MELISSA BLOCK, Host:
Unidentified Man #3: (Singing) It sucks to be me...
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
JEFF LUNDEN: Producer Kevin McCollum says it doesn't suck to be him. His show, "Avenue Q," has found new life and new audiences off-Broadway.
KEVIN MCCOLLUM: How do you have a hit musical off- Broadway? You go to Broadway for six years, you win the Tony Award, is how you have a hit off-Broadway.
LUNDEN: "Avenue Q," the intimate satirical adult puppet show closed after a Broadway run of over 2,500 performances last September. McCollum and his partners then made the surprising announcement that they were going to move the production a few blocks away to a 499-seat theater off Broadway. It may be only a five-minute walk from "Avenue Q's" old theater to its new home, but McCollum says the savings are tremendous - from theater rent to advertising to salaries to smaller stage crews. And he says the budget isn't hindered by some of Broadway's built-in union rules.
MCCOLLUM: One of the things about our new theater is we don't have some of the Broadway work rules that says if you do work, you have to pay at least four hours for something that only take 30 minutes.
LUNDEN: That got some other producers talking, like Harriet Leve, whose four-actor stage version of Alfred Hitchcock's "The 39 Steps" just finished a very successful two-year run on Broadway.
HARRIET LEVE: With the running costs being sliced in half, you really didn't have to do too much thinking to figure out, yes, we should do this.
LUNDEN: Both shows have been able to recycle their Broadway sets and costumes, but Leve says there's another advantage to seeing "The 39 Steps" in a smaller theater.
LEVE: Unidentified Man #4: Excuse me. I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
(SOUNDBITE OF PLAY, "THE 39 STEPS")
LUNDEN: And smaller theaters means smaller ticket prices.
LEVE: On Broadway, it was about 116, and our top ticket price is about 89.50, so there's a difference.
LUNDEN: Gordon Cox, theater reporter for Variety, says until recently shows like "Avenue Q," which began life at the tiny Vineyard Theater off-Broadway, would have never moved to Broadway in the first place. Since upsizing shows for Broadway has been a trend, downsizing could become a trend as well.
GORDON COX: Small, quirky shows that in past years would have seemed a natural for off-Broadway, now that they are becoming more common on Broadway, this can open the door to them thinking about downsizing again.
LUNDEN: Producer Kevin McCollum says audiences have rediscovered "Avenue Q" off-Broadway only because the show's brand was built by its long Broadway run and Tony Award wins.
MCCOLLUM: If "Avenue Q" had stayed off-Broadway from the very beginning, we would have been closed by now.
LUNDEN: For NPR News, I'm Jeff Lunden in New York.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.