U.S., Allies Slowly Launch Effort To Tame Kandahar Thousands of U.S. troops are heading into southern Afghanistan for what is being called the most important operation of the nine-year war. A tough battle in Kandahar — against Taliban militants as well as corruption, incompetence and lack of governance — lies ahead.
NPR logo

U.S., Allies Slowly Launch Effort To Tame Kandahar

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/127770428/127770667" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
U.S., Allies Slowly Launch Effort To Tame Kandahar

U.S., Allies Slowly Launch Effort To Tame Kandahar

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/127770428/127770667" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.


Thousands of American troops are heading to southern Afghanistan, specifically to Kandahar, to bring stability to the country's second- largest city and the birthplace of the Taliban. How well that mission goes could determine when and how many U.S. troops begin coming home.

SIEGEL: In the first of his reports, Tom Bowman tours Kandahar with one of the top American generals there to gauge the fight ahead.

TOM BOWMAN: Brigadier General Ben Hodges hops out of his armored vehicle. He's in downtown Kandahar, a honeycomb of low concrete buildings that stretch to the hazy horizon. It's sprawling, just like Los Angeles without the skyscrapers.

SIEGEL: Taliban assassinations and intimidation and a lot of common crime. It's a lawless atmosphere of power brokers and their gunmen vying for dominance.

BEN HODGES: Kandahar really is Dodge City. There's not as much open shooting as you would see in Dodge City.


BOWMAN: Hodges is a deputy American commander here. He's got a mischievous grin and that drawl is from his native Tallahassee.

HODGES: I think it probably was what Denver must have been like in the mid-1800s, in terms of people trying to grab what they could.

BOWMAN: Here in Kandahar city, Hodges is looking for a place to house Afghan government workers. Without them, there's no functioning government.

HODGES: If you want to get, you know, skilled employees, you've to give them a, you know, a decent place to live that's relatively secure.

BOWMAN: Which is why Hodges meets with NATO troops here who aren't chasing Taliban, but are rebuilding a compound of abandoned concrete houses. Hodges goes inside.


BOWMAN: It's littered with broken glass and dangling electrical cord. A Canadian army engineer, Lieutenant Colonel Jenny Carignan, tells Hodges about fixing up the compound.

JENNY CARIGNAN: Should be starting sometime in July but we're looking at aesthetics work, so, resurfacing, painting, windows and electrical, obviously, and plumbing.

BOWMAN: Hodges jokes with an Afghan police commander about how much space the man would need for his family.

HODGES: Yeah, but you've got, like, 20 children. I don't think - you would need two compounds.


BOWMAN: For all the laughter, the police are part of the problem here. There's petty corruption and incompetence and little leadership. So, across town there's more construction going on.


BOWMAN: The Americans building a new barracks to house the Afghan National Police.


HODGES: Unidentified Man: Pretty good. How are you doing?

BOWMAN: Hodges is joined on the tour by Kandahar's police chief. His name is Sardar Mohammad Zazai, and he's seen as ineffective and unwilling to address corruption.

SARDAR MOHAMMAD ZAZAI: (Through translator) I don't deny that there used to be a lot of corruption, but since I started here work, it's reduced the level of corruption, and we are still working on that process.

BOWMAN: General Hodges' convoy moves on through the city like a long line of elephants. There's a sense of normalcy, despite the city's reputation. Shops are open. Traffic is heavy. Families walk along the sidewalks and watch the military convoy. Hodges stops at an abandoned hotel surrounded by vacant lots.

HODGES: This is a hotel, huh?

BOWMAN: He planned to rent the building to house new police recruits expected to pay $4,000 a month in rent. That's not going to happen. The owner walks over and tells Hodges he's already rented the place for $10,000 to another American government agency. The owner of the building's name? Karzai.


JONATHAN VANCE: Are you related to President Karzai?

KARZAI: He's my cousin.

VANCE: Big family.


BOWMAN: That's another problem. The Karzai family has a tight grip on Kandahar. The president's brother, Ahmed Wali Karzai, is head of the provincial council and the biggest powerbroker in town. He's also accused of stealing public and private land, and providing support to drug traffickers. Most officials here steer away from even talking about him.

VANCE: Yeah, you're on very sensitive ground there, I got to tell you.

BOWMAN: Canadian Brigadier General Jonathan Vance commands U.S. and allied forces around Kandahar.

VANCE: He has great capacity to do things that we need. But if you're in a country that has been in peril for so long, any powerful person, your capacity to survive is pretty good and the methods of that survival sometimes don't pass the sniff test.

BOWMAN: The corruption is made worse by the hundreds of millions of dollars being spent by the Americans here on everything from rental housing and trucking to construction and security. The U.S. is struggling to find a way to spread that wealth so a few powerbrokers don't grab it all. But there's no good solution yet.


BOWMAN: The helicopter lands at Forward Operating Base Wilson, a jumble of tents and newly constructed plywood buildings.


BOWMAN: Inside the military operations center, Hodges and a few other officers unfold a map, showing where the American and Afghan soldiers will operate in Zhari.

NICK CARTER: There will be 3,000 people in here?


CARTER: Five? Five thousand.

BOWMAN: One of the officers is British Major General Nick Carter, commander of all U.S. and allied forces in the south. To win Kandahar, the allies must root the Taliban from Zhari.

CARTER: I think it's still the case that the insurgency has got a significant amount of freedom of movement in Zhari, and that's inevitable given that we haven't really had much of a presence here for last few years.

BOWMAN: But how do they measure success? How will they know if it's working or not? General Carter says the big test is not how many Taliban they kill. It's whether the local meetings called shuras are well represented.

CARTER: That'll give you a sense of whether you're being successful or not because when it's not representative, it probably means the security situation is not ideal...

BOWMAN: They're afraid to come to shuras.

CARTER: And they're intimidated, and they don't have freedom of movement.

BOWMAN: But Carter says Afghans want more than just a meeting.

CARTER: I mean, they want to be able to educate their children. They want access to basic health care. They don't really want a lot of central government. But they do want access to the capacity of government to solve their problems.

BOWMAN: That's one of the most important unanswered questions: Will the government of President Hamid Karzai do its part? Hodges ponders that question back at the base.

HODGES: We can't force them to do that. Don't want to force them to do that, and frankly, you know, the Afghans will come up with a better solution than Hodges could ever come up with. But we got to create the space for them to be able to do that.

BOWMAN: Tom Bowman, NPR News, Kandahar, Afghanistan.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.