real increases in prices, according to AARP's Cristina Martin Firvida.

Ms. CRISTINA MARTIN FIRVIDA (Director of Economic Security, AARP): Health care, which is one thing that retirees buy in greater abundance than healthier younger workers, is something that is not going down in price and, in fact, continues to outpace inflation.

ABRAMSON: Just ask Sonja Asher of Minneapolis, a widow completely dependent on the $924 a month she gets from Social Security. Asher, who is 83, says energy prices may be down, but the costs of owning a home and a car are going up.

Ms. SONJA ASHER: House insurance, car insurance. Yes, it's not good. For gas, I mean, they seem to raise it according to the gas pump prices, and that's not the whole cost of a car for sure.

ABRAMSON: Nevertheless, members of Congress have proposed about a three percent cost-of-living increase. Jim Horney of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities says such an increase would fly in the face of the 1975 law that instituted regular cost-of-living increases for Social Security.

Mr. JIM HORNEY (Director of Federal Fiscal Policy, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities): I think that would be a bad precedent, and that's why we recommend that you don't provide a cost of living in this situation, where the cost of living hasn't gone up.

ABRAMSON: Horney does like the president's idea of a one-time cash payment, but deficit hawks like Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute say there is no justification for giving seniors special treatment right now.

Mr. CHRIS EDWARDS (Tax Policy Director, Cato Institute): Most people are not getting wage increases this year. So, you know, for example, young families with children, I mean, you know, nanny care and that sort of thing are rising, and yet we don't jump out and give them a special payment.

ABRAMSON: AARP's Cristina Martin Firvida says, in fact, seniors are facing special hardships because their housing values and retirement accounts have crashed in value.

Ms. FIRVIDA: What they do not have is the luxury of time to see the value of those investments, of their home, come back.

ABRAMSON: One problem is that this proposal treats 50 million seniors as a homogenous group, but the stories seniors tell show just how individual their needs are.

Noreen Martin is 92 and lives in Brighton Gardens, an assisted living facility near Washington, D.C. She feels that prices of things that matter to her are climbing.

Ms. NOREEN MARTIN: Nearly two bucks for animal crackers? Please. I have a three-year-old, that's why I buy animal crackers.

(Soundbite of laughter)

ABRAMSON: A three-year-old great-granddaughter. But Noreen Martin has other income besides Social Security, and she lives in a comfortable high-rise. She says the proposal to give every senior a payout doesn't make sense.

Ms. MARTIN: I don't need $250, I mean, right now. If the market goes down again, I'll take it happily, but I don't need it. I think there should be a cutoff point.

ABRAMSON: Martin says she would probably not spend the money. She would just give it to her children, and that might help them pay for a proposal that could add more than $13 billion to the deficit.

Larry Abramson, NPR News.

(Soundbite of music)


You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.